Sat, Jun 13, 2009 - Page 9 News List

In Russia, recession means reform

Some Russians fear that rising oil and commodity prices could pull their country out of recession too quickly, leading to the crippling of a reformist agenda

By Michael Stott  /  REUTERS , MOSCOW

Russia’s economy is mired in a deep recession, unemployment is soaring and industrial production is collapsing — but some policymakers and economists fret that the Eurasian giant may recover too quickly.

They fear long-delayed reforms to make business more competitive and the state more efficient will not happen if Russia bounces back rapidly, burying its problems once again under a gusher of oil money.

The global financial crisis hit Russia with unexpected ferocity last year, knocking it from growth of 7 percent or 8 percent a year into a contraction of 9.5 percent in the first quarter of this year — a bigger shock than in any other major world economy.

In most countries, such a dramatic downturn would trigger social unrest and threaten political stability.

Some commentators abroad rushed to make dire predictions about new revolutions in Russia, or claimed to detect splits in the country’s dual power system between Russian President Dmitry Medvedev and his powerful patron, Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin.

But such speculation is largely unfounded. Inside Russia, where the mainstream media is state-controlled, civil society barely exists and the Kremlin dominates politics. So discussion of politics is focusing not on the risk of mass unrest, but on the danger of missing a historic chance for change.

Liberal business groups and some officials close to Medvedev are using the crisis to argue the need for sweeping reforms: a crackdown on corruption, stronger guarantees for property rights, a more independent judiciary, reform of the pensions system to create domestic pools of savings, better transport infrastructure to lower companies’ costs and a reduction in costly regulation and bureaucracy.

Ultimately, such reforms could help to wean Russia off its dependence on natural resources and lead to a more diversified, and more stable, economy.

“The fear is that the oil price will go back up, there will be no reforms and this will expose Russia to a continuation of the same boost and bust cycle of the last 20 years,” said Roland Nash, head of research at Moscow’s biggest investment bank, Renaissance Capital. “Right now is a perfect time to do a reform program.”


A government minister, speaking on condition of anonymity, agrees.

“We are really happy about this crisis,” he said. “Our history shows that structural reforms only happen when things are bad.”

Because of the closed nature of the Russian system, most of the debate about policy is conducted well away from the public eye. Gossip abounds of secret meetings where nationalists confront reformists, of clashes over assets between factions in the ruling class and of fights for survival between oligarchs. Hard facts are elusive.

But it is clear that Russia’s economic fate remains for now almost entirely in the hands of the oil and commodity markets. Oil and gas make up most of the country’s exports and form the backbone of government revenues.

Russia’s benchmark Urals blend of oil rose above US$60 per barrel at the end of last month for the first time since November, from around US$40 at the height of the global financial panic. So some analysts already think the worst of the economic pain is over.

“The economy clearly bottomed in [the first quarter] and has a great chance to rebound later in the year,” Moscow-based investment bank Troika Dialog said in its latest monthly survey.

Comments will be moderated. Keep comments relevant to the article. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned. Final decision will be at the discretion of the Taipei Times.

TOP top