Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin once characterized liberals and leaders of human rights groups as jackals who scavenged for handouts at foreign embassies. His protege and successor as president, Dmitri Medvedev, recently met with some of those very people, praising their work and saying that they had been treated unfairly.
But Medvedev left it at that. No new policies or aid.
About a year after becoming Russia’s third president, Medvedev remains something of a puzzle, and the financial crisis has only deepened the questions about his intentions. Is he the affable front man for the business-as-usual hardliners in the Kremlin, a puppet president who offers soothing remarks but little else? Or is he a genuine reformer who is edging Russia away from the more heavy-handed practices of Putin, but needs time to make his mark?
Medvedev lately seems to have gone out of his way to showcase his supposed liberal leanings and to distinguish himself from Putin. Medvedev first gave an interview to a fiercely anti-Kremlin newspaper, Novaya Gazeta, whose reporters have been killed and harassed in recent years.
He then convened the meeting with human rights and related advocacy groups on April 15. They have long complained of government harassment and are now operating in such a climate of intimidation that some of their leaders have hired bodyguards.
“It is no secret that there is a seriously distorted perception of human rights activities in our country,” Medvedev said at the meeting, issuing the kind of apology rarely, if ever, heard from Putin.
“Many officials are now under the impression that all non-governmental organizations are enemies of the state and should be fought, so that they do not transmit some sort of disease that may undermine the foundations of our society,” Medvedev said. “I think such an interpretation is simply dangerous.”
If his statements were heartening to the groups, they were, as often is the case, not accompanied by action. And in general, it is difficult to discern even a minor shift in how the Kremlin wields power under Medvedev.
The recent mayoral race in Sochi, host of the 2014 Winter Olympics, appeared to have been orchestrated using the same techniques honed in the Putin era. Opposition candidates were kicked off the ballot or subjected to intensely hostile TV coverage. The Kremlin’s favorite won 77 percent of the vote after barely campaigning.
“For now, Medvedev is just pronouncing nice words,” said Alexei Simonov, who is president of the Glasnost Defense Foundation in Moscow, which promotes media freedom, and who was at the meeting. “And he has done a lot of that. But there has been a complete lack of deeds.”
Medvedev’s comments are regularly parsed for signs of discord with Putin, who is considered Russia’s paramount leader, and it is perhaps possible to glean from them a rebuke to Putin’s style.
But it seems far more likely that Putin has chosen to let Medvedev adopt his own tone as long as he does not alter the government’s course.
Medvedev is a former law professor who appears to have sympathy for the difficulties of human rights groups. Even so, the groups’ leaders could point to only one move by the government recently that indicated a thaw: a court-ordered release from prison of a lawyer, Svetlana Bakhmina, who was a minor figure in the crackdown by Putin on the Yukos Oil company and its head, former oligarch Mikhail Khodorkovsky.
RSS