Tue, Apr 20, 2004 page6

• Israel to free man who blew whistle on nukes

  • AP
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  Eighteen years after he was kidnapped by Mossad agents, nuclear whistleblower Mordechai Vanunu will go free this week -- a moment Israel fears will refocus unwelcome attention on its "bomb in the basement."

  Anti-nuclear crusaders are flying in from Europe and the US for Wednesday's release, but they won't be able to embrace their hero.

  Israel's security services, trying to quash celebrations and keep Vanunu silent, have barred him from speaking to foreigners, traveling abroad or even approaching foreign embassies for fear he might seek political asylum.

  Vanunu, 50, said in remarks published yesterday that he has no more secrets to spill beyond what he told The Sunday Times of London in 1986 about his nine years as a technician at the Dimona nuclear reactor in the Negev Desert.

  The US and Europe already know everything they need to know about Israel's nuclear program, Vanunu told Shin Bet interrogators two weeks ago, according to transcripts published in the Yediot Ahronot and Maariv dailies.

  "As for myself, I just want to repeat the things I already said and that were published," Vanunu was quoted as saying.

  Vanunu said he hoped there would be renewed debate about Israel's nuclear program and that the Dimona reactor should be destroyed, "like the reactor in Iraq was destroyed." Israel bombed the Iraqi reactor in 1981.

  Based on Vanunu's descriptions and the photographs he secretly took inside the Dimona reactor, foreign experts said in 1986 that Israel had the world's sixth-largest stockpile of nuclear weapons. Such revelations undercut Israel's policy of "nuclear ambiguity."

  That policy was forged in the 1960s when Israel promised the US it would not declare its nuclear status, test nuclear weapons or use them for political gain, wrote Israeli historian Avner Cohen on the Web site of the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, an academic journal in the US. In exchange, Washington did not pressure Israel to disarm.

  Israel has kept the pledge, neither confirming nor denying it has nuclear capability. Some say that by drawing attention to its nuclear capability, Vanunu actually boosted Israel's security.

  "There is no question that more than anybody, he (Vanunu) contributed to Israeli deterrence," Cohen said.

  Vanunu is celebrated by anti-nuclear campaigners abroad. He received thousands of letters of support while in prison, was formally adopted by an elderly couple from Minnesota and had celebrities and members of the US Congress lobby on his behalf.

  But there is little sympathy for him in Israel, a country where just about everything is debated openly -- except nuclear weapons.

  Israelis believe the weapons are their last line of defense, "the ultimate guarantee that another Holocaust will not happen," said legal commentator Moshe Negbi. The consensus is that too much talk will only harm security.

  Still, critics say, Vanunu's punishment was excessive, considering that he didn't reveal anything Israel's enemies didn't already suspect.

  Those in charge of security at Dimona ignored many warning signs that Vanunu was drawn into left-wing and pacifist circles while still working at the reactor, said Yossi Melman, a journalist who writes about espionage.

  Vanunu said Israel shouldn't have trusted him with sensitive information and that the "bigshot psychologists" from the Shin Bet and the Mossad security services should have spotted him as a potential security risk.

  "You gave information to the wrong man," Maariv quoted him as saying. However, he insisted he was not a spy.

  Vanunu was snatched from Rome by the Mossad in 1986 after being lured into a rendezvous by a female agent, smuggled to Israel by yacht, tried behind closed doors and sentenced to 18 years for treason. He spent 12 of those years in solitary confinement.

  In the 30 months, Vanunu was under 24-hour video surveillance, with fluorescent lights on at all times in his windowless cell, said his brother Meir. He was allowed a one-hour daily walk in a yard shrouded in canvas to prevent him from signaling other prisoners. His only human contact was a guard and a family visit every two weeks.

  Yediot and Maariv ran rare photographs of the white-haired, balding Vanunu yesterday, showing him in jeans, a brown prison uniform shirt and a blue ski jacket. Vanunu, a convert to Christianity, wore a gold cross around his neck and held a copy of the International Herald Tribune.

  The prisoner, one of 11 children of working-class Jewish immigrants from Morocco, seems to have been an accidental spy.

  He was a loner who rebelled against his ultra-Orthodox Jewish upbringing and searched for a place to belong. He studied at Ben Gurion University in the Negev while working at the reactor, joining pacifist and Arab-Jewish groups on campus, and earned an undergraduate degree in philosophy.

  In 1985, after getting fired from Dimona, Vanunu flew to Thailand, where he stayed at a Buddhist monastery and considered conversion, then moved on to Australia. He became a Christian, changed his name to John Crossman, joined an Anglican congregation in Sydney and met a freelance journalist who suggested Vanunu talk to the media about Dimona. The Sunday Times was interested.

  The Israeli government is trying to limit the damage caused by Vanunu's release by imposing restrictions on his movement, with the implicit threat of re-arrest if he violates them.

  "We just want to stop him from spreading state secrets," said Likud Party legislator Yuval Steinitz, chairman of parliament's Defense and Foreign Affairs Committee.

  "We think Vanunu still has information he hasn't revealed," Steinitz said.
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Can Taiwan keep the talent it invites?

  • 2

    Taiwan expresses regret after CPTPP does not address its accession

  • 3

    Wickets tumble on first day of first Ashes Test

  • 4

    Taiwan and Japan have ties that run deep, premier says

  • 5

    PLA could attack with little warning: US