The Taipei Times reported last week that housing transactions fell 15.3 percent last month, to under 20,000 units. However, the market boomed for the first eight months of the year, and observers expect it to show growth for the year as a whole.
The fall was due to Central Bank intervention.
“The negative impact of credit controls grew evident for the third straight month,” said Sinyi Realty Inc (信義房屋) research manager Tseng Ching-ter (曾敬德), according to the report.
Photo: AFP
Central Bank Governor Yang Chin-long (楊金龍) in October said that the Central Bank implemented selective credit controls in September to cool the housing market. The controls were put in place because the bank feared that a speculative bubble was forming in the housing market, with prices rising quickly, driven by consumer expectations that prices would continue to rise.
Consumers seem unaware, or at least unaffected, by the fact that the population is shrinking. They expect that prices of property will always rise and they prefer to own rather than rent. Nor are homeowners generally willing to rent out vacant houses, since the income is often perceived as not worth the trouble, and taxes are low. Hence, the singular market characteristics of Taiwan, with its high housing prices, high vacancy rate and high ownership rate, which is over 80 percent in the big cities.
The result is a market in which the number of first-time home buyers is low, and most buyers already own a home. In August last year the government launched a subsidy program to increase the number of first-time home buyers by helping them with mortgages.
Photo: Reuters
LANDOWNERS COMPLAIN
Why is it so difficult to obtain houses at low prices even though Taiwan is overbuilt? Some of the issues I have explored before. But another factor in the housing price explosion is land planning decisions made early in the democratic era that have handed Taiwan’s urban “planning” over to developers.
A Rutgers-based scholar, Mi Shih (史宓), has written a series of papers on planning and the conversion of the domestic economy to a real-estate based economy. According to Shih, the story begins in the 1970s with the issue of land zoned as reserved land (保留地) — that is, land for public facilities such as roads and parks, which could not be developed. However, the law required that private landowners whose land becomes reserved land be compensated, but in the Martial Law era, there was no legal requirement to pay in the short term. Hence, local governments routinely delayed or refused to pay. Shih instances a 1988 estimate showing that “Taiwan had nearly 41,000 hectares of reserved land in total, with a compensatory cost almost double that of all Taiwanese governmental budgets combined.”
This blew up into a crisis because the law required that all reserved land compensation be paid out by September of 1988 or else the land would be de-zoned. The legislature amended the Urban Planning Act (都市計畫法) to remove that requirement, and landowners began to yell, “generating a roaring grassroots discontent to which the rapidly democratizing Taiwanese government could not turn a deaf ear,” Shih says.
That was also the time when the Snails Without Shells protests over suddenly rising housing prices were taking place.
TRANSFERABLE DEVELOPMENT RIGHTS
As in so many policymaking situations, planners looked to the US for solutions, borrowing the idea of transferable development rights (TDR). In American practice, the government often gives TDRs to landowners and developers to facilitate planned development that extends beyond the property they own. Major cities that use this approach carefully monitor and manage it to keep cities compact and reduce community objections.
Shih says that Taiwanese planners intended to use TDRs to get developers to finance government compensation for reserved land. However, the Taiwanese TDR model, known as “floating TDR,” does not require government-designated receiving sites and gives developers great legal freedom to build TDR projects almost anywhere. Developers simply “move” the permitted floor space from the public reserved lands to their projects, often exceeding local density limits. Shih adds that “3,764 development projects have utilized TDR since the early 2000s, generating 807 hectares of floor area in excess of existing density limits — roughly equivalent to adding 100,875 new, market-rate apartments.”
This freedom from regulatory restriction means that local governments do not capture most of the land value created by building construction. It goes to developers, a massive hidden subsidy to land development. Community input in this process is entirely lacking, an example of the way early democratic era regulators retained the mindset of the authoritarian era.
In a later paper Shih and Chang Ying-hui (江穎慧) at National Chengchi University show how the TDR approach, coupled with formulaic density calculations, produce urban landscapes in Taiwan, land speculation and commodification, and the current real-estate driven economy. When they calculate the value of land, developers know what density numbers will be permitted by the government. These they treat as extra profit. Together, TDR practices and density valuations drive increased land brokerage and land transactions, pushing up prices. This creates, they contend, a “financially more calculable urban world in which capital’s acquisitive appetite for land’s monetary value is intensified.” Moreover, Shih and Chang argue, because these approaches are viewed by planners, developers and the public at large as purely technical decisions, they escape political scrutiny.
Worse, in yet another paper on Taiwan TDR practices, Shih and colleagues observe that TDR projects push up the value of nearby residential properties as well, making homes for lower income groups even less affordable.
It should now be obvious why the Central Bank is tinkering with the interest rates to cool down the housing market: interest rate changes have no effect on the political economy of residential development, and on the legal arrangements that favor developers over all other players in the market.
The Central Bank’s intervention exists solely to keep the market from exploding and then collapsing, a way of keeping a permanent crisis from spinning out of control — like so many other government interventions in Taiwan’s numerous permanent crises.
Notes from Central Taiwan is a column written by long-term resident Michael Turton, who provides incisive commentary informed by three decades of living in and writing about his adoptive country. The views expressed here are his own.
On the evening of June 1, Control Yuan Secretary-General Lee Chun-yi (李俊俋) apologized and resigned in disgrace. His crime was instructing his driver to use a Control Yuan vehicle to transport his dog to a pet grooming salon. The Control Yuan is the government branch that investigates, audits and impeaches government officials for, among other things, misuse of government funds, so his misuse of a government vehicle was highly inappropriate. If this story were told to anyone living in the golden era of swaggering gangsters, flashy nouveau riche businessmen, and corrupt “black gold” politics of the 1980s and 1990s, they would have laughed.
This is a deeply unsettling period in Taiwan. Uncertainties are everywhere while everyone waits for a small army of other shoes to drop on nearly every front. During challenging times, interesting political changes can happen, yet all three major political parties are beset with scandals, strife and self-inflicted wounds. As the ruling party, the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) is held accountable for not only the challenges to the party, but also the nation. Taiwan is geopolitically and economically under threat. Domestically, the administration is under siege by the opposition-controlled legislature and growing discontent with what opponents characterize as arrogant, autocratic
When Lisa, 20, laces into her ultra-high heels for her shift at a strip club in Ukraine’s Kharkiv, she knows that aside from dancing, she will have to comfort traumatized soldiers. Since Russia’s 2022 invasion, exhausted troops are the main clientele of the Flash Dancers club in the center of the northeastern city, just 20 kilometers from Russian forces. For some customers, it provides an “escape” from the war, said Valerya Zavatska — a 25-year-old law graduate who runs the club with her mother, an ex-dancer. But many are not there just for the show. They “want to talk about what hurts,” she
It was just before 6am on a sunny November morning and I could hardly contain my excitement as I arrived at the wharf where I would catch the boat to one of Penghu’s most difficult-to-access islands, a trip that had been on my list for nearly a decade. Little did I know, my dream would soon be crushed. Unsure about which boat was heading to Huayu (花嶼), I found someone who appeared to be a local and asked if this was the right place to wait. “Oh, the boat to Huayu’s been canceled today,” she told me. I couldn’t believe my ears. Surely,
RSS