The government released figures for October showing that, year on year, exports increased 49 percent to a record US$61.8 billion for the month. The dramatic increases were partly due to fall being the high season, but largely due to the AI boom driving demand for exports, which many investors fear is rapidly turning into a massive bubble. An editorial in this newspaper last month warned that the government should be ready in case the boom turns to bust.
In previous boom-bust cycles, from shoes and textiles, through computer parts and accessories, to tools, bicycles and sporting goods, Taiwan has survived in part because it has had a robust, diversified manufacturing base, skilled in lean production, and cadres of managers and export firms with vast experience in operating in manufacturing clusters. Take, for example, the textile cluster in western Changhua, or the old mold and die cluster in New Taipei’s Sanchong District (三重). But one by one, these industries and products have moved to other countries.
MICROCHIPS, MEGA BUSINESS
Photo: AFP
Enter Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co. (TSMC). That firm’s production is worth roughly 25 percent of Taiwan’s GDP and 30 percent of the Taiwan stock market’s main index, according to Wiki. By most accounts, it produces 8 to 15 percent of the nation’s GDP. The diversified manufacturing economy of the “miracle years” never depended on a single firm the way Taiwan’s economy today depends on the health of TSMC and its chip industry cohorts.
The Taipei Times editorial called for the government to be prepared for a stock market shock if the AI demand busts. But as various articles on Taiwan’s booming exports have noted in the past few months, Taiwan’s traditional industries are ailing. The Taiwan Institute of Economic Research (TIER), which uses a colored light system to indicate the health of a sector, has had electronics on yellow-red (booming) or green most of the year, but metals and chemicals largely flashing blue (contraction).
Photo: AP
Traditional industries have been hit hard by the New Taiwan Dollar’s appreciation, which has worsened their ability to compete on price. US President Donald Trump’s tariff madness has also impacted them. TIER’s monthly report for October observed that, excluding AI applications and pre-stocking for new consumer electronics, traditional industry exports were negative. TIER also wrote that “imports of chemicals, basic metals and their products declined significantly, indicating relatively weak traditional industry demand.”
Similarly, the Chung-Hwa Institution for Economic Research (CIER) observed in an August editorial that “since the US-China trade war began in 2018, total manufacturing output has grown 23 percent, but this growth has been concentrated mainly in integrated circuits and electronic products.”
It said that traditional industries have shrunk, “making the export structure even more lopsided.” CIER called on the government to promote R&D and innovation, since those industries employ 25 percent of all workers and offshoring them could lead to social and political disruption.
Photo: EPA
If AI is a bubble doomed to bust, what will take up the slack? The pattern of Taiwan’s industrial development suggests that the government should pay less attention to the vicissitudes of the stock market and more to identifying the next big industry Taiwan can move into once the chip industry and AI have moved elsewhere. And move they will: Taiwan’s aging population and demographic collapse suggest that those industries are living on borrowed time. Their upstream supply chains further depend on flows of migrant workers from nations that are also suffering from plummeting fertility.
TALENT TROUBLES
Photo: EPA
The National Development Council (NDC) has put forth Taiwan’s Five Trusted Industry Sectors Promotion Plan, following the plans outlined in President William Lai’s (賴清德) inauguration speech. The plan calls for making Taiwan “an indispensable and trusted technological partner of democracies around the world” — the word “indispensable” there indicates how the plan increases Taiwan’s international security by embedding it in the economies of other democracies.
The five sectors include semiconductors, AI, military, surveillance and security and next generation communications industries. The NDC has programs for talent recruitment, under the assumption that what Taiwan needs is high-level tech and engineering talent.
A recent article in the Taipei Times on the Gold Card talent program highlighted the problem with that, one I’ve discussed many times: Taiwan doesn’t need imported high-end talent. It needs skilled technical workers, machine operators, sales people and similar mid-level workers. The quest for high-end talent isn’t an economic program so much as a program to attract high-level workers because their perceived higher status validates Taiwan. Like many events and programs in Taiwan, it’s really about chasing status.
The hunt for “talent” is further misguided because it addresses the wrong industries. Last week, the head of the Chinese National Association of Industry and Commerce (CNAIC) Thomas Wu (吳東亮) urged the government to tackle the growing disjunction between high tech industry and the traditional sectors, arguing that most of the workforce is in those industries, which produce essential goods and services.
Of course Taiwan should be pursuing high tech industry, but it should be noted that one reason that Taiwan is chasing tech success is because high tech success confers status. The chip industries give Taiwan a global profile. Traditional industries, by contrast, lack social status. A good example of that is the NDC’s own 2025 to 2028 development plan, where the traditional industries rate a mere couple of lines. None of the vivid language and imagery of the plan is directed at them.
NOT TOO LATE
In a decade Taiwan could find itself in a very strange crunch, with both high and low-end industry drying up. The aging, shrinking workforce will be leaving the semiconductor and AI industries, yet traditional industries will also be disappearing. What will Taiwan do for an economy then? The gaudy glories of the tech industry mask an economy that increasingly resembles several European states: a post-industrial lootscape heavily dependent on real estate and finance, with the bulk of the working population in low-end service jobs without prospects. A world created by PRC manufacturing dominance.
Traditional industries are probably doomed in the long run. They compete on price, and cheaper skilled labor is abundant in other countries. Many traditional industry firms are zombie firms, kept alive on subsidies, incapable of R&D. The government should treat the calls for saving traditional industries as calls for transforming their workforce.
As I always say, it’s not too late.
Notes from Central Taiwan is a column written by long-term resident Michael Turton, who provides incisive commentary informed by three decades of living in and writing about his adoptive country. The views expressed here are his own.
Most heroes are remembered for the battles they fought. Taiwan’s Black Bat Squadron is remembered for flying into Chinese airspace 838 times between 1953 and 1967, and for the 148 men whose sacrifice bought the intelligence that kept Taiwan secure. Two-thirds of the squadron died carrying out missions most people wouldn’t learn about for another 40 years. The squadron lost 15 aircraft and 148 crew members over those 14 years, making it the deadliest unit in Taiwan’s military history by casualty rate. They flew at night, often at low altitudes, straight into some of the most heavily defended airspace in Asia.
Many people in Taiwan first learned about universal basic income (UBI) — the idea that the government should provide regular, no-strings-attached payments to each citizen — in 2019. While seeking the Democratic nomination for the 2020 US presidential election, Andrew Yang, a politician of Taiwanese descent, said that, if elected, he’d institute a UBI of US$1,000 per month to “get the economic boot off of people’s throats, allowing them to lift their heads up, breathe, and get excited for the future.” His campaign petered out, but the concept of UBI hasn’t gone away. Throughout the industrialized world, there are fears that
Taiwan’s democracy is at risk. Be very alarmed. This is not a drill. The current constitutional crisis progressed slowly, then suddenly. Political tensions, partisan hostility and emotions are all running high right when cool heads and calm negotiation are most needed. Oxford defines brinkmanship as: “The art or practice of pursuing a dangerous policy to the limits of safety before stopping, especially in politics.” It says the term comes from a quote from a 1956 Cold War interview with then-American Secretary of State John Foster Dulles, when he said: ‘The ability to get to the verge without getting into the war is
Like much in the world today, theater has experienced major disruptions over the six years since COVID-19. The pandemic, the war in Ukraine and social media have created a new normal of geopolitical and information uncertainty, and the performing arts are not immune to these effects. “Ten years ago people wanted to come to the theater to engage with important issues, but now the Internet allows them to engage with those issues powerfully and immediately,” said Faith Tan, programming director of the Esplanade in Singapore, speaking last week in Japan. “One reaction to unpredictability has been a renewed emphasis on
RSS