As federal flood-control officials directed efforts on Thursday to block off the 17th Street Canal, the source of most of the water swamping New Orleans, they faced growing criticism over decades of missed opportunities to prevent precisely this kind of disaster.
In interviews and a telephone conference call with reporters, senior officials and engineers from up and down the ranks of the Army Corps of Engineers conceded that they had no ability to detect quickly small breaches in the matrix of 560km of levees around the city.
Unless such holes can be blocked early, the punch of storm-driven waters will almost invariably rip away at the edges, widening the breach.
The officials and engineers said that after they had found the widening gap in the concrete wall that lines the eastern side of the canal, they had no quick-response plan to repair it.
Even as they tried to improvise a solution, while fresh torrents of water steadily inundated neighborhood after neighborhood, their efforts were impeded by a lack of heavy helicopters, most of which had been dispatched by federal emergency management officials to rescue stranded residents.
"The first priority of the rotary-winged aircraft was to rescue people," Lieutenant General Carl Strock, head of the US Army Corps of Engineers, said in the conference call. "Plugging the gap was a lower priority."
The accumulation of 40 years of compromises of that sort on Thursday resulted in a mixture of grief, frustration and defensiveness from the Corps, which has long been given a mission far broader than its budget.
Ultimately, the Army Corps was being directed, along with 15 other agencies, by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), Strock said.
"It is FEMA who is really calling the shots and setting priorities here," he said.
Strock also defended the administration against the idea that spending on Iraq had diminished the Corps capacity to deal with domestic threats like the hurricane.
"I do not see that to be the case," he said.
"We deeply regret the loss of life associated with this," Strock said. "We are committed to doing whatever we can right now to stop the flow of waters and get the city on the road to recovery."
Alfred Naomi, a Corps senior project manager in the New Orleans district, said the New Orleans protection system was a vexing mix: It met the standards that had long ago been agreed on, but it was known to be inadequate.
"This storm was much greater than protection we were authorized to provide," he said.
While Congress appropriated more than US$4.7 billion for the Corps of Engineers this year, the amount spent on the New Orleans levee projects highlighted by the flooding was relatively small. The Lake Pontchartrain project drew about US$5.7 million and that was almost US$2 million more than what US President George W. Bush recommended in his budget.
In the last five years, Congress has repeatedly raised the amount of money for levee projects in New Orleans over what Bush requested, according to numbers provided by Senate Republicans.
In fact, lawmakers repeatedly enlarged the corps' budget overall -- but it was always still far below what corps engineers said would finish the job.
Adam Hughes, a budget policy analyst with OMB Watch, said such tradeoffs far too often err on the side of serving short-term needs and discounting long-term risks. And now, he said, the destruction of New Orleans made an earlier investment in bigger berms and other protections -- all part of that gray universe of what bureaucrats call infrastructure -- look like a bargain.
"This is a classic example of what under-funding infrastructure can do," Hughes said.
An uncrewed Chinese spacecraft has acquired imagery data covering all of Mars, including visuals of its south pole, after circling the planet more than 1,300 times since early last year, state media reported yesterday. The Tianwen-1 successfully reached the Red Planet in February last year on the country’s inaugural mission there. A robotic rover has since been deployed on the surface as an orbiter surveyed the planet from space. Among the images taken from space were China’s first photographs of the Martian south pole, where almost all of the planet’s water resources are locked. In 2018, an orbiting probe operated by the European
FEELING THREATENED: The first military commission under Kim Jong-un’s leadership to last longer than a day is a sign of a growing escalatory doctrine, an analyst said North Korea discussed assigning additional duties to its frontline army units at a key military meeting, state media said yesterday, suggesting that the country might deploy battlefield nuclear weapons targeting South Korea along the rivals’ tense border. The discussion comes as South Korean officials said North Korea has finished preparations for its first nuclear test in five years, as part of possible efforts to build a warhead to be mounted on short-range weapons capable of hitting targets in South Korea. During an ongoing meeting of the Central Military Commission of the ruling Workers’ Party on Wednesday, North Korean leader Kim Jong-un and
TRADE TALK: Xiao Qian said that Australia had fired the ‘first shot’ in deteriorating trade relations with China, but improvements were possible if Canberra takes action China’s new ambassador to Australia chided protesters who heckled him yesterday during a speech about the future of relations between the two countries. Xiao Qian (肖千), who has only been in the role since January, had just begun his speech at the University of Technology Sydney when the first protesters interjected, calling for freedom for Xinjiang, Tibet and Hong Kong. The ambassador was repeatedly interrupted by sign-wielding protesters, some criticizing China’s treatment of the Uighur people as well as the university for inviting Xiao to speak. “People who are coming again and again to interrupt the process, that’s not expression of freedom of
A former South Korean Navy SEAL turned YouTuber who risked jail time to leave Seoul and fight for Ukraine said it would have been a “crime” not to use his skills to help. Ken Rhee, a former special warfare officer, signed up at the Ukrainian embassy in Seoul the moment Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy asked for global volunteers and was fighting on the front lines near Kyiv by early March. To get there, he had to break South Korean law — Seoul banned its citizens from traveling to Ukraine, and Rhee, who was injured in a fall while leading a special operations