Mon, Oct 20, 2025 page7

• UK’s Labour Party needs to prove it understands China threat

  Dispelling confusion about the dropped spy case would build confidence that the British government has a coherent policy

  • The Guardian Editorial
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  No single word describes the challenge that China poses for British foreign policy.

  There is threat and opportunity; a requirement to engage and an imperative to be guarded. The Chinese Communist Party (CCP) represses dissent and pursues its interests overseas with coercive nationalist determination. It is not a regime with which the UK could build a relationship based on common values.

  However, China is also a superpower with near-monopoly control of some mineral resources and pre-eminence in important manufacturing supply chains. Trusting friendship is not an option; hostile rejection is unrealistic. It is not easy to manage relations through private diplomacy, let alone under public scrutiny. However, British Prime Minister Keir Starmer’s government has looked especially awkward in its response to the collapse of a high-profile espionage case, involving the alleged transmission of secrets from inside parliament to Chinese officials.

  The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) dropped the case against two men, a parliamentary researcher and a teacher working in China.

  Both denied wrongdoing.

  The CPS said a conviction could not be secured if China was not named in government witness statements as a threat to national security — ostensibly a requirement of the Official Secrets Act.

  Opposition parties have cried foul. There are ample policy papers and ministerial statements going back many years attesting to the threat China poses. The suspicion has been raised that political pressure was applied to drop the case through fear of offending Beijing and spoiling economic relations.

  Ministers rejected that claim and accused the Conservatives of failing to fix flaws in the act when they were in power.

  In parliament on Wednesday, Conservative Party leader Kemi Badenoch said the whole affair “stinks of a cover-up.”

  The prime minister responded that the Tory leader was “slinging mud.”

  He committed to publish witness statements that he said support the government’s account of events.

  Something is clearly amiss if the CPS thought there was an espionage case to answer, but could not bring it to trial. In a climate of endemic mistrust in politics, it would be prudent of Badenoch to beware leaping from scepticism to conspiracy theory. By the same token, if wider diplomatic and commercial anxieties really are unconnected to the case, the government should have been more transparent, earlier.

  Partisan rhetoric has heated the debate without shedding much light on the underlying issue. There is more consensus on this question than the tone of party political exchanges over the past few days suggested.

  In office, Conservative ministers, including Badenoch, picked their words carefully when describing the risks of overexposure to the CCP’s espionage and dependence on Chinese technology, often to the frustration of hawkish backbenchers. The suppression of political freedoms in Hong Kong was not opposed as robustly as pro-democracy activists there deserved.

  Managing relations with an assertive superpower is complex. Judicious language does not necessarily indicate naivety about the danger, but diplomatic protocol should not prevent candor about the limits to engagement with a regime that is often hostile to fundamental British interests.

  The Labour government is not the first to send mixed signals on this point. If Starmer has a clear sense of how to strike the balance between trade with China and national security interests, ending confusion over the failed espionage case would be a good way to spell it out.
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Taipei to join Japan, US response to rare earth ban

  • 2

    Calls for reform after drunk woman publicly assaulted in Taipei station

  • 3

    Flight attendants’ union to protest EVA marathon

  • 4

    Torrential rain expected this week, the CWA says

  • 5

    China’s visa program just for show: MAC