When you spend an entire film following a hysterical woman doggedly searching for her just-deceased husband’s amputated leg, you expect there to be some deep, symbolic revelation to the quest — or at least some sort of crazy plot twist. But instead it just serves to tell a quite conventional, formulaic story about love and loss, which some viewers will find immensely moving (there was much sobbing in the theater). Yet it just feels that director Chang Yao-sheng (張耀升) could have done so much more.
It’s not so bad that the film is unwatchable. There is plenty of dark humor and excellent acting from lead Gwei Lun-mei (桂綸鎂), who convincingly delivers her role of Yu-ying without veering into caricature: you both love and hate her. The film opened this year’s Golden Horse Film Festival and was nominated for five awards, although it failed to bag any.
There’s actually a moving backstory to A Leg: Chang’s mother embarked on the same quest after his father died, raising hell for everyone around her until she found the amputated limb. Chang says his mother’s journey was even more extreme than is depicted here, as she didn’t start the search until the 27th day after the amputation and even enlisted the help of politicians and gangsters to pressure the hospital to give it up.
Photo courtesy of Applause Entertainment
What’s also relevant to the film is the fact that Chang’s parents didn’t exactly have a loving relationship. His mother simply wanted to do one last thing for her husband so he could leave this world in one piece. This notion is actually quite thought-provoking and should be more than enough for a worthy feature film. Plus, the screenwriting partnership between Chang, an acclaimed novelist, and cinematographer Chung Mong-hong (鍾孟宏) saw smashing success last year with A Sun (陽光普照), creating great hype and hopes for this film.
The problem is that there’s just something too glossy and too sappy about the love story portrayed in A Leg: two charming ballroom dancers fall in love and marry, but their relationship is rocky as Yu-ying’s husband, Tzu-han (Tony Yang, 楊祐寧), is reckless and frequently gets into trouble. The relationship eventually falls apart and Tzu-han ill-advisedly tries to redeem himself.
Tzu-han’s faults are quite typical, often just doing what he feels is right for the relationship without consulting the partner and refusing to communicate. Yu-ying starts out rather innocent albeit with a tough streak, but as their marriage crumbles she develops into the relentless character we see in the opening scene.
Photo courtesy of Applause Entertainment
The whole story is told in flashbacks and narrated by Tzu-han, who sounds deeply sorry for what he did, while Yu-ying drives the story forward in her manic quest to get the leg back from the hospital. Since they both make a living using their legs, it becomes a central theme to the story, which is also a clever device.
The resulting product is meant to be somewhat surreal and funny, but it tries too hard to play the overly-packaged, lovey-dovey emotion card, making many of the scenes and sequences unbelievable even while knowing that it is an attempt at humor. Despite the superb acting, the characters toe the line between authenticity and parody and don’t go deep enough in either direction, making them hard to relate to and difficult for the viewer to immerse themselves into the plot.
Too many shenanigans and too long of a running time obfuscate the central question: Why is Yu-ying risking it all for someone who is already dead, especially after how he treated her? Maybe the answer is meant to be that simple, but Chang tries too hard to highlight the long-winding love story and doesn’t take the fascinating leg concept far enough, resulting in this reviewer leaving the theater feeling rather empty.
A Leg 腿
Directed by: Chang Yao-sheng (張耀升)
Starring: Gwei Lun-mei (桂綸鎂) as Yu-ying, Tony Yang (楊祐寧) as Tzu-han and Michael Chang(張少懷) as John
Language: Mandarin and Taiwanese with Chinese and English subtitles
Running time: 115 minutes
Taiwan release: In theaters
The town of Baolai (寶來) is located along the Southern Cross-Island Highway in the upper reaches of Kaohsiung City. After suffering a devastating setback at the hands of Typhoon Morakot, the town’s tourism industry is finally showing signs of recovery. While the town itself has many commercial hot spring offerings for tourists, the adjacent Baolai River also has at least five different wild hot springs available to those with a more adventurous spirit. SHIDONG AND WUKENG Just before entering the town of Baolai, make two right turns to reach the bridge across the Baolai River. Immediately after crossing this bridge, there is
Jan. 25 to Jan. 30 It was the beginning of the end when Dutch sergeant Hans Jurgen Radis walked out of Fort Zeelandia and surrendered to the besieging army of Cheng Cheng-kung (鄭成功, also known as Koxinga). The Dutch had already been trapped in the fort for nine months, and they were sick, hungry and in despair. After one defection during the early days of the siege, Dutch commander Frederick Coyett set up checkpoints around the fort’s perimeter, in what is today’s Tainan. Radis told his bunkmate he was going hunting, but by the time they realized where
In October of 2002 the James Ossuary exploded into the public consciousness. The artifact, a burial box in which bones were interred, was announced at a press conference in Washington prior to undergoing any form of scholarly authentication. It had an inscription that read in Aramaic: Ya’akov bar Yosef akhui di Yeshua (“James, son of Joseph, brother of Jesus”). Its promoters presented the thing as the first real concrete link to the historical Jesus. It was an obvious fake, and at that time I was administrating two enormous discussion groups devoted to early Christian history, which hosted numerous scholars in
“Well, if it cannot happen this year because of the pandemic,” Tourism Bureau Director General Chang Shi-chung (張錫聰) says at the end of his interview with Cycling Shorts last week, “at least we’ll be ready to promote it next year.” Chang is discussing the Year of Cycling Tourism (自行車旅遊年) that has long been planned for this year. He has spent the previous 30 minutes introducing the various infrastructure projects undertaken over recent years and those proposed for the next few. Essentially, the Bureau, under the Ministry of Transportation and Communications (MOTC), has been pulling together resources from a wide range of
RSS