The Constitutional Court on Friday ruled unconstitutional the search and seizure of confidential messages shared between lawyers and their clients during a prosecutors’ investigation, and ordered that the law be amended within two years.
The ruling on Articles 122-2 and 133-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (刑事訴訟法) came after Lee and Li Attorneys-at-Law challenged the constitutionality of the clauses, when its Hsinchu branch office was raided and messages between staff and clients were seized by prosecutors in a 2011 litigation case.
The law firm said that the prosecutors’ actions had infringed on its right to keep communication with its clients confidential, especially as prosecutors at the time could not prove that the office had committed any wrongdoing to justify their search.
Photo: Taipei Times file
Under the two articles, the premises or properties of any third -party can be searched only if there is probable cause.
A seizure that is not covered by a search warrant must be adjudicated by a judge, except when the item is seized for evidence, the articles say.
The court’s ruling said that the articles fail to take into consideration the attorney-client privilege, which is a rule that protects the confidentiality of communication between lawyers and clients.
The content of the two articles works against Articles 15 and 16 of the Constitution, which stipulate that “the right of existence, the right of work and the right of property shall be guaranteed to the people,” and that “the people shall have the right of presenting petitions, lodging complaints or instituting legal proceedings,” the ruling said.
Agencies should amend the Code of Criminal Procedure within two years, the court said, adding that before the revision of the law is completed, judges and prosecutors should conduct searches and seizures in accordance with the intention of the judgement.
The number of search warrants issued by Taiwanese courts from 2020 to last year averaged nearly 15,000 per year, Constitutional Court head clerk Hsu Chen-chou (許辰舟) said.
During this three-year period, 20 law firms have been searched, of which 18 were due to lawyers having become criminal suspects or because they were involved in collusion to destroy evidence, Hsu said.
‘OBNOXIOUS MAN’: The KMT’s Chen Ching-hui moved into Chung Chia-pin’s path atop the podium and reached for him before he grabbed at her legs with both hands Democratic Progressive Party Legislator Chung Chia-pin (鍾佳濱) yesterday said he slipped and lost his balance, and did not know who was around him, after jumping onto the speaker’s podium at the legislature in Taipei. He apologized after a collision with Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Legislator Chen Ching-hui (陳菁徽), who moved to intercept him as he mounted the podium. There was pushing and shoving when the session started in the morning as KMT lawmakers attempted to block access to the podium to shield Legislative Speaker Han Kuo-yu (韓國瑜) so he could preside over the session. Video footage showed Chung step on a chair and
Police officers yesterday morning apprehended the prime suspect of a triple homicide case, after raiding the suspect’s hideout in Taichung. They transported the suspect to New Taipei City for questioning and recorded his statement last night. The suspect, identified as a 24-year-old man surnamed Chang (張), is believed to have used his hands to strangle his wife, surnamed Chen (陳), 29, along with his three-year-old son from a previous marriage and his wife’s mother, 69. The three dead bodies were wrapped in blankets when they were discovered inside their apartment in New Taipei City’s Sanchong District (三重) on Saturday. Chang was holding a
Hungarian Member of Parliament Tompos Marton said he considers Taiwan to be a better alternative to China as a strategic partner. Marton, who is the vice president of the opposition Momentum Party, made the remarks in an interview with the Central News Agency on Sunday. He draped a Republic of China flag across his shoulders to protest Chinese President Xi Jinping’s (習近平) visit to the capital city, Budapest, on Thursday last week, and openly voiced support for Taiwan on social media. He said in the interview that he wanted to remind the world that there were alternatives to China, and that “Taiwan has
A female physician at New Taipei City’s Shuang Ho Hospital was bullied and made to work for 32 consecutive hours by a senior colleague while pregnant before later having a miscarriage, an internal investigation found, the hospital said on Monday. The perpetrator has been removed from his post, the hospital said. The attending physician in the hospital’s Medical Imaging Department, identified by the pseudonym Y, earlier on Monday told reporters that she had been bullied by a male senior colleague who arranged shifts in her department. In January, shortly after she became pregnant, Y asked the department director if she could avoid overnight