Sun, Sep 19, 2004 page17

• Discovering a new idea in Taiwanese literature

  Taiwan studies has emerged in the academic world and Tu Ko-ching, who recently took up the newly created Lai Ho and Wu Chu-liu Endowed Chair in Taiwan Studies at the University of California, Santa Barbara, is promoting literary tradition and Taiwan's place in the world

  • By Ian Bartholomew / STAFF REPORTER
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  Literary traditions are subjective things and the various merits of "canonical" writers are something that scholars have spent lifetimes arguing over. Tu Kuo-ching (杜國清) is embarking on the perilous task of establishing a literary tradition for Taiwan, a task made all the more difficult by Taiwan's still uncertain sense of its national identity and also by the fact that he wants to make this tradition known internationally through a projected series of literature in translation that will introduce the Western reader to the great figures of Taiwanese literature from the Japanese occupation period until the early 1980s.

  The definition of Taiwanese literature is a fraught question, seeing as it invokes linguistic, ethnic and nationalist sentiments, and also rubs up against the overwhelming presence of the literature of China. Tu boldly sweeps aside much of the debate when he states "Taiwanese literature is literature that deals with Taiwan, with this island and its experience."

  

  "We simply cannot have a linguistic definition of Taiwanese literature," he said during an interview last week when visiting Taiwan to give a seminar on the various projects that he hopes to initiate as the Lai Ho and Wu Cho-liu Professor of Taiwan Studies. "If we say that Taiwanese literature must be written in Chinese, then we cut out many writers of the [Japanese] occupation."

  

  Top, Tu Kuo-ching and, above, his book.

  PHOTO: IAN BARTHOLOMEW, TAIPEI TIMES

  The question is quite fundamental for Tu, who dates Taiwanese literature from the Japanese occupation period, during which some seminal figures wrote in Japanese. Tu sees Taiwan's experience as unique and separate from that of its giant neighbor China, and therefore worthy of separate study.

  "The impact of various foreign influences on Taiwanese literature have made it an important subject for comparative study from an international perspective, and have also warranted its study on a theoretical basis for eventual evaluation within a global vision," was how Tu put it during his inaugural speech on Aug. 30, this year. But it has been a long process to have Taiwan recognized as a separate field of academic study, especially within the international community. Against China's strongly nationalistic definition of what constitutes Chinese literature, Tu promotes a broader idea of Chinese literatures (with an emphasis on the plural), of which Taiwanese literature is a branch.

  In 1996, Tu launched the Taiwan Literature English Translation Series published by Forum for the Study of World Literatures in Chinese, a scholarly journal dedicated to introducing Taiwan's literature to a broader academic community. The name of the publisher reflects Tu's desire to distance Chinese literature from a narrowly linguistic definition. "There is no reason why Chinese literature must come out of China," Tu said. "What about Chinese writers in Singapore and other Southeast Asian countries? What about literature in other languages about the Chinese experience?"

  So within this broad context, Taiwanese literature can take its place among world literatures written in or by Chinese without any direct reference to the political entity of the People's Republic of China (PRC). "This is an idea that the PRC probably doesn't much like, for the Chinese tend to see such things in terms of monolithic unity -- we are the only one, we are the center -- but Chinese literatures are branches of the main body."

  But ultimately, Tu wants to get away from seeing Taiwan literature too tightly linked to the Chinese language in any shape or form. "The ethnicity of the author is not really relevant, and the language he or she writes in can be transcended through translation. What is important is the world of that literature. This is an absolute." Taiwanese literature is about this island and its experience in the world, and rises above the popular debate about Chinese, Hokkien, Hakka and even Aboriginal languages. "It is about this land, its society, its people and its history. It doesn't matter if the author is Taiwanese or not."

  As far as his insistence that Taiwan literature should be written in Hokkien, Tu says that this is simply "another chauvinism." Tu takes this further to say "what we call Taiwanese should include Mandarin, Hakka and even Aboriginal languages as well as Hokkien."

  For Tu, the final arbitrator of literature is quality, and it really doesn't matter which of the Taiwanese languages are used. "I respect people who are trying to create a Hokkien literature, and if they can produce a book like Dream of the Red Chamber then many people will refer to it as the bible of Hokkien literature. If such a great writer did emerge in Hokkien, he or she could open up a new tradition within Taiwanese literature. But this is easier said than done."

  While decrying the parochialism that has caused Taiwan literature to descend into bitter and often meaningless arguments over politically correct usage -- a tangled debate that is best know for the tortuous issue of Romanization of Chinese and Hokkien place names -- Tu insists that the only way out is through taking an international perspective, something he is well-placed to do in his new position. Starting next year, Tu will be launching a series of collected works by various major Taiwanese authors in English translation, including Yeh Shih-tau's (葉石濤) History of Taiwanese Literature (臺灣文學史綱). "This is very important for there is no good introduction to Taiwanese literature in English," Tu said. While some Taiwanese works have been translated into English, there is still an absence of a systematic body of work in translation. Howard Goldblatt, a distinguished translator who has worked on some of Taiwan's most important contemporary writers, has complained that there is a lack of interest in publishing Taiwanese works. Even though Tu's interest is primarily academic, saying that he will leave the study of writers from the 1980s on to others, knowing where Taiwanese literature came from is probably a good idea if we want to speculate about where it might be going. This can be seen clearly in the two writers whose names are attached to the endowed chair. Tu sees Lai Ho (賴和) as "the father of Taiwan's new literature," a pioneer who used literature as a means of resistance and struggle, in a way not dissimilar to the May Fourth New Literature Movement in China by which he was influenced. He insisted on using colloquial Chinese as his medium, equally rejecting the classical forms imposed by tradition and Japanese, imposed by an occupation government. Wu Cho-liu (吳濁流), the author of Asia's Orphan (亞細亞的 孤兒), the acknowledged masterpiece of Taiwanese literature, was born of Hakka parents and started his literary career writing in Japanese. These two authors perfectly showcase the unique and diverse qualities that have formed Taiwan's literature.

  As recognition of Taiwan's unique experience grows, the field of Taiwan studies has also expanded in the international community. Important centers of study have such as the Society for Taiwan Studies at Tenri University and the Japan Association for Taiwan Studies in Japan, the Research Unit on Taiwan Culture and Literature at the Ruhr University in Bochum, Germany and others have been established to reflect the interest and importance attached to this new field. This is a great step forward from the situation little more than a decade ago when few would have acknowledged the separateness of what Taiwan represents. Tu's work carries on a process that can only gather momentum.
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Chinese technicians join airport MRT project

  • 2

    A train for whom? Is a new monorail helpful for Cairo?

  • 3

    Apple is giving Intel’s turnaround some momentum

  • 4

    Uncrewed US craft transits the Taiwan Strait

  • 5

    Taiwan firms eye Philippines amid shift to non-China supply chains: CIER