German Chancellor Olaf Scholz is considering extending the operational lifetime of Germany’s three active nuclear power stations beyond December, when they are scheduled to go offline.
An Aug. 3 report in the Wall Street Journal said that Scholz ordered a review into postponing the decommissioning of the plants, as Germany faces natural gas supply problems due to the Russia-Ukraine War.
Some Taiwanese media outlets presented the situation in Germany as described above.
However, this does not represent the full picture.
The German Ministry of Economic Affairs and Climate Action on Tuesday last week issued a news release saying that the Wall Street Journal report misrepresents the facts, and that stress tests to check the stability of the country’s power grid are ongoing.
Once the stress tests have been completed, the German government will likely reach one of three conclusions: Take the country’s three remaining nuclear power plants offline on the planned date; adjust the plants’ power generation efficiency and postpone their decommissioning until after the winter; or grant short-term extensions of one to two years to the operational life of the plants as an emergency measure.
It appears that German authorities have not yet reached a conclusion on whether to extend the plants’ operational life, as the facilities have entered the decommissioning phase.
Questions remain over the plants’ operational and financial situations, as well as how to deal with the peripheral decommissioning work already begun.
Given that the stress test is an emergency measure in reaction to the war’s fallout, a postponement of the plants’ decommissioning would be different in nature from a nuclear extension program, which usually adds 10 years to the operational lifetime of a plant.
An earlier news release issued by the ministry provides further indication that Germany might not grant the plant’s extensions.
Announcing the adoption of the “largest acceleration package for the expansion of renewable energy in decades,” the Aug. 7 news release said Germany would “triple” the pace of renewable energy expansion “across the board” to gradually wean itself off its reliance on fossil fuels.
Given the tense situation in the Taiwan Strait, some Taiwanese say the government should extend the operational lives of Taiwan’s nuclear power plants.
However, this would not be a good idea.
The war in Ukraine has seen its nuclear power plants damaged by Russian artillery shells, sparking fears of a nuclear disaster.
The Chinese military has for many years disseminated the idea that if China were to “unify” with Taiwan by force, Beijing would pursue a scorched earth policy, or as it puts it: “The islands will remain, but the people will not.”
If war were to break out with China, the safety of Taiwan’s nuclear power plants would be a cause of concern for Taiwanese government officials.
Others argue that a conflict might involve China imposing a maritime blockade around Taiwan proper so that the nation would need to rely on its nuclear power plants to generate electricity.
However, nuclear power advocates should remember that when power transmission towers collapsed during typhoons in the past, nuclear power plants were shut down for safety reasons.
During a wartime scenario, if Taiwan’s electricity grid were to be affected, the nation’s nuclear power plants would be unable to generate electricity for the same reason. Under such a scenario, the Chinese military would not need to go to the trouble of disrupting international commercial shipping with a blockade of Taiwan, it could cause power blackouts simply by disrupting Taiwan’s power grid, thereby forcing its nuclear power plants offline.
Rather than place one’s hopes on a life extension to Taiwan’s nuclear power plants, it would be better to develop renewable energy, a smart power grid and better storage equipment. This is the only way to simultaneously meet the twin threats of extreme climate events and an invasion or blockade by China.
Furthermore, developing Taiwan’s renewable energy market and attracting more foreign investment would ensure that countries around the world pay close attention to Taiwan’s situation. A thriving green energy market could become Taiwan’s second protective amulet, after its semiconductor industry.
Finally, in addition to energy security and reducing carbon emissions, the government also needs to draft a plan to ensure that households in rural areas benefit from green energy.
Chen Bing-heng is founding chairman of the Matsu Fish Conservation Union.
Translated by Edward Jones
Minister of Labor Hung Sun-han (洪申翰) on April 9 said that the first group of Indian workers could arrive as early as this year as part of a memorandum of understanding (MOU) between the Taipei Economic and Cultural Center in India and the India Taipei Association. Signed in February 2024, the MOU stipulates that Taipei would decide the number of migrant workers and which industries would employ them, while New Delhi would manage recruitment and training. Employment would be governed by the laws of both countries. Months after its signing, the two sides agreed that 1,000 migrant workers from India would
On March 31, the South Korean Ministry of Foreign Affairs released declassified diplomatic records from 1995 that drew wide domestic media attention. One revelation stood out: North Korea had once raised the possibility of diplomatic relations with Taiwan. In a meeting with visiting Chinese officials in May 1995, as then-Chinese president Jiang Zemin (江澤民) prepared for a visit to South Korea, North Korean officials objected to Beijing’s growing ties with Seoul and raised Taiwan directly. According to the newly released records, North Korean officials asked why Pyongyang should refrain from developing relations with Taiwan while China and South Korea were expanding high-level
Japan’s imminent easing of arms export rules has sparked strong interest from Warsaw to Manila, Reuters reporting found, as US President Donald Trump wavers on security commitments to allies, and the wars in Iran and Ukraine strain US weapons supplies. Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi’s ruling party approved the changes this week as she tries to invigorate the pacifist country’s military industrial base. Her government would formally adopt the new rules as soon as this month, three Japanese government officials told Reuters. Despite largely isolating itself from global arms markets since World War II, Japan spends enough on its own
When 17,000 troops from the US, the Philippines, Australia, Japan, Canada, France and New Zealand spread across the Philippine archipelago for the Balikatan military exercise, running from tomorrow through May 8, the official language would be about interoperability, readiness and regional peace. However, the strategic subtext is becoming harder to ignore: The exercises are increasingly about the military geography around Taiwan. Balikatan has always carried political weight. This year, however, the exercise looks different in ways that matter not only to Manila and Washington, but also to Taipei. What began in 2023 as a shift toward a more serious deterrence posture
RSS