Wed, May 22, 2013 - Page 11 News List

Blogger charged with libel for lambasting novel’s translation
罵人亂翻譯 不懂日文當庭漏氣

The cover of the Chinese version of The Hentai Prince and the Stony Cat published in Taiwan.

Photo: Yu Jui-jen, Liberty Times

After reading a Chinese translation of a Japanese light novel, a 22-year-old man from Taoyuan County, surnamed Wu, went on his blog to criticize the allegedly poor translation, reprehending it by saying that “anyone who reads this translation will go insane,” and telling the translator to give up his vocation immediately. After being informed of the situation, the translator, surnamed Huang, decided to take Wu to court. Wu was unable to read aloud from the original Japanese book during the hearing when the prosecutor asked him to do so, so the prosecutor said that he was not proficient enough in Japanese to ascertain whether the translation was accurate. On May 9, Wu was brought up on libel charges.

According to the prosecutor’s investigation, Wu purchased the second installment of The Hentai Prince and the Stony Cat, translated by Huang and published by Sharp Point Publishing. After reading the book, Wu went on a blogging Web site three times to post ill-intended comments that were highly critical of the translation for its alleged plethora of mistakes, saying that “the indiscriminate translation lacks any sense of unity,” and asking whether it was “translated using Google Translate.”

During the prosecutor’s investigation, Wu admitted that he had gone online to criticize the translation, claiming to have reached an intermediate reading level after studying Japanese for five years, and going on to point out 122 alleged mistakes in the translation, which caused him to feel dissatisfied with the experience of reading the book and subsequently go online to post the comments.

(Liberty Times, Translated by Kyle Jeffcoat)



1. vocation n.

行業;職業 (hang2 ye4; zhi2 ye4)

例: Most university graduates end up choosing a vocation that is not related to their major.


2. plethora n.

過多 (guo4 duo1)

例: A plethora of bands will be performing at the festival this year.


3. indiscriminate adj.

雜亂無章的;任意的 (za2 luan4 wu2 zhang1 de5; ren4 yi4 de5)

例: The terrorists’ indiscriminate bombing of the event killed hundreds of innocent civilians.





This story has been viewed 3122 times.

Comments will be moderated. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned.

TOP top