The Constitutional Court on Friday ruled unconstitutional the search and seizure of confidential messages shared between lawyers and their clients during a prosecutors’ investigation, and ordered that the law be amended within two years.
The ruling on Articles 122-2 and 133-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (刑事訴訟法) came after Lee and Li Attorneys-at-Law challenged the constitutionality of the clauses, when its Hsinchu branch office was raided and messages between staff and clients were seized by prosecutors in a 2011 litigation case.
The law firm said that the prosecutors’ actions had infringed on its right to keep communication with its clients confidential, especially as prosecutors at the time could not prove that the office had committed any wrongdoing to justify their search.
Photo: Taipei Times file
Under the two articles, the premises or properties of any third -party can be searched only if there is probable cause.
A seizure that is not covered by a search warrant must be adjudicated by a judge, except when the item is seized for evidence, the articles say.
The court’s ruling said that the articles fail to take into consideration the attorney-client privilege, which is a rule that protects the confidentiality of communication between lawyers and clients.
The content of the two articles works against Articles 15 and 16 of the Constitution, which stipulate that “the right of existence, the right of work and the right of property shall be guaranteed to the people,” and that “the people shall have the right of presenting petitions, lodging complaints or instituting legal proceedings,” the ruling said.
Agencies should amend the Code of Criminal Procedure within two years, the court said, adding that before the revision of the law is completed, judges and prosecutors should conduct searches and seizures in accordance with the intention of the judgement.
The number of search warrants issued by Taiwanese courts from 2020 to last year averaged nearly 15,000 per year, Constitutional Court head clerk Hsu Chen-chou (許辰舟) said.
During this three-year period, 20 law firms have been searched, of which 18 were due to lawyers having become criminal suspects or because they were involved in collusion to destroy evidence, Hsu said.
Three batches of banana sauce imported from the Philippines were intercepted at the border after they were found to contain the banned industrial dye Orange G, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) said yesterday. From today through Sept. 2 next year, all seasoning sauces from the Philippines are to be subject to the FDA’s strictest border inspection, meaning 100 percent testing for illegal dyes before entry is allowed, it said in a statement. Orange G is an industrial coloring agent that is not permitted for food use in Taiwan or internationally, said Cheng Wei-chih (鄭維智), head of the FDA’s Northern Center for
The Chinese military has built landing bridge ships designed to expand its amphibious options for a potential assault on Taiwan, but their combat effectiveness is limited due to their high vulnerability, a defense expert said in an analysis published on Monday. Shen Ming-shih (沈明室), a research fellow at the Institute for National Defense and Security Research, said that the deployment of such vessels as part of the Chinese People’s Liberation Army (PLA) Navy’s East Sea Fleet signals a strong focus on Taiwan. However, the ships are highly vulnerable to precision strikes, which means they could be destroyed before they achieve their intended
About 4.2 million tourist arrivals were recorded in the first half of this year, a 10 percent increase from the same period last year, the Tourism Administration said yesterday. The growth continues to be consistent, with the fourth quarter of this year expected to be the peak in Taiwan, the agency said, adding that it plans to promote Taiwan overseas via partnerships and major events. From January to June, 9.14 million international departures were recorded from Taiwan, an 11 percent increase from the same period last year, with 3.3 million headed for Japan, 1.52 million for China and 832,962 to South Korea,
REWRITING HISTORY: China has been advocating a ‘correct’ interpretation of the victory over Japan that brings the CCP’s contributions to the forefront, an expert said An elderly Chinese war veteran’s shin still bears the mark of a bullet wound he sustained when fighting the Japanese as a teenager, a year before the end of World War II. Eighty years on, Li Jinshui’s scar remains as testimony to the bravery of Chinese troops in a conflict that killed millions of their people. However, the story behind China’s overthrow of the brutal Japanese occupation is deeply contested. Historians broadly agree that credit for victory lies primarily with the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT)-led Republic of China (ROC) Army. Its leader, Chiang Kai-shek (蔣介石), fled to Taiwan in 1949 after losing a
RSS