The Judicial Yuan on Saturday said draft amendments to the Constitutional Court Procedure Act (憲法訴訟法) proposed by Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Legislator Weng Hsiao-ling (翁曉玲) could harm people’s right to seek constitutional relief.
Weng yesterday said the Judicial Yuan misinterpreted her draft.
The exchanges were made ahead of the draft’s review at the legislature’s Judiciary and Organic Laws and Statutes Committee today.
Photo: Liao Chen-huei, Taipei Times
The Judicial Yuan said Weng’s proposed amendments to Article 4 of the act might virtually cripple the authority of grand justices to interpret the Constitution.
Weng in the previous legislative session drafted an amendment specifying that “the total number of incumbent grand justices” referred to in the act is defined as “15” as stipulated in Article 5 of Additional Articles of the Constitution of the Republic of China (中華民國憲法增修條文).
In the current legislative session, she motioned another proposal to the act, which would raise the threshold for passing a ruling of constitutional interpretation from a simple majority to two-thirds of the judges.
That means it would require a quorum of at least 10 grand justices attending constitutional interpretation proceedings and at least seven agreeing on the ruling to make a judgement, if both draft amendments are passed by the legislature, the Judicial Yuan said.
Grand justices must be nominated by the president and approved by the Legislative Yuan to be sworn in and perform their duties, it said.
However, there are no mechanisms to extend an incumbent justice’s term or to offer a temporary appointment, it said, adding that a vacancy arises when a justice resigns or passes away.
The grand justices would in practice be unable to initiate constitutional interpretation proceedings and pass a ruling if the incumbent personnel are fewer than 10 people, especially when the nomination and legislative review process is delayed, according to the draft amendments, it said.
It also cited Article 12 of the Constitutional Court Procedure Act as specifying that grand justices recusing themselves from a case in accordance with the act “will not count towards the total number of incumbent justices.”
That means when grand justices refrain from a constitutional interpretation process due to disqualification reasons, those taking part in the proceedings and ruling would inevitably be fewer than 15 people, clashing with the draft amendments, it said.
The Constitution is fundamental to protecting basic human rights and grand justices are the sole authority with a universal binding force to conduct constitutional review, it said.
However, the increased threshold for initiating a procedure and passing a ruling would be no better than depriving grand justices of their authority to perform constitutional duties, seriously affecting people’s right to seek a constitutional interpretation, it said.
The draft amendments would also deny the possibility for constitutional agencies to resolve constitutional disputes through judicial review and thus damage judicial credibility, it said, suggesting that the draft bill not be passed.
Weng in response said that the Judicial Yuan misrepresented her proposal.
The total number of incumbent grand justices should be 15, she said.
However, if there are only 10 of the 15 justices left for a case due to the disqualification of the other five, then the quorum of a two-thirds majority would be calculated based on 10, Weng said.
Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Chairman Eric Chu (朱立倫) yesterday supported Weng’s proposal.
Passing a constitutional amendment requires a three-quarters majority of the legislature, and most important bills require a two-quarters or three-fourths majority, Chu said.
“How is it reasonable that the passage of a constitutional interpretation ruling by grand justices only requires a majority of more than half?” he asked.
Additional reporting by Liu Wan-ling and Shih Hsiao-kuang
Kenting National Park service technician Yang Jien-fon (楊政峰) won a silver award in World Grand Prix Photography Awards Spring Season for his photograph of two male rat snakes intertwined in combat. Yang’s colleagues at Kenting National Park said he is a master of nature photography who has been held back by his job in civil service. The awards accept entries in all four seasons across six categories: architectural and urban photography, black-and-white and fine art photography, commercial and fashion photography, documentary and people photography, nature and experimental photography, and mobile photography. Awards are ranked according to scores and divided into platinum, gold and
More than half of the bamboo vipers captured in Tainan in the past few years were found in the city’s Sinhua District (新化), while other districts had smaller catches or none at all. Every year, Tainan captures about 6,000 snakes which have made their way into people’s homes. Of the six major venomous snakes in Taiwan, the cobra, the many-banded krait, the brown-spotted pit viper and the bamboo viper are the most frequently captured. The high concentration of bamboo vipers captured in Sinhua District is puzzling. Tainan Agriculture Bureau Forestry and Nature Conservation Division head Chu Chien-ming (朱健明) earlier this week said that the
The first bluefin tuna of the season, brought to shore in Pingtung County and weighing 190kg, was yesterday auctioned for NT$10,600 (US$333.5) per kilogram, setting a record high for the local market. The auction was held at the fish market in Donggang Fishing Harbor, where the Siaoliouciou Island-registered fishing vessel Fu Yu Ching No. 2 delivered the “Pingtung First Tuna” it had caught for bidding. Bidding was intense, and the tuna was ultimately jointly purchased by a local restaurant and a local company for NT$10,600 per kilogram — NT$300 ,more than last year — for a total of NT$2.014 million. The 67-year-old skipper
BREACH OF CONTRACT: The bus operators would seek compensation and have demanded that the manufacturer replace the chips with ones that meet regulations Two bus operators found to be using buses with China-made chips are to demand that the original manufacturers replace the systems and provide compensation for breach of contract, the Veterans Affairs Council said yesterday. Democratic Progressive Party Legislator Michelle Lin (林楚茵) yesterday said that Da Nan Bus Co and Shin-Shin Bus Co Ltd have fielded a total of 82 buses that are using Chinese chips. The bus models were made by Tron-E, while the systems provider was CYE Electronics, Lin said. Lin alleged that the buses were using chips manufactured by Huawei subsidiary HiSilicon Co, which presents a national security risk if the
RSS