Fri, Dec 01, 2023 page9

• Why the COP28 in Dubai has already failed

  Conferences such as the COP28 are only meaningful if everyone can criticize, gather peacefully and demonstrate

  • By Marta Schaaf and Kristine Beckerle
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  To avert catastrophic climate change, an active and empowered civil society is necessary. The upcoming UN Climate Change Conference (COP28) in Dubai is almost certain to provide further proof that we are to fail if we rely on large, powerful institutions such as governments and multinational corporations.

  Fossil-fuel companies have known about their contributions to climate change since the 1970s, yet they continue to drill and expand their operations. While governments have paid lip service to the problem by adopting the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change and the Paris climate agreement, the latest Production Gap Report shows just how little these commitments mean in practice. Between now and 2030, output in the top 20 fossil-fuel-producing countries are set to more than double the amount consistent with limiting global warming to 1.5° Celsius.

  Self-regulation by governments and fossil-fuel companies is woefully insufficient, not least because governments and fossil-fuel companies are often one and the same. For too long, both have sought to appease public concerns with greenwashing campaigns and the promise of future silver-bullet technologies such as carbon capture and storage. When some segment of the public is not pacified by such ploys, many of these same governments and companies have been all too willing to resort to quashing freedom of expression, association and peaceful assembly.

  Only through collective action, advocacy and civil-society participation in policymaking would governments be forced to do what it takes to phase out fossil fuels, support the transition to renewable energy and protect human rights in a world of increasingly extreme weather and drought. Yet civil society cannot thrive without civic spaces — public forums where citizens could jointly criticize and pressure the most powerful without fear or suppression. At COP28, outside the protected confines of the UN’s “blue zone,” there would be virtually no civic spaces at all.

  Dubai is one of the most expensive cities in the world, which means that lodging, food and other expenses would be prohibitively expensive for most people, especially the disadvantaged and marginalized who are most affected by the climate crisis. Moreover, it is illegal in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) even to criticize the government, or to say anything deemed to “harm the public interest,” and foreigners are sometimes detained for comments made while in the country. Minor signs of dissent during the 2011 Arab Spring were quickly and forcibly repressed. To this day, scores of human-rights activists and dissidents remain arbitrarily detained, including 60 members of the “UAE-94,” who were tried en masse in 2013. Four years later, the UAE imprisoned Ahmed Mansoor, the only remaining Emirati working publicly to defend human rights in the country.

  The government has continued its repression in the run-up to COP28. It has cut off communication between many prisoners and their families, prosecuted Emiratis who have been deported back to the country after seeking refuge abroad, and rejected the UN’s calls to release prisoners of conscience.

  The UAE is also infamous for its use of unlawful electronic surveillance. Mansoor is just one of many human-rights defenders who has been targeted with spyware developed by cybersurveillance companies such as NSO Group and Hacking Team.

  Such abuses are more than sufficient to create a climate of fear among activists hoping to attend COP28. While the UAE promises to make “space available for climate activists to assemble peacefully and make their voices heard,” it remains to be seen what this would look like in practice. What risks might activists still face if they speak out against the UAE’s abysmal rights record or failure to phase out fossil fuels? We do not know, because the UNFCCC secretariat and the UAE have not even disclosed the Host Country Agreement — the bare-minimum standard of transparency for any COP.

  Of course, the UAE is hardly alone in its hostile attitude toward civil society. Around the world, countries are cracking down on protesters, misapplying current law to stifle climate dissent and enacting new legislation to criminalize protest — often at the behest of powerful fossil-fuel companies. Some of these laws target climate activists directly, indicating that summits like the annual climate-change COPs are of particular concern to repressive governments.

  Despite this year being another year of record-setting heat and rainfall events, COP28 is unlikely to produce any meaningful outcome. That is as unjust as it is tragic. The people who suffer the most from climate change are not heads of state or fossil-fuel executives. In the UAE and around the world, those bearing the brunt of the crisis are often the same people facing discrimination, marginalization and a lack of basic protection from their governments.

  Since it is their futures that are to be discussed at COP28, their engagement, activism and demands for accountability are essential. It is through civil society that we might expose greenwashing and achieve the solutions that have long been promised. International conferences to discuss an existential global threat would only generate meaningful results if everyone is free to criticize, gather and peacefully demonstrate. Repressive laws, a climate of fear and imprisoned domestic dissidents serve no purpose other than to support defenders of the status quo.

  Marta Schaaf is Amnesty International’s director of the Program on Climate, Economic and Social Justice and Corporate Accountability. Kristine Beckerle is Amnesty International’s Middle East and North Africa Regional Office’s economic, social and cultural rights adviser.

  Copyright: Project Syndicate
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Taiwanese lose status after obtaining single-use Chinese passport

  • 2

    Jeers as Real Madrid fall 2-1 to Man City

  • 3

    KMT chair to meet with Xi, but at a price: source

  • 4

    Taiwanese tourists go viral in video during Japan quake

  • 5

    US vows deterrence ‘through strength’