Conflict with Taiwan could leave China with “massive economic disruption, catastrophic military losses, significant social unrest, and devastating sanctions,” a US think tank said in a report released yesterday.
The German Marshall Fund of the United States (GMF) yesterday released a report titled If China Attacks Taiwan: The Consequences for China of “Minor Conflict” and “Major War” Scenarios.
The report details the “massive” economic, military, social and international costs to China in the event of a minor conflict or major war with Taiwan, estimating that the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) could sustain losses of more than half of its active-duty ground forces, including 100,000 troops killed.
Photo: Screen grab from the German Marshall Fund’s Web site
Understanding Chinese President Xi Jinping's (習近平) risk calculus is “crucial” to understanding Beijing’s possible actions, it says.
The report was edited by Bonnie Glaser, managing director of GMF's Indo-Pacific program, and its contributors include Zack Cooper, a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute.
It details how a minor conflict or a major war scenario would affect the People’s Republic of China (PRC) in contingencies expected to occur between this year and 2030.
The report defines a minor conflict as a blockade by Chinese ships and aircraft involving deadly air and maritime confrontations between the PLA and Taiwan, without losses of foreign personnel, concluding with the US intervening to ensure both sides mutually agree to de-escalate the situation.
A “major war” scenario would entail several months of armed conflict resulting in a PLA defeat, though it would establish control of the islands in Kinmen and Lienchiang (Matsu) counties, the report says.
That scenario would begin with an amphibious invasion of Taiwan and involve attacks on US military bases in Japan and Guam, it says.
It would result in losses of 100,000 personnel for the PLA, and 50,000 military and 50,000 civilian casualties for Taiwan, while the US would suffer 5,000 military and 1,000 civilian casualties and Japan would lose 1,000 military personnel and 500 civilians, the report says.
“The costs to the PRC of a failed military operation against Taiwan would be substantial,” it says.
However, “national humiliation” in the event of a PLA defeat would leave Beijing “strongly tempted to relaunch the war,” it says.
It could also result in military backing for a rival civilian leader or even a coup designed to restore national pride, the report says.
Starting with the economic implications, the paper references estimates by Rhodium of US$2 trillion to US$3 trillion and Bloomberg of US$10 trillion in economic losses for China in a limited escalation scenario.
As China’s annual exports account for 20 percent of GDP, compared with 10 percent for the US, any conflict “risks cutting off the country’s only sources of economic growth in the future, leaving its economy entirely dependent on weakening domestic demand,” the report says.
Meanwhile, a major war could bring “near-total embargoes on trade with China,” US economic sanctions, major fluctuations in global financial markets and disruption to manufacturing supply chains, and Hong Kong might cease to be a global economic hub, it says.
The international economy could split into three blocs: a larger group of countries aligned with the US, a smaller group of countries aligned with Beijing and a group of countries attempting to remain neutral while continuing to trade with both groups, it says.
A Taiwan contingency could also bring major social unrest and “strain the Chinese Communist Party’s (CCP) ability to maintain internal political order and social control,” particularly if defeated, the report says.
It lists the risks as a loss of legitimacy for the CCP, casualty sensitivity during a demographic decline, political dissatisfaction due to economic consequences and emboldened ethnic separatist movements that could threaten China’s territorial integrity.
The CCP is preparing by developing an intensive surveillance and internal security apparatus, but it would struggle to maintain control in a major conflict due to material shortages, political disillusionment and population dislocation, the report says.
As for the international costs, a major conflict could set China back “decades on the global stage,” it says.
Global markets could accelerate derisking, shifting supply chains away from China, while embargoes and sanctions could affect China’s access to imported energy and raw materials, it says.
Nations could respond by withdrawing foreign ambassadors and non-combatants from China, pulling out of Belt and Road Initiative projects and withdrawing from organizations such as BRICS and the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, it says.
As China holds a veto in the UN Security Council it is unlikely to be suspended from the UN General Assembly, but it could face condemnation or an International Court of Justice case, the report says.
However, Chinese leaders would likely view the international implications of a minor conflict as “manageable,” it says.
“Deterrence rests on perceptions, rather than reality,” and Chinese leaders are likely to underestimate the effects of a possible conflict and remain undeterred, it says.
China might misjudge Taiwan or the US’ capabilities or commitment, underestimate the potential costs of a conflict or could feel that it has “no better alternative” and must achieve “reunification” within a set time frame, the report says.
NATIONAL SECURITY: Authorities are working to confirm the identities of the military personnel involved and investigating possible illegal conduct and regulatory violations Authorities are probing possible national security implications after Kinmen police and immigration officers on Sunday found a Chinese woman allegedly posing as a tourist while engaging in prostitution involving more than 10 military personnel. The woman, surnamed Chen (陳), has since been deported, authorities said, adding that investigators are still working to confirm the identities of those implicated, as the records only listed code names and aliases. The case stemmed from a report received by the Kinmen District Prosecutors’ Office on Friday last week from the Jinhu Precinct of the Kinmen County Police Bureau. On Sunday, police, along with the National Immigration
GLOBALGIVING: ‘ Caving to external pressure is not acceptable for an organization that has cultivated justice reform and human rights for 30 years,’ one NGO said A slew of non-government organizations (NGOs) have withdrawn from the GlobalGiving fundraising platform after it announced it would use “Chinese Taipei” instead of “Taiwan” from next month. The Taiwan Good Rice Association wrote on Facebook on Friday that it was informed on April 28 via a teleconference call of the change, which was made because the platform wanted to operate in China. Taiwan Good Rice is to terminate all cooperative relationships with GlobalGiving in response to the platform’s “unilateral and non-negotiable” decision to remove references to Taiwan, the NGO said. “Taiwan is in the official name of Taiwan Good Rice Association and the
HEAVY WEATHER: Typhoon Jangmi is due to crash straight into the Ryukyus as airlines look to shift flights to larger aircraft or cancel flights to Okinawa entirely Taiwan’s international air carriers announced flight adjustments over the weekend as Typhoon Jangmi is forecast to hit the Ryukyu Islands today and tomorrow. The Central Weather Administration (CWA) upgraded Jangmi from a tropical storm to a typhoon at 8am yesterday, with the eye located 580km south of Naha city. It was moving north at 19kph. Today, China Airlines’ CI-120, CI-121, CI-122 and CI-123 flights between Taoyuan and Naha, Okinawa, have been canceled as well as CI-132 and CI-133 between Kaohsiung and Naha. EVA Air’s BR-112, BR-113, BR-186 and BR-185 flights between Taoyuan and Naha are also canceled. Low-cost carrier Tigerair Taiwan canceled IT-230,
REASONS FOR TRAVEL: An assistant professor said that proposed amendments to penalize drivers if they used drugs overseas would not deter people from traveling People who operate a motor vehicle under the influence of marijuana would have their driver’s license revoked, even if they used the substance while overseas, the Ministry of Transportation and Communications said yesterday, citing proposed amendments to the Road Traffic Management and Penalty Act (道路交通管理處罰條例). The amendments would also authorize the government to revoke the licenses of people determined to have used Category 1 or Category 2 narcotics, even if they were not operating a vehicle while under the influence of drugs, as well as ban them from taking the license test for three years, the ministry said. People aged 18 or