Not long before he died on Oct. 15, tech visionary Paul Allen traveled to the south of France for a personal tour of a 35-country quest to replicate the workings of the sun. The goal is to one day produce clean, almost limitless energy by fusing atoms together rather than splitting them apart.
The Microsoft Corp cofounder said he wanted to view the early stages of the International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER) in Cadarache firsthand, to witness preparations “for the birth of a star on Earth.”
Allen was not just a bystander in the hunt for the holy grail of nuclear power. He was among a growing number of ultra-rich clean-energy advocates pouring money into start-ups that are rushing to produce the first commercially viable fusion reactor long before the US$23 billion ITER program’s mid-century forecast.
Amazon founder and chief executive officer Jeff Bezos, Microsoft cofounder Bill Gates and venture capitalist Peter Thiel are just three of the billionaires chasing what late physicist Stephen Hawking called humankind’s most promising technology.
Scientists have long known that fusion has the potential to revolutionize the energy industry, but development costs have been too high for all but a handful of governments and investors. Recent advances in exotic materials, 3D printing, machine learning and data processing are all changing that.
“It’s the SpaceX moment for fusion,” said Christofer Mowry, chief executive officer of the Bezos-backed General Fusion Inc near Vancouver, Canada. He was referring to Elon Musk’s reusable rocket maker.
“If you care about climate change you have to care about the timescale and not just the ultimate solution. Governments aren’t working with the urgency needed,” Mowry said.
The company Allen supported, TAE Technologies, stood alone when it was incorporated as Tri-Alpha Energy two decades ago. Now it has at least two dozen rivals, many funded by investors with a track record of disruption.
As a result, there has been an explosion of discoveries that are driving the kind of competition needed for a transformational breakthrough, Mowry said.
One of the clearest measures of progress in the field was on display last week in Gandhinagar, India, where the Vienna-based International Atomic Energy Agency held its biennial fusion forum. The conference highlighted a record 800 peer-reviewed research papers, 60 percent more than a decade ago.
Fusion itself is not the problem. The tricky part is generating more energy than is used in the process. Such reactors have to mimic conditions found only in deep space, a much more complex and costly endeavor than fission. Heating plasma to temperatures higher than stars and then containing the ensuing reactions inside cryogenic cooling vessels can require a million parts or more.
Even if commercial fusion takes longer than expected to achieve, many of the innovations produced along the way are likely to prove lucrative on their own, said IP Group PLC, a London-based investor in intellectual property.
Research firms are already minting patents to protect their creations, from software that simulates plasma burning at 150 million degrees Celsius to a new type of magnet that has applications in healthcare.
“There’ll still be significant residual value,” said Robert Trezona, who oversees IP Group’s investment in First Light Fusion Ltd, a company near Oxford University, the advisory board of which includes former US secretary of energy Steven Chu.
“It would have been inconceivable for a small company like First Light to make advancements in fusion sciences 20 years ago,” Trezona said.
One of the most ambitious ventures is Commonwealth Fusion Systems, a company founded last year by six Massachusetts Institute of Technology professors. Backed by some of the biggest names in business, they are confident they will be able to produce a prototype of a so-called net energy reactor by 2025.
The start-up raised US$50 million in March from a group led by Italy’s Eni SpA, one of several oil producers preparing for a carbon-neutral world. Last month it secured an unspecified sum from Breakthrough Energy Ventures, a fund seeded by Gates, Bezos and fellow tycoons including Richard Branson, Ray Dalio and Michael Bloomberg, the majority owner of Bloomberg LP.
“The greater danger is not having anybody succeed than having everybody,” Commonwealth Fusion chief executive officer Bob Mumgaard said by phone from Cambridge, Massachusetts. “We need more smart people driving very hard to crack this.”
Still, ITER remains the best bet in terms of breaking the code for producing cheap energy on a massive scale, saod Nawal Prinja, a nuclear engineer at Aberdeen-based John Wood Group PLC and a featured speaker at the forum in India.
“They’re coming up with all kinds of new ideas to make the industry more efficient, but turning ideas into a commercial station is a different story,” Prinja said.
Only ITER, Latin for “the way,” has the resources needed to perfect the kind of reactor that can run entire cities, he said.
If so, many of today’s fusion investors might not live long enough to benefit from the rollout. It has already taken ITER more than three decades just to lay the foundation of a machine designed to prove the viability of its concept, and it does not expect to have a reactor capable of powering a couple million US households until about 2050.
Tim Luce, ITER’s chief scientist and Allen’s host at the sprawling research facility about 50km north of Marseille, dismissed criticism of the time horizon.
What the international effort is trying to accomplish, he said, is simply too ambitious for any one actor in the private sector.
“These other competitors have a vision for doing something smaller, but I haven’t seen a compelling piece of physics that shows they can do it,” Luce said. “It’s the story of the tortoise and the hare and we’re the tortoise.”
Then there is Musk, a serial innovator who thinks the whole fusion crowd is barking up the wrong tree.
In a weed-and-whiskey podcast that went viral last month, the Tesla and Solar City cofounder said smart money like his is better spent on finding more efficient ways to capture the sun’s energy than on trying to recreate it.
“We’ve got a giant thermonuclear reactor in the sky,” Musk said. “It shows up every day very reliably. If you can generate solar panels and store it with batteries, you can have it 24 hours a day.”
Apple Inc has closed in on an agreement with OpenAI to use the start-up’s technology on the iPhone, part of a broader push to bring artificial intelligence (AI) features to its devices, people familiar with the matter said. The two sides have been finalizing terms for a pact to use ChatGPT features in Apple’s iOS 18, the next iPhone operating system, said the people, who asked not to be identified because the situation is private. Apple also has held talks with Alphabet Inc’s Google about licensing its Gemini chatbot. Those discussions have not led to an agreement, but are ongoing. An OpenAI
INSATIABLE: Almost all AI innovators are working with the chipmaker to address the rapidly growing AI-related demand for energy-efficient computing power, the CEO said Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) yesterday reported about 60 percent annual growth in revenue for last month, benefiting from rapidly growing demand for artificial intelligence (AI) and high-performance computing applications. Revenue last month expanded to NT$236.02 billion (US$7.28 billion), compared with NT$147.9 billion in April last year, the second-highest level in company history, TSMC said in a statement. On a monthly basis, revenue surged 20.9 percent, from NT$195.21 billion in March. As AI-related applications continue to show strong growth, TSMC expects revenue to expand about 27.6 percent year-on-year during the current quarter to between US$19.6 billion and US$20.4 billion. That would
‘FULL SUPPORT’: Kumamoto Governor Takashi Kimura said he hopes more companies would settle in the prefecture to create an area similar to Taiwan’s Hsinchu Science Park The newly elected governor of Japan’s Kumamoto Prefecture said he is ready to ensure wide-ranging support to woo Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) to build its third Japanese chip factory there. Concerns of groundwater shortages when TSMC’s two plants begin operations in the prefecture’s Kikuyo have spurred discussions about the possibility of tapping unused dam water, Kumamoto Governor Takashi Kimura said in an interview on Saturday. While Kimura said talks about a third plant have yet to occur, Bloomberg had reported TSMC is already considering its third Japanese fab — also in Kumamoto — which would make more advanced chips. “We are
KEY TECHNOLOGY: South Korea’s semiconductor exports reached US$11.7 billion in March, and the chip sector accounts for one-fifth of the nation’s total exports South Korea would set up an aid package worth more than US$7 billion to support its chip industry, the South Korean Ministry of Economy and Finance said yesterday. This initiative follows its pledge last year to build the world’s largest chip center using US$240 billion of private investment, primarily from Samsung Electronics Co, the world’s largest memorychip maker, as it seeks an edge in the global industry. Seoul “is preparing an assistance package of more than 10 trillion won (US$7.3 billion) to support fabless, chips materials and manufacturing equipment in all areas of chips industry,” South Korean Minister of Economy and Finance