Sun, Jul 31, 2016 - Page 8 News List

Taipei Watcher: Could Taiwan be a little more gay?

Taiwan is listed 34 on the global Gay Happiness Index (GHI) for gay men, but there is still room for improvement

By Eddy Chang  /  Staff reporter

Two gay men kiss each other after finishing the registration process at a household registration office in Taichung on Oct. 1 last year on the first day of the city’s adoption of the new registration policy for same-sex couples.

Photo: Su Meng-chuan, Taipei Times

In May, PlanetRomeo, an online community and gay dating service for men, released its Gay Happiness Index (GHI) for gay men. Iceland topped the index with a score of 79 out of 100, while other Nordic countries Norway (77) and Denmark (76) took the second and third spot.

The index ranks countries on three criteria: public opinion, public behavior and life satisfaction. Uganda (20) at 127 was the unhappiest country for gay men. Taiwan (54) was listed 34 on the index, but there is still room for improvement.

Among Asian nations, the top three were Israel (71) at seven, Thailand (67) at 16 and then Taiwan. China (41) placed 63 on the index, which was slightly lower than South Korea (43) at 57 and one spot higher than Singapore (41) at 64.


Of the index’s three criteria, “public opinion” measures how gay men feel about society’s view on homosexuality, such as whether their country’s laws are positive (or negative) and whether they would kiss or hold hands with another man in public. Taiwan scored 45 points out of 100.

The “public behavior” category measures how gay men experience the way they are treated — family and workplace discrimination, for example, or verbal or physical abuse. Taiwan scored 63 points in this category.

How satisfied gay men are with their lives and whether they accept themselves, including whether they have or intend to move or change jobs on account of their sexual orientation, is measured by “life satisfaction.” Taiwan scored 55 points in this category.

These results show that there is room for improvement before lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) people obtain a high degree of life satisfaction.

“The GHI ranking correlates with the scale of democratic societies and freedom to autocratic countries and human rights violations,” the company says. “The GHI is not only about the happiness of gay men, it can also be seen as a powerful indicator for the general development of freedom, justice and security in a country.”

The company adds that low-ranking countries “are known for having a negative view towards basic human freedoms in society.”


The situation facing LGBT people in Taiwan has gradually improved. Ever since Kaohsiung launched its “sunshine registration” (陽光註記) policy to allow semi-official registration of same-sex couples at its household registration offices in May last year, many of the nation’s cities and counties have followed suit.

Over the past year, all six municipalities — Taipei, New Taipei City, Taoyuan, Taichung, Tainan and Kaohsiung — as well as Chiayi City, Changhua County, Hsinchu County and Yilan County have adopted the registration policy, which accounts for 79.8 percent of the nation’s total population. This actually gives registered gay couples some of the rights enjoyed by married heterosexual couples, including being allowed to make certain medical decisions and sign formal documents for their partners.

President Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) promised to protect LGBT people’s equal rights in the lead up to the elections in January. Unfortunately, Tsai changed her position three months after being elected, stating that the legalization of same-sex marriage has to be based on “the blessing of the whole society” (整體社會的祝福).

Although the local governments have moved in a progressive direction, the central government has failed to put the LGBT issue on its legislative priority list, borrowing the previous government’s talking point that society has to reach a “consensus” on the issue before amending the law. What “consensus” does her administration need before taking action, and how many more years will the delay continue? Its determination to protect LGBT people’s human rights seems questionable.

Comments will be moderated. Keep comments relevant to the article. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned. Final decision will be at the discretion of the Taipei Times.

TOP top