Last week the pro-China parties announced the first victims of the new legislative program, likely intended to send a chill through the local press: the National Communications Commission (NCC) and its approval of Mirror News. The move highlights both the irregularities around regulatory approval in Taiwan’s divided politics, and the irrepressible need of the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) to attack and control the media. Like Fu Kun-chi’s (傅?萁) program to slather concrete across the east coast, it recalls the era of former president Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九) and his attempts to deliver Taiwan to the People’s Republic of China (“Notes from Central Taiwan: The once and future king of Hualien,” June 10, 2024).
Mirror Media was founded in 2016 as a print weekly started by Pei Wei (裴偉), the former chief editor of Next Magazine, whose reporting had summoned lawsuit after lawsuit. Pei brought over a number of people from Next. In December of 2019 Mirror submitted an application to the NCC to open a TV news station.
Ironies abounded in the move. The NCC, was established in 2006 by the KMT legislature to do an end run around then-Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) president Chen Shui-bian’s (陳水扁) control of government media and media oversight, to bring mass media under KMT control by centralizing media oversight in legislative (read: KMT) hands and chill pro-Taiwan speech. Members are appointed in proportion of party control of the legislature. It is easy to forget that the last eight years of press freedom in Taiwan have been historically anomalous, because the DPP controlled the legislature.
Photo: Tien Yu-hua, Taipei Times
THE COMING STRUGGLE
The Ma era should be understood as the template for KMT actions in the democratic era, and for the KMT’s coming moves. Fierce struggles were fought over media freedom. The Public Television Service (PTS) became the site of a bitter fight over control, as in June of 2009 the legislature enlarged the board of directors for the PTS. Since the PTS was funded by the old Government Information Office (GIO), the GIO instantly appointed eight new directors, a move the Control Yuan censured six months later. Under Ma, the GIO was eventually closed and replaced by the Central News Agency (CNA), which the KMT hoped would give it greater control over the media.
The Ma administration also saw the Next Media group of Hong Kong media mogul Jimmy Lai (黎智英), now rotting in jail in the People’s Republic of China (PRC), twice attempt to purchase the pro-PRC China Times Group, but was rejected. Lai had been harshly critical of Beijing. The group was eventually sold to pro-PRC gazillionaire Robert Tsai (蔡衍明) of the Want Want group, who then attempted to form the notorious “media monster” by purchasing the Next Media group.
Photo: Liu Hsin-de, Taipei Times
That affair was a precursor of what we can expect from our current legislature. For example, when the NCC refused Next Media a license to operate a news channel it attempted to open an internet news channel with nothing but Apple content from its Apple Daily. That prompted the KMT-controlled legislature to consider legislation to rein in the internet. Similarly, when the NCC piled on all sorts of conditions for the Want Want acquisition of Next Media, the legislature, which had been rejecting moves to support the deal legislatively, suddenly decided to consider them.
The goal was always the same: to produce a pro-KMT media and chill media activity. As Lai put it in the Wall Street Journal at the time: “The NCC would not undertake actions that endanger press freedom and the reputation of Taiwan if President Ma and the ruling KMT did not back their actions.” It is probably not a coincidence that the current KMT-controlled legislature’s first move under the new legislative “reforms” is against the media.
The KMT probably also wants to retaliate for the NCC’s refusal to renew CtiTV’s license in November of 2020. Want Want’s media group had been accused of taking PRC money and direction in its reporting.
In January of 2022 the NCC granted permission to Mirror Media to open the news channel, which was slated for May of this year. However, it placed 26 conditions on the new channel, and listed another 16 items as administrative guidance. The 26 conditions included ownership restrictions, mandate to establish reporters in foreign capitals, mandates on the size and growth of its capital, and so forth. Two of the seven NCC commissioners dissented from the majority decision, arguing that Mirror added nothing new to the current news environment.
Though the Mirror News attack should be viewed against the background of Ma-era moves to rein in the press, it needs to be said: the KMT’s choice of target is a good one. In March Mirror News went through four different chairmen in response to allegations that management was interfering in news reporting, a violation of one of the NCC conditions. Allegations also swirled that retired NCC commissioners were receiving payments from Mirror, and Mirror’s print weekly and TV news stations, which were supposed to be separate, used the same reporters. Of course, there were the inevitable rumors that DPP faction influence enabled Mirror to obtain approval.
The KMT investigation should thus have no trouble finding things to complain about. Will that be used as an excuse for new attacks on press freedom? The Ma era experience suggests that it will, but also suggests that if civil society is vigilant and foreign observers comment — last time around, when the legislature attacked PTS, both Freedom House and Reporters Without Borders criticized the legislature — the moves can be turned back.
CHINESE LABOR
Meanwhile, another Ma-era project, bringing laborers from the PRC into Taiwan, received a spark last week. KMT Legislator Chen Hsueh-sheng (陳雪生), who represents Lienchiang/Matsu, proposed amendments to the Offshore Islands Development Act (離島建設條例) that would allow PRC manufacturers to participate in industrial development and public construction projects on outlying islands. The amendment also removes quotas on students from the PRC. Recall that large portions of those islands are restricted military zones.
The proposal echoes many of the moves of the Ma administration. I suspect most readers have forgotten that in 2008 Ma permitted PRC fishermen to work in isolated areas of Taiwan’s fishing ports. In 2008 Ma’s Executive Yuan added a clause to the procurement laws which permitted Chinese firms to bid on Taiwan government procurement. That withered in the face of criticism from within the KMT itself, since many legislators were involved with the local construction-industrial state and its patronage networks, which could never survive the onslaught of state-backed construction firms from the PRC.
The KMT is still chip, chip, chipping away at the walls used to keep out PRC labor and PRC firms, and attacking the media environment. The names change, but the game plan is always the same.
Meanwhile, the KMT legislature has offered no proposals on immigration, population, wages, house prices, social housing, global warming, renewable energy and many other areas urgently needing policy direction.
Welcome to Ma Ying-jeou, 2.0.
Notes from Central Taiwan is a column written by long-term resident Michael Turton, who provides incisive commentary informed by three decades of living in and writing about his adoptive country. The views expressed here are his own.
In recent weeks the Trump Administration has been demanding that Taiwan transfer half of its chip manufacturing to the US. In an interview with NewsNation, US Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick said that the US would need 50 percent of domestic chip production to protect Taiwan. He stated, discussing Taiwan’s chip production: “My argument to them was, well, if you have 95 percent, how am I gonna get it to protect you? You’re going to put it on a plane? You’re going to put it on a boat?” The stench of the Trump Administration’s mafia-style notions of “protection” was strong
Every now and then, it’s nice to just point somewhere on a map and head out with no plan. In Taiwan, where convenience reigns, food options are plentiful and people are generally friendly and helpful, this type of trip is that much easier to pull off. One day last November, a spur-of-the-moment day hike in the hills of Chiayi County turned into a surprisingly memorable experience that impressed on me once again how fortunate we all are to call this island home. The scenery I walked through that day — a mix of forest and farms reaching up into the clouds
Late last month US authorities used allegations of forced labor at bicycle manufacturer Giant Group (巨大集團) to block imports from the firm. CNN reported: “Giant, the world’s largest bike manufacturer, on Thursday warned of delays to shipments to the United States after American customs officials announced a surprise ban on imports over unspecified forced labor accusations.” The order to stop shipments, from the US Customs and Border Protection (CBP), came as a surprise to Giant, company officials said. Giant spokesman Ken Li (李書耕) said that the CPB never visited the company’s factories to conduct on-site investigations, nor to interview or
“Eighteen years ago, people didn’t even know the name of this ingredient,” says 58-year-old Gil Sa-hyeon, holding up a cluster of dried brownish stems. “Now it’s everywhere.” His shop, Joseon Yakcho, sits in the heart of Seoul’s Yangnyeongsi Market, South Korea’s largest traditional medicinal herb market, its streets lined with shops displaying buckets of herbs such as licorice root and cinnamon bark that spill on to the pavements, filling the air with their distinct, earthy aroma. The ingredient Gil is referring to is hovenia dulcis, known in Korean as heotgae — the oriental raisin tree that’s become the cornerstone of South Korea’s
RSS