Chinese women who publish homoerotica online say they are being threatened with fines and jail time, as increasing enforcement of vague obscenity charges targets a rare space for LGBTQ identity and feminism.
In recent months, Chinese police have detained dozens of writers on Haitang Literature City, a Taiwan-based Web site known for publishing serialized Boys’ Love, a genre of erotic fiction mainly written and read by heterosexual women.
Originating as a strand of Japanese manga comics in the 1960s known as yaoi, the genre has attracted a cult following in Asia and beyond, leading to popular screen adaptations and Web series. The stories defy social stereotypes about the roles of men and women, said a 22-year-old writer who asked to go by the pseudonym Miu Miu.
Photo: AFP
“It’s a kind of resistance... resisting a male-dominated society,” she said.
The latest crackdown ensnared mostly amateur writers who earned little to nothing for their work.
Under Chinese law, profiting from “spreading obscene content” can lead to fines and prison. “Serious” instances can carry jail terms of up to a decade.
The obscenity law applies when someone’s work gets at least 10,000 clicks or is “used” to collect fees exceeding 10,000 yuan (nearly US$1,400).
While the law excludes “artistic works or works of artistic value,” that distinction is usually left to police.
“The rules are outdated,” said a lawyer representing one of the authors and who asked not to be named due to the risk of repercussions.
“The general public’s attitude towards sex is no longer the same as it was 30 or 40 years ago,” the lawyer added.
One author phoned by police earned 2,000 yuan for two books with a total of 72 chapters that, combined, drew around 100,000 clicks.
“Are there really 100,000 people who have seen my work like they said? Are they really going to sentence me to three to five years?” the author wrote on Weibo. “Don’t they know how precious three to five years of life are?”
CENSORS WITHOUT BORDERS
The investigations have also renewed criticism of a practice known as “distant water fishing,” cross-provincial policing by cash-strapped local governments.
The profit-driven enforcement typically involves authorities traveling to another jurisdiction and seizing a suspect’s assets.
“Police find this kind of stuff can make them money,” Liang Ge, a lecturer on digital sociology at University College London, said of the targeting of Boys’ Love authors.
In one case, a policeman from northwestern Lanzhou traveled 2,000 kilometers to investigate a writer in her coastal hometown.
She was driven to the police station and questioned for hours about her writing.
She is currently on bail but could face criminal charges, which would disqualify her from taking China’s civil service exam and positions in some hospitals and schools.
Another 20-year-old author received a police summons which prompted her to travel hundreds of kilometers from the city of Chongqing to Lanzhou.
On arrival police urged her to “return the illegal income” she had earned from her writing to reduce her sentence.
“It’s a very dirty practice,” said the lawyer, noting the central government in Beijing has issued several directives against it.
‘SOCIAL AWAKENING’
Activists see the crackdown on alleged obscenity as part of a wider push to suppress LGBTQ expression — an effort that has expanded under President Xi Jinping (習近平).
China classified homosexuality as a crime until 1997 and a mental illness until 2001. Same-sex marriage is not legal and discrimination remains widespread.
The Boys’ Love genre — often lightly erotic but sometimes overtly explicit — has become increasingly censored as its popularity has boomed.
Television adaptations have rewritten male lovers as friends, as same-sex relationships are banned from the screen. In 2018, a writer known by her pseudonym Tianyi was sentenced to over a decade in prison for earning US$21,000 from a homoerotic novel about a teacher and his student.
Last year, a court in Anhui province heard 12 cases involving spreading obscene content for profit, according to public records which do not give outcomes of the trials. Many in China “feel less and less space to express themselves freely,” said Ge, the lecturer and a longtime reader of Boys’ Love.
“It’s not just about posting something on social media, it’s about reading something in their private life.”
As news of the crackdown spread, Haitang users rushed to cancel their accounts.
But writer Miu Miu said she has not given up hope she might be able to finish her favorite stories.
“Sexual knowledge has become taboo,” she said.
“This is a social awakening.”
The depressing numbers continue to pile up, like casualty lists after a lost battle. This week, after the government announced the 19th straight month of population decline, the Ministry of the Interior said that Taiwan is expected to lose 6.67 million workers in two waves of retirement over the next 15 years. According to the Ministry of Labor (MOL), Taiwan has a workforce of 11.6 million (as of July). The over-15 population was 20.244 million last year. EARLY RETIREMENT Early retirement is going to make these waves a tsunami. According to the Directorate General of Budget Accounting and Statistics (DGBAS), the
Last week the story of the giant illegal crater dug in Kaohsiung’s Meinong District (美濃) emerged into the public consciousness. The site was used for sand and gravel extraction, and then filled with construction waste. Locals referred to it sardonically as the “Meinong Grand Canyon,” according to media reports, because it was 2 hectares in length and 10 meters deep. The land involved included both state-owned and local farm land. Local media said that the site had generated NT$300 million in profits, against fines of a few million and the loss of some excavators. OFFICIAL CORRUPTION? The site had been seized
Next week, candidates will officially register to run for chair of the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT). By the end of Friday, we will know who has registered for the Oct. 18 election. The number of declared candidates has been fluctuating daily. Some candidates registering may be disqualified, so the final list may be in flux for weeks. The list of likely candidates ranges from deep blue to deeper blue to deepest blue, bordering on red (pro-Chinese Communist Party, CCP). Unless current Chairman Eric Chu (朱立倫) can be convinced to run for re-election, the party looks likely to shift towards more hardline
Sept. 15 to Sept. 21 A Bhutanese princess caught at Taoyuan Airport with 22 rhino horns — worth about NT$31 million today — might have been just another curious front-page story. But the Sept. 17, 1993 incident came at a sensitive moment. Taiwan, dubbed “Die-wan” by the British conservationist group Environmental Investigation Agency (EIA), was under international fire for being a major hub for rhino horn. Just 10 days earlier, US secretary of the interior Bruce Babbitt had recommended sanctions against Taiwan for its “failure to end its participation in rhinoceros horn trade.” Even though Taiwan had restricted imports since 1985 and enacted