On Thursday last week, a 17-year-old surnamed Liu (劉) turned himself in after discharging a modified submachine gun more than 50 times at a closed pawnshop in New Taipei City’s Tucheng District (土城). After investigating the incident, police detained two other teenagers in connection with a previous attack on the same pawnshop on April 10.
The shootings in broad daylight have unnerved the public.
The Criminal Code says that “an offense committed by a person who is under fourteen years of age is not punishable,” while “punishment may be reduced for an offense committed by a person more than the age of fourteen but under the age of eighteen.”
In practice, offenders aged 14 to 18 get largely reduced penalties, and commutations if they turn themselves in. This could be one of the major reasons that, according to crime data, fraud rings and other criminal organizations exploit underage people to commit crimes on their behalf.
Under the Criminal Code, teenagers younger than 14 lack criminal responsibility, while those aged 14 to 18 have limited criminal responsibility.
Those age thresholds are higher than in most other countries. For example, the age of criminal responsibility in the UK was in 1998 lowered to 10, and underage offenders serve their sentences in secure centers for young people. The age of criminal responsibility is 13 in France, and 12 in Ireland and the Netherlands.
In China, the age thresholds for limited and full criminal responsibility were in 2020 set at 14 and 18 respectively. The amendment was drafted in response to a continuous surge in juvenile delinquency and stipulates that children aged 12 to 14 who intentionally kill or cause bodily harm to another person resulting in their death or severe disability due to patently cruel or unusual methods can be charged with full criminal responsibility. In such cases, the Chinese Supreme People’s Procuratorate has to approve the charges.
These examples could become references for amendments in Taiwan.
Taiwanese legislation on juvenile delinquency is modeled after German laws. The Juvenile Justice Act (少年事件處理法) is a special act established for offenders aged under 18. Article 27 sets rules for pre-deliberation and stipulates that juveniles who commit an offense that carries a prison term of up to five years should stand trial in a juvenile court.
The article means that juvenile offenders merely get a slap on the wrist, but it is also in line with the prevention concept laid out in global criminal justice standards.
The only flaw with the act is Article 74, which states that when a young person commits an offense that carries a prison term of up to 10 years, the court can remit the punishment and order protective measures “if a sentence reduced in accordance with Article 59 of the Criminal Code is still too heavy.”
Aside from felonies such as manslaughter or forcing others to commit sexual intercourse, young people are exempt from punishment for most offenses. Such a lenient system could embolden juvenile offenders to commit further crimes, instead of deterring them.
The Juvenile Justice Act’s parameters for pre-deliberation and punishment exemption are too wide, potentially letting off juvenile offenders too easily.
Taiwan’s age of criminal responsibility dates back to the establishment of the Criminal Code in 1935. The regulations should be updated to bring them in line with modern society.
Chao Hsuey-wen is an assistant professor and holds a doctorate in law from Fu Jen Catholic University.
Translated by Rita Wang
We are used to hearing that whenever something happens, it means Taiwan is about to fall to China. Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) cannot change the color of his socks without China experts claiming it means an invasion is imminent. So, it is no surprise that what happened in Venezuela over the weekend triggered the knee-jerk reaction of saying that Taiwan is next. That is not an opinion on whether US President Donald Trump was right to remove Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro the way he did or if it is good for Venezuela and the world. There are other, more qualified
The immediate response in Taiwan to the extraction of Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro by the US over the weekend was to say that it was an example of violence by a major power against a smaller nation and that, as such, it gave Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) carte blanche to invade Taiwan. That assessment is vastly oversimplistic and, on more sober reflection, likely incorrect. Generally speaking, there are three basic interpretations from commentators in Taiwan. The first is that the US is no longer interested in what is happening beyond its own backyard, and no longer preoccupied with regions in other
As technological change sweeps across the world, the focus of education has undergone an inevitable shift toward artificial intelligence (AI) and digital learning. However, the HundrED Global Collection 2026 report has a message that Taiwanese society and education policymakers would do well to reflect on. In the age of AI, the scarcest resource in education is not advanced computing power, but people; and the most urgent global educational crisis is not technological backwardness, but teacher well-being and retention. Covering 52 countries, the report from HundrED, a Finnish nonprofit that reviews and compiles innovative solutions in education from around the world, highlights a
A recent piece of international news has drawn surprisingly little attention, yet it deserves far closer scrutiny. German industrial heavyweight Siemens Mobility has reportedly outmaneuvered long-entrenched Chinese competitors in Southeast Asian infrastructure to secure a strategic partnership with Vietnam’s largest private conglomerate, Vingroup. The agreement positions Siemens to participate in the construction of a high-speed rail link between Hanoi and Ha Long Bay. German media were blunt in their assessment: This was not merely a commercial win, but has symbolic significance in “reshaping geopolitical influence.” At first glance, this might look like a routine outcome of corporate bidding. However, placed in
RSS