Fri, Apr 02, 2010 - Page 6 News List

Reports framed to avoid war: ElBaradei

LETHAL COVER-UP? The former chief of the UN’s nuclear agency said that despite its technical status, the organization’s work is deeply politicized, especially over Iran


The UN’s former top nuclear watchdog said on Wednesday his cautious language in reports about Iran’s nuclear program was part of a deliberate policy to keep a lid on tensions and avert a rush to war.

Mohamed ElBaradei, who was director-general of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) for 12 years before stepping down in November, pleaded with the international community to “learn the lessons” of the Iraq invasion and prevent further conflict in the Middle East.

In an interview, he said that despite its technical status, the IAEA’s work was deeply politicized.

“We are a technical organization totally embedded in a political setting,” ElBaradei said, “and we have to be aware of the background and political implications of our work.”

ElBaradei, who was jointly awarded the Nobel peace prize in 2005 along with the IAEA, has been criticized by some for allegedly toning down agency reports on the threat posed by Iran.

A report earlier this year — the first under the stewardship of ­ElBaradei’s successor, Yukiya Amano — was noted for its blunter language concerning Iran’s nuclear program, prompting some to accuse ElBaradei of concealing facts.

“It is now clear that ... ­ElBaradei was engaged in what may well prove to be the most lethal cover-up in human history,” a Forbes magazine columnist said following the report’s publication.

ElBaradei denied any cover-up had taken place, but acknowledged he believed he had a duty to frame agency reports in a way that could not be exploited by those seeking war. “When I was working at the agency we would literally go through 30 drafts or so of each report before it was ready, because I knew every word could be used politically and in a very subjective way,” he said. “Every word was weighed to make sure that it was immune from being abused and I always wanted to make sure that we were not overstating or understating, but rather just stating the facts.”

He rejected suggestions this amounted to undue political interference in the agency’s work.

“I think the tone was set by me, that’s true,” he said. “But all the facts were in every report, unvarnished.”

His cautious reports are in contrast to the title of his memoirs, Crawling Away From Armageddon, to be published later this year.

The book is expected to reveal details of ElBaradei’s private conversations with US officials, with whom he fought in vain to avoid a US-led invasion of Iraq.

“I would hope that the lessons of Iraq, both in London and in the US have started to sink in,” he said. “Sure there are dictators, but are you ready every time you want to get rid of a dictator to sacrifice a million innocent civilians?”

Comments will be moderated. Keep comments relevant to the article. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned. Final decision will be at the discretion of the Taipei Times.

TOP top