Hundreds of lawyers of the Taiwan Bar Association and seven local bar associations on Saturday held a protest in Taipei against a proposed amendment to the Constitutional Court Procedure Act (憲法訴訟法), which they said would incapacitate the court and sabotage the nation’s liberal democratic constitutional order.
Under the amendments proposed by Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Legislator Weng Hsiao-ling (翁曉玲), the act would be changed to specify that the “total number of incumbent justices” mentioned in the act means “15” — the courts full number of judges, while a two-thirds majority would be needed to issue a ruling.
The current law requires a simple majority — based on the number of judges present and participating in a deliberation — to pass a ruling, but under the amendments, a ruling would require the participation and approval of at least 10 justices.
Some people are worried that this higher threshold could cripple the court’s effectiveness.
Making the situation worse, the KMT and Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) — which together hold a combined majority in the legislature — have been delaying the approval of seven new justices nominated by President William Lai (賴清德).
There are currently only eight incumbent justices, short of the proposed 10-member quorum, so if the amendments passed, the Constitutional Court would be paralyzed.
The Constitutional Court’s role is not only to clarify the separation of powers and resolve disputes between state agencies, but also to serve as a last resort for defending citizens’ fundamental rights.
The nation’s liberal democratic constitutional order would disintegrate if the court is incapacitated, the bar associations said on Saturday.
The lawyers also cited justice appointment mechanisms and constitutional court ruling requirements in other countries, including the quorum of justices and threshold for passing a ruling in the supreme courts of the US, Canada and Japan, as well as Germany’s Federal Court of Justice.
They said that while they all have a required minimum number of justices for passing a ruling, they also have mechanisms for avoiding a paralyzed court due to an inability to reach a quorum. For example, the US Supreme Court chief justice can assign cases to a circuit appeals court.
The lawyers raised concerns that Weng’s proposal makes passing constitutional rulings much more difficult, especially without a mechanism to avoid court incapacitation, which would surely pose a serious risk to the constitutional system.
TPP Legislator and former lawyer Vivian Huang (黃珊珊) in an article in the Chinese-language Contemporary Law Journal also opposed Weng’s proposal.
She said that Weng’s concerns are unfounded, as there were no rulings in which professional opinions were disregarded, and rulings made by a few justices are hardly possible in reality.
Weng on Friday stubbornly adhered to her view that the lawyers are only a minority of “Democratic Progressive Party supporters,” adding that the risk of paralyzing the court lies in Lai’s nomination of justices, not her proposed amendments.
While the draft amendments are still under review in cross-caucus discussions, the TPP’s stance would be critical, as it would be put to a floor vote if a consensus is not reached. After an internal meeting on Friday, the TPP caucus said it would propose its own amendment bill, which has not yet been revealed.
Although the KMT caucus has denied online reports that the next review of the bill is scheduled for tomorrow, people should continue to pay close attention and voice their concerns to local lawmakers.
If the amendment is passed, it would certainly affect their fundamental rights.
China has not been a top-tier issue for much of the second Trump administration. Instead, Trump has focused considerable energy on Ukraine, Israel, Iran, and defending America’s borders. At home, Trump has been busy passing an overhaul to America’s tax system, deporting unlawful immigrants, and targeting his political enemies. More recently, he has been consumed by the fallout of a political scandal involving his past relationship with a disgraced sex offender. When the administration has focused on China, there has not been a consistent throughline in its approach or its public statements. This lack of overarching narrative likely reflects a combination
Behind the gloating, the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) must be letting out a big sigh of relief. Its powerful party machine saved the day, but it took that much effort just to survive a challenge mounted by a humble group of active citizens, and in areas where the KMT is historically strong. On the other hand, the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) must now realize how toxic a brand it has become to many voters. The campaigners’ amateurism is what made them feel valid and authentic, but when the DPP belatedly inserted itself into the campaign, it did more harm than good. The
US President Donald Trump’s alleged request that Taiwanese President William Lai (賴清德) not stop in New York while traveling to three of Taiwan’s diplomatic allies, after his administration also rescheduled a visit to Washington by the minister of national defense, sets an unwise precedent and risks locking the US into a trajectory of either direct conflict with the People’s Republic of China (PRC) or capitulation to it over Taiwan. Taiwanese authorities have said that no plans to request a stopover in the US had been submitted to Washington, but Trump shared a direct call with Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平)
Workers’ rights groups on July 17 called on the Ministry of Labor to protect migrant fishers, days after CNN reported what it described as a “pattern of abuse” in Taiwan’s distant-water fishing industry. The report detailed the harrowing account of Indonesian migrant fisher Silwanus Tangkotta, who crushed his fingers in a metal door last year while aboard a Taiwanese fishing vessel. The captain reportedly refused to return to port for medical treatment, as they “hadn’t caught enough fish to justify the trip.” Tangkotta lost two fingers, and was fired and denied compensation upon returning to land. Another former migrant fisher, Adrian Dogdodo
RSS