Like so many sectors of the economy, the news industry is hurtling toward a future where artificial intelligence (AI) plays a major role — grappling with questions about how much the technology is used, what consumers should be told about it, whether anything can be done for the journalists who would be left behind.
These issues were on the minds of reporters for the independent outlet ProPublica as they walked picket lines last month. They are inching toward a potential strike, in what is believed would be the first such job action in the news business where how to deal with AI is the chief sticking point.
Few expect this dispute would be the last.
Photo: Reuters
AI has undeniably helped journalists, simplifying complex tasks and saving time, particularly with data-focused stories. News organizations are using it to help sift through the Epstein files. AI suggests headlines, summarizes stories. Transcription technology has largely eliminated the need for a human to type up interviews. These days, even a simple Google search frequently involves AI.
Yet rushing to see how AI can help a financially troubled industry has resulted in several cases of publications owning up to errors.
Within the past year, Bloomberg issued several corrections for mistakes in AI-generated news summaries. Business Insider and Wired were forced to remove articles by a fake author named Margaux Blanchard. The Los Angeles Times had trouble with AI and opinion pieces. Ars Technica said AI fabricated quotes, and the publication that has frequently reported on the risks of overreliance on AI tools embarrassed itself further by failing to follow its policy to tell readers when the tool is used.
The ProPublica dispute is noteworthy for how it touches on issues that are frequently cause for debates. The union representing ProPublica’s journalists, negotiating its first contract with the outlet known for investigative reporting, says it wants commitments that mirror those sought elsewhere in the industry about disclosure and the role of humans in the use of AI.
Along with holding informational pickets, union members pledged overwhelmingly that they would be willing to strike without a satisfactory agreement, New York Guild spokeswoman Jen Sheehan said.
“It feels to me pretty monumental when we think about the trajectory of AI and journalism,” said Alex Mahadevan, an expert on the topic at the Poynter Institute journalism think tank.
ProPublica has rejected its requests, the union said.
Insight into why can be found in an essay, “Something Big is Happening,” that circulated widely last month. Author and investor Matt Shumer, who said he has spent six years building an AI start-up, wrote that the technology is advancing so quickly that “if you haven’t tried AI in the last few months, what exists today would be unrecognizable to you.”
Small wonder, then, that news executives are reluctant to put guarantees in writing that could quickly become outdated.
Rather than make promises that cannot be kept, ProPublica is exploring how technology can create more space for investigative reporting, company spokesman Tyson Evans said.
In the “unlikely event” of AI-related layoffs, ProPublica is proposing expanded severance packages for those affected, he said.
“We’re approaching AI with both curiosity and skepticism,” Evans said. “It would be a mistake to freeze editorial decisions in a contract that will last years.”
Fifty-seven of 283 contracts at US news organizations negotiated by the NewsGuild-USA contain language related to AI, said Jon Schleuss, president of the union that represents more journalists than any in the US.
The first such deals happened in 2023. He wants provisions in more contracts.
It would not be easy, judging by the reluctance of many outlets to be tied down. The organization Trusting News, which encourages news organizations to develop and make public its policies on AI use, estimates that less than half of US outlets have done so.
“I think it is becoming harder,” Schleuss said, “because too many newsrooms are being run by the greedy side of the organization and not by the journalism side of the organization.”
The New York guild is pushing for contracts that guarantee AI would not eliminate jobs. That is no surprise; unions exist to protect jobs. Schleuss characterized a proposal that ensures an actual journalist is involved when AI is used to prevent errors and help an outlet build trust with its readers.
“Humans are actually so much better at going out, finding the story, interviewing sources, bringing back the relevant pieces, asking the hard follow-up questions and putting that in a way that people can understand and see, whether it’s a news story or a video,” he said. “Humans are way better at doing that than AI ever will be.”
Apparently, not everyone in journalism agrees. Chris Quinn, editor of the Plain Dealer in Cleveland, Ohio, last this month of his disgust with a recent college graduate who turned down a job offer, because the person had been taught that AI was bad for journalism.
Quinn’s newspaper has been sending some of its journalists out to cover stories by interviewing people, collecting quotes and information, then feeding it to a computer to write. While a human would edit what the computer spits out, an integral part of the process — a reporter using his or her judgement about how to tell a story — has been stripped from their hands. Quinn defended it as the best use of limited resources.
Research shows that a vast majority of US consumers believe that it is very important that newsrooms tell the public when AI is used to write stories or edit photographs, said Benjamin Toff, director of the Minnesota Journalism Center at the University of Minnesota.
However, here is the rub: Such disclosure makes them trust the outlet’s stories less, not more.
A significant minority — 30 percent in a study Toff conducted last year — does not want AI used in journalism at all.
Telling a reader that AI was used is not as simple as it sounds.
“There are just so many, many uses of AI in journalism, from the very beginning of the reporting process to when you hit publish, that just broadly declaring that when AI is used in the newsgathering process that you have to disclose it, just seems like it is actually a disservice to the reader in some cases,” Mahadevan said.
Two lawmakers in New York state — the US’ publishing capital — introduced legislation last month requiring clear disclaimers when AI is used in published content. There is no immediate word on its chances for passage, but both sponsors are Democrats in a legislature controlled by that party.
Mahadevan believes it is fair to have policies that require human involvement — editing to prevent slip-ups, for example.
However, even these declarations are open to interpretation, he said.
If an outlet uses chatbots to answer reader questions, are they being edited by a human being?
“Speaking realistically, the newsroom of the future is going to look completely different than it does today,” Mahadevan said. “Which means people will lose jobs. There will be new jobs. So, I think it’s important that we are having these conversations right now, because audiences do not want a newsroom completely taken over by AI.”
Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) has approved a capital budget of US$31.28 billion for production expansion to meet long-term development needs during the artificial intelligence (AI) boom. The company’s board meeting yesterday approved the capital appropriation plan for purposes such as the installation of advanced technology capacity and fab construction, the world’s largest contract chipmaker said in a statement. At an earnings conference last month, TSMC forecast that its capital expenditure for this year would be at the higher end of the US$52 billion to US$56 billion range it forecast in January in response to robust demand for 5G, AI and
PORTFOLIO REBALANCING: The adjustments in three global equity indices reflect rising investor appetite for semiconductor and artificial intelligence-related stocks Taiwan’s weighting in major global equity indices compiled by MSCI Inc is to rise modestly following the latest quarterly review, underscoring the market’s expanding role in emerging-market portfolios, as global investors continue to favor the nation’s technology sector. Taiwan’s weighting in the MSCI Emerging Markets Index is to increase by 0.30 percentage points to 23.76 percent, after the changes take effect at the close of the May 29 session. Its weighting in the MSCI All-Country Asia ex-Japan Index is to rise 0.37 percentage points to 27.16 percent, while that in the MSCI All Country World Index is to edge up slightly to
NEW MARKET: The partnership opens up India to the Dutch company, which already has a strong hold in the semiconductor market of South Korea, Taiwan and China ASML Holding NV entered into a partnership agreement with Tata Electronics Pvt Ltd aimed at ramping up India’s goal to develop domestic chip-manufacturing capabilities. The Dutch company’s technology would help power Tata Electronics’ planned 300 millimeter (mm) semiconductor foundry in Gujarat, according to a joint statement from the two companies on Saturday. The signing of a memorandum of understanding coincides with a visit by Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi to the Netherlands, which is looking to deepen bilateral relations with New Delhi. ASML, whose top customers include Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (台積電) and Samsung Electronics Co, makes lithography machines that can print
The Hsinchu County Government’s Labor Affairs Department yesterday said that it has received a plan from cosmetics brand Taiwan Shiseido Co (台灣資生堂) detailing mass layoffs at its plant in Hukou Township (湖口). While the labor authorities did not disclose the number of employees to be laid off, Japanese news media earlier in the day reported that the closure of the company’s factory in Hukou would result in 170 employees losing their jobs. Shiseido followed the law by reporting its layoff plan, the department said, adding that authorities would closely monitor negotiations between the management and affected employees and step in if any
RSS