The sudden and unexpected announcement that the Global Views Monthly Survey Research Center will no longer conduct or accept commissions for polls on elections and political issues — with a presidential election looming — is suspicious and places a dark cloud of conspiracy over the upcoming election.
The move was unexpected because when Global Views released their latest poll that showed that Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) Chairperson Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) was holding a small lead over President Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九), they said they were planning to increase the frequency of their polling in the run-up to the election.
Those very words were still fresh when the person in charge of the center quietly resigned. The eerie part about all of this is that the polls Global Views has conducted for so long have often shown Tsai doing better than Ma, and the support rates for the two candidates in their polls have often been much closer than polls conducted by other media companies.
The disappearnce of Global View’s polls, coupled with the majority of the remaining polls being favorable to Ma, it will make for a textbook example of Noelle-Neumann’s “spiral of silence” theory — the minority fails to voice their opinion out of fear of reprisal or isolation from the majority. Any need for false polling is eliminated, because the negative polls naturally suppress Tsai’s support and predictions about who would win the election simply add insult to injury.
Closing a polling company to create an aberration should be added to all the upcoming editions of media studies textbooks as a prototypical example of a regressing democracy. Perhaps it is even the byproduct of a meticulously designed media studies experiment.
On one hand the survey program is expanded, enhancing the aberration, while on the other hand, a polling company is closed to suppress differing opinions, maybe even creating a chilling effect throughout the polling industry so that professionals producing opinion polls with differing numbers will have to take unpaid leave or maybe even lose their jobs.
In the short term, the spiral of silence would serve to enhance the strategic voting effect if People First Party Chairman James Soong (宋楚瑜) decides to participate in the presidential election because so many polls show Tsai and Soong’s combined support ratings are far higher than those for Ma. This means the number of people opposed to Ma far exceed the number of his supporters and the tipping point between Soong and Ma is not found in the distance between them in the polls, but rather in whether Tsai can beat Ma. As soon as this news gets out, Ma will be in a precarious situation.
However, the result of heavy manipulation would be the victory predicted by the polls not matching the victory in the actual election results. For example, in the 1948 US presidential election all the polls had the Republican Party candidate Thomas Dewey defeating then-US president Harry Truman and most media headlines referred to Dewey as victor. However, Truman defeated Dewey.
Look at DPP vice presidential candidate Su Jia-chyuan’s (蘇嘉全) narrow loss to Taichung Mayor Jason Hu (胡志強) by less than 3 percentage points in the special municipality elections in November last year, when media polls predicted that Hu would win by 10 percentage points or more. Simply looking at the numbers, it would seem that Su benefited from the shooting of KMT Central Committee member Sean Lien (連勝文) on the eve of the election.
Whoever is generating spirals of silence will not only hurt society, they are also committing a heinous crime against Taiwanese democracy.
Hsu Yung-ming is a political science professor at Soochow University.
Translated by Kyle Jeffcoat
Taiwan is rapidly accelerating toward becoming a “super-aged society” — moving at one of the fastest rates globally — with the proportion of elderly people in the population sharply rising. While the demographic shift of “fewer births than deaths” is no longer an anomaly, the nation’s legal framework and social customs appear stuck in the last century. Without adjustments, incidents like last month’s viral kicking incident on the Taipei MRT involving a 73-year-old woman would continue to proliferate, sowing seeds of generational distrust and conflict. The Senior Citizens Welfare Act (老人福利法), originally enacted in 1980 and revised multiple times, positions older
The Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) has its chairperson election tomorrow. Although the party has long positioned itself as “China friendly,” the election is overshadowed by “an overwhelming wave of Chinese intervention.” The six candidates vying for the chair are former Taipei mayor Hau Lung-bin (郝龍斌), former lawmaker Cheng Li-wen (鄭麗文), Legislator Luo Chih-chiang (羅智強), Sun Yat-sen School president Chang Ya-chung (張亞中), former National Assembly representative Tsai Chih-hong (蔡志弘) and former Changhua County comissioner Zhuo Bo-yuan (卓伯源). While Cheng and Hau are front-runners in different surveys, Hau has complained of an online defamation campaign against him coming from accounts with foreign IP addresses,
Taiwan’s business-friendly environment and science parks designed to foster technology industries are the key elements of the nation’s winning chip formula, inspiring the US and other countries to try to replicate it. Representatives from US business groups — such as the Greater Phoenix Economic Council, and the Arizona-Taiwan Trade and Investment Office — in July visited the Hsinchu Science Park (新竹科學園區), home to Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co’s (TSMC) headquarters and its first fab. They showed great interest in creating similar science parks, with aims to build an extensive semiconductor chain suitable for the US, with chip designing, packaging and manufacturing. The
When Taiwan High Speed Rail Corp (THSRC) announced the implementation of a new “quiet carriage” policy across all train cars on Sept. 22, I — a classroom teacher who frequently takes the high-speed rail — was filled with anticipation. The days of passengers videoconferencing as if there were no one else on the train, playing videos at full volume or speaking loudly without regard for others finally seemed numbered. However, this battle for silence was lost after less than one month. Faced with emotional guilt from infants and anxious parents, THSRC caved and retreated. However, official high-speed rail data have long
RSS