On Dec. 25, the Legislative Yuan passed on its third reading amendments to the Civil Code lowering the statutory age of majority from 20 to 18 years old, while also providing for a transitional period before they take effect on Jan. 1, 2023.
Complementary measures that were passed included amending Article 980 of the Civil Code to say that a man or woman aged 18 or younger cannot get married, and deleting Article 981’s provision that “a minor must have the consent of his statutory agent for concluding a marriage.”
It would be fair to say that these amendments are a landmark reform in the history the Civil Code.
However, less attention has been paid to provisions of the Criminal Code regarding the criminal responsibility of minors.
Article 18 of the code states: “An offense committed by a person who is under 14 years of age is not punishable. Punishment may be reduced for an offense committed by a person more than the age of 14, but under the age of 18.”
The forerunner of this article was adopted as part of Shen Jiaben’s (沈家本) legal reforms in the final years of the Qing Dynasty.
At that time, conservative officials were of the opinion that Western laws’ provision that juveniles could be exempt from punishment or have their punishment reduced was well intentioned and could be copied by China.
However, they felt that the original draft’s provision that anyone aged 16 or younger bore no criminal responsibility — no matter how great or small, serious or trivial the offense might be — was too generous in its age range and could be open to abuse.
Article 11 of the New Penal Code of the Great Qing Dynasty, which was enacted in 1911, adopted the compromise that no one aged 12 or younger should be punished for an act, while the punishment could be reduced for those aged 16 or younger. This provision was retained in the 1912 Provisional New Criminal Statute, which was in force in the early years of the Republic of China, following the fall of the Qing Dynasty.
This was followed by the Criminal Code that was adopted in 1928, and is now known as the Former Criminal Code.
In consideration of China’s lack of economic development and limited education system, the 1928 Criminal Code raised the age of criminal responsibility to 13, with reduced penalties for those aged 13 to 16.
The current Criminal Code, which was drawn up in 1935, followed. It increased the age of criminal responsibility by one year to 14, as stipulated in Article 18, which has not been changed since then.
In the UK, since 1998, children are considered responsible for crimes at the age of 10, and there are special prisons for juvenile offenders. The age of criminal responsibility is set at 13 years in France and 12 years in the Netherlands. In Ireland, it was raised from seven to 12 in 2006.
In Germany, which has long been the model for criminal law in Taiwan, children are considered responsible for crimes at the age of 14, the same as in Taiwan.
However, because Germany has in the recent past experienced a number of violent and serious sexual crimes committed by minors, there is ongoing discussion about reducing the age of criminal responsibility to 12.
The provisions of Section 7 of Germany’s Youth Courts Act also give courts the authority to order preventive detention for juvenile offenders. The overall trend in Germany is for its criminal justice policies to become more stringent regarding juvenile offenders.
In Taiwan’s education system, the age of 14 generally coincides with the second year of junior-high school. Today, information networks are highly developed and education is universal, so conditions differ from those of a century ago during the late Qing Dynasty and the early part of the Republic of China. From time to time, juveniles commit serious acts of criminal violence.
However, because of the provisions of Article 18 of the Criminal Code, when dealing with persons aged 14 or younger, courts have no choice but to find them not guilty. The most that courts can do is to order a certain period of reformatory education with restrictions on personal freedom, which has a limited deterrent effect.
At this landmark moment, when the legislature has amended the Civil Code’s definition of the age of majority, it should also give due attention to the matter of the age of criminal responsibility, as defined by Article 18 of the Criminal Code.
Chao Hsuey-wen is a lecturer at Soochow University and a doctoral candidate in Fu Jen Catholic University’s department of law.
Translated by Julian Clegg
The diplomatic dispute between China and Japan over Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi’s comments in the Japanese Diet continues to escalate. In a letter to UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres, China’s UN Ambassador Fu Cong (傅聰) wrote that, “if Japan dares to attempt an armed intervention in the cross-Strait situation, it would be an act of aggression.” There was no indication that Fu was aware of the irony implicit in the complaint. Until this point, Beijing had limited its remonstrations to diplomatic summonses and weaponization of economic levers, such as banning Japanese seafood imports, discouraging Chinese from traveling to Japan or issuing
The diplomatic spat between China and Japan over comments Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi made on Nov. 7 continues to worsen. Beijing is angry about Takaichi’s remarks that military force used against Taiwan by the Chinese People’s Liberation Army (PLA) could constitute a “survival-threatening situation” necessitating the involvement of the Japanese Self-Defense Forces. Rather than trying to reduce tensions, Beijing is looking to leverage the situation to its advantage in action and rhetoric. On Saturday last week, four armed China Coast Guard vessels sailed around the Japanese-controlled Diaoyutai Islands (釣魚台), known to Japan as the Senkakus. On Friday, in what
On Nov. 8, newly elected Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Chairwoman Cheng Li-wun (鄭麗文) and Vice Chairman Chi Lin-len (季麟連) attended a memorial for White Terror era victims, during which convicted Chinese Communist Party (CCP) spies such as Wu Shi (吳石) were also honored. Cheng’s participation in the ceremony, which she said was part of her efforts to promote cross-strait reconciliation, has trapped herself and her party into the KMT’s dark past, and risks putting the party back on its old disastrous road. Wu, a lieutenant general who was the Ministry of National Defense’s deputy chief of the general staff, was recruited
The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) on Nov. 5 recalled more than 150,000 eggs found to contain three times the legal limit of the pesticide metabolite fipronil-sulfone. Nearly half of the 1,169 affected egg cartons, which had been distributed across 10 districts, had already been sold. Using the new traceability system, officials quickly urged the public to avoid consuming eggs with the traceability code “I47045,” while the remainder were successfully recalled. Changhua County’s Wenya Farm — the source of the tainted eggs — was fined NT$120,000, and the Ministry of Agriculture instructed the county’s Animal Disease Control Center to require that
RSS