When a UN report warned that Japan’s storied animation sector was in danger of potential collapse, you would be forgiven for thinking the cause was the rise of artificial intelligence (AI).
It was not. Low pay, excessive working hours and weak protections for people’s intellectual property (IP) rights had created “an environment ripe for exploitation,” the UN human rights body said last year. If the outlook was grim then, the proliferation of AI could prove existential.
Tokyo owes more to these artists. Even as Japan’s industrial might slipped during the so-called “lost decades,” their imagination and soul propeled the nation’s soft power and global influence. Dragon Ball, Pokemon and Studio Ghibli churned out internationally beloved storylines and characters. The government was arguably slow to appreciate or monetize this, but has since spent years trying to turn the nation’s creative works into a leading export — as powerful as any car or chip.
AI’s threat gives Japan a second chance to do right by the workers propping up the US$21 billion industry. Tokyo must move fast to bolster labor rights, protect IP, demand transparency and fairly compensate artists, or risk letting Silicon Valley write the rules as it goes.
The release of OpenAI’s Sora 2 video creator was the latest wake-up call. Users of the TikTok clone began quickly turning a beloved catalogue of anime characters into AI slop.
Japanese Representative Akihisa Shiozaki in a commentary said he was especially alarmed to see high-quality generations of Japanese icons — while Western figures such as Mickey Mouse or Superman were conspicuously absent.
Japan expressed its concerns to OpenAI, he said, apparently prompting OpenAI CEO Sam Altman to announce an update that gives rightsholders “more granular control” and praising the nation’s “remarkable creative output.”
Altman said they hoped to start a revenue sharing plan “soon.”
OpenAI’s swift response is a good first step, but tech giants should also pay for the creativity they have already exploited. While I was scrolling Sora 2 a few days ago, clips featuring Naruto, Doraemon, Totoro and many other anime favorites were abundant, even if my brief attempts to create new videos with some of them were refused. It is more than apparent that Japan’s cultural crown jewels were used to train the video generator that has the potential to be a big moneymaker for the tech giant.
The reach of Japan’s creative industry gives it an obligation to lead this global fight for the future of arts in the AI era. It can start by demanding transparency. Most leading tech companies have stopped sharing the details of the data used to train their models. The public deserves to know what goes into these systems — not just so rightsholders are aware if their work was used, but so researchers and policymakers can better understand how these tools shape the world around us.
As Bloomberg Opinion columnist Dave Lee said, companies pay for the chips that their machines need, they pay for the power to run them and for the labor of their engineers, “So why not pay for the work of human creators, without whom today’s AI models wouldn’t be worth a penny?”
Even amid periods of massive technological transformation, there are precedents for how to renumerate creatives, Lee said.
It is also clear that even before the rise of AI, Japan’s anime industry was overdue for a labor reckoning. Despite a boom globally, many creatives are living in poverty. Tokyo could fix this by empowering unions in a sector long resistant to organizing. This would not only help improve conditions, but also offer the artists a fighting chance to have a say in how their work is used by AI and how the technology can be deployed within their industry.
The 2023 Hollywood writers’ strike exposed how critical organized labor is for creative sectors and offers a precedent: Those employed in the field won the right to decide for themselves how and when AI is used, while still ensuring they would be compensated either way.
Automation can threaten artists’ livelihoods or be used responsibly to help fill gaping labor shortages. Collective bargaining agreements give workers a say in how this process ultimately unfolds.
In a news conference last month, a Japanese lawmaker overseeing IP strategy called anime and manga “irreplaceable treasures of our country.” AI tools are now capable of replicating, and even replacing, something that has made Japan a cultural powerhouse. The window for Tokyo to act is closing fast.
Catherine Thorbecke is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering Asia tech. Previously she was a tech reporter at CNN and ABC News.
“Si ambulat loquitur tetrissitatque sicut anas, anas est” is, in customary international law, the three-part test of anatine ambulation, articulation and tetrissitation. And it is essential to Taiwan’s existence. Apocryphally, it can be traced as far back as Suetonius (蘇埃托尼烏斯) in late first-century Rome. Alas, Suetonius was only talking about ducks (anas). But this self-evident principle was codified as a four-part test at the Montevideo Convention in 1934, to which the United States is a party. Article One: “The state as a person of international law should possess the following qualifications: a) a permanent population; b) a defined territory; c) government;
The central bank and the US Department of the Treasury on Friday issued a joint statement that both sides agreed to avoid currency manipulation and the use of exchange rates to gain a competitive advantage, and would only intervene in foreign-exchange markets to combat excess volatility and disorderly movements. The central bank also agreed to disclose its foreign-exchange intervention amounts quarterly rather than every six months, starting from next month. It emphasized that the joint statement is unrelated to tariff negotiations between Taipei and Washington, and that the US never requested the appreciation of the New Taiwan dollar during the
Since leaving office last year, former president Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) has been journeying across continents. Her ability to connect with international audiences and foster goodwill toward her country continues to enhance understanding of Taiwan. It is possible because she can now walk through doors in Europe that are closed to President William Lai (賴清德). Tsai last week gave a speech at the Berlin Freedom Conference, where, standing in front of civil society leaders, human rights advocates and political and business figures, she highlighted Taiwan’s indispensable global role and shared its experience as a model for democratic resilience against cognitive warfare and
The diplomatic spat between China and Japan over comments Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi made on Nov. 7 continues to worsen. Beijing is angry about Takaichi’s remarks that military force used against Taiwan by the Chinese People’s Liberation Army (PLA) could constitute a “survival-threatening situation” necessitating the involvement of the Japanese Self-Defense Forces. Rather than trying to reduce tensions, Beijing is looking to leverage the situation to its advantage in action and rhetoric. On Saturday last week, four armed China Coast Guard vessels sailed around the Japanese-controlled Diaoyutai Islands (釣魚台), known to Japan as the Senkakus. On Friday, in what
RSS