The voters of Monroe County, Michigan, might have expected an economic windfall when they flipped from supporting Democrat then-US president Barack Obama to help put US President Donald Trump in the White House in 2016.
However, it went the other way: Through the first three years of the Trump administration, the county lost jobs and brought in slightly less in wages in the first three months of this year than in the first three months of 2017 as Trump was taking over.
That was before the COVID-19 pandemic and the associated recession.
Photo: EPA-EFE
With the US election just days away, recently released government data and new analysis show just how little progress Trump made in changing the trajectory of the Rust Belt region that propelled his improbable rise to the White House.
While job and wage growth continued nationally under Trump, extending trends that took root under Obama, the country’s economic weight also continued shifting south and west, according to data from the US Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages (QCEW) that was recently updated to include the first three months of this year.
A study from the Economic Innovation Group (EIG) pointed to the same conclusion. It found relative stagnation in economic and social conditions in the Midwest compared with states like Texas or Tennessee where “superstar” cities, such as Dallas and Nashville, enjoyed more of the spoils of a decade-long US expansion.
Across the industrial belt from Wisconsin to Pennsylvania, private job growth from the first three months of 2017 through the first three months of this year lagged the rest of the US — with employment in Michigan, Wisconsin and Ohio growing 2 percent or less over that period compared with a 4.5 percent national average, according to QCEW data.
By contrast, Texas and California saw job growth of more than 6 percent from 2017 through the start of this year, while Idaho led the nation with employment growing more than 10 percent.
Perhaps notably for the election, an analysis of 17 prominent counties in the five battleground states of Florida, Michigan, Ohio, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin showed the limits of Trump’s controversial tax and trade policies in generating jobs where he promised them. All 17 of the counties had a voting-age population greater than 100,000 people as of 2016, supported Obama in the 2012 election and voted for Trump in 2016.
In 13 of those counties, all in the Rust Belt region, private job growth lagged the rest of the country. Employment actually shrank in five of them. Of the four with faster job growth than the rest of the country, two were in Florida, one was in Pennsylvania and one was in Wisconsin.
The findings show that under the “greatest economy ever” boasts that Trump made before the pandemic, when job and wage growth were indeed strong, the fundamental contours of regional US prosperity seemed largely unchanged.
Some of that might have stemmed from Trump’s own policies. The use of steel tariffs, for example, might have ended up costing Michigan jobs.
“The key battleground areas ... have not fared well under President Trump, even prior to the pandemic,” Moody’s Analytics chief economist Mark Zandi said.
The swing state counties most supportive of Trump in 2016 were “especially vulnerable” to the president’s trade war tactics because of their ties to global markets, he said.
However, Trump was also swimming against a very strong tide, driven by forces bigger than a tweet or a tariff can likely counter.
For decades, people, capital and economic output have been shifting from a mid-20th century concentration in the US northeast and Midwest to the open land, cheaper wages and more temperate climate of the Sun Belt, and the innovation corridor from Silicon Valley to Washington state.
Trump, in his 2016 campaign, put a premium on manufacturing jobs — last century’s path to the middle class — and as president used a combination of trade policy, tariffs and blunt force arm-twisting on companies to try to shore up the prospects of the industrial heartland that formed his electoral base.
It did not happen. Texas, according to QCEW data, gained more manufacturing jobs from 2017 to the start of this year than Ohio, Michigan, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania combined; the smaller, but increasingly competitive manufacturing cluster in Tennessee, Georgia, South Carolina and Alabama gained as many factory positions as those legacy manufacturing states.
While Trump might have failed in his efforts to reinvigorate the Rust Belt, the forces acting against the region predate his administration.
A longer-term analysis by the EIG, looking at outcomes across an index of social and economic measures, showed little progress from the start of the century through 2018.
According to an analysis of EIG data, two to three times as many counties in Ohio, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin slipped further down the think tank’s Distressed Communities Index as climbed to a more prosperous bracket over those nearly two decades.
In Florida and Washington state, by contrast, five times as many counties moved into a more well-off bracket, and in California three times as many counties prospered.
EIG research director Kenan Fikri said it was “easy to forget” that the Midwest and Great Lakes regions were once the “pinnacle of what the US had to offer” before the economy shifted to a more technology, service-oriented and global footing.
“We have seen the gravity of economic well-being take a dramatic shift to the west... It continued unabated through the first several years of the Trump administration,” he said.
PRICE HIKES: The war in the Middle East would not significantly disrupt supply in the short term, but semiconductor companies are facing price surges for materials Taiwan’s semiconductor companies are not facing imminent supply disruptions of essential chemicals or raw materials due to the war in the Middle East, but surges in material costs loom large, industry association SEMI Taiwan said yesterday. The association’s comments came amid growing concerns that supplies of helium and other key raw materials used in semiconductor production could become a choke point after Qatar shut down its liquefied natural gas (LNG) production and helium output earlier this month due to the conflict. Qatar is the second-largest LNG supplier in the world and accounts for about 33 percent of global helium output. Helium is
DOMESTIC COMPONENT: Huang identified several Taiwanese partners to be a key part of Nvidia’s Vera Rubin supply chain, including Asustek, Hon Hai and Wistron Nvidia Corp chief executive officer Jensen Huang (黃仁勳), addressing crowds at the company’s biggest annual event, unveiled a variety of new products while predicting that its flagship artificial intelligence (AI) processors would help generate US$1 trillion in sales through next year. During a two-and-a-half-hour keynote address, Huang announced plans to push deeper into central processing units (CPUs) — Intel Corp’s home turf — and introduced semiconductors made with technology acquired from start-up Groq Inc. The company even said it was developing chips for data centers in outer space. At the heart of Huang’s speech was the message that demand for computing power
OPTIMISTIC: Inflation still has a chance of remaining below the central bank’s 2 percent alert level, as Taiwan’s economy is resilient with healthy exports, the NDC minister said Taiwan’s inflation could exceed 2 percent this year if oil prices continue to surge amid escalating tensions in the Middle East, prompting the government to reassess its economic outlook, the Directorate-General of Budget, Accounting and Statistics (DGBAS) said yesterday. DGBAS Minister Chen Shu-tzu (陳淑姿) told lawmakers at a meeting of the legislature’s Finance Committee that the agency’s earlier growth forecast of 1.68 percent in the consumer price index (CPI) and 7.71 percent for GDP this year did not account for the ongoing Middle East conflict and would need revision, if tensions persist. The previous forecast assumed an average international crude price of
ELECTRIC DREAMS: Smart cities would use ‘virtual power plants,’ which integrate idle electricity use from households, businesses and factories, Asustek said Asustek Computer Inc (華碩) yesterday showcased key components of its artificial intelligence (AI)-driven smart city initiatives at a trade show in Taipei, eyeing new business opportunities as cities develop sovereign AI infrastructure. Advances in generative, multimodal and physical AI are driving cities toward a new phase of “sovereign AI,” Asustek cochief executive officer Samson Hu (胡書賓) told reporters on the sidelines of the Smart City Summit and Expo at Taipei Nangang Exhibition Center’s Hall 2. The company showcased its “AI City” framework, which comprises three layers — computing infrastructure centered on AI servers, AI models and a platform layer for data processing
RSS