Taiwan's music industry suffered a setback yesterday when the Shihlin District Court found a local peer-to-peer (P2P) file-sharing operator not guilty of infringing intellectual property rights.
In the nation's first ruling on file-sharing cases, the court found that Weber Wu (吳怡達), president of Ezpeer -- which provides a for-fee platform for subscribers to swap files -- did not engage in reproducing or publicly distributing works of copyright holders.
The court also said that current laws and regulations do not specifically ban or limit file-sharing activities.
"We will keep negotiating with record labels to find a way that would create benefits for us, the copyright holders and consumers," Wu said at a press conference yesterday after the verdict was announced.
The plaintiff, the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry (IFPI) in Taiwan, which represents major record labels, said it would appeal the verdict.
"This is the darkest day for the music industry," said Robin Lee (
Lee said the association would also target individual file-sharers for further legal action.
The association has been waging a legal war on P2P operators for three years. A similar lawsuit against kuro.com.tw, Taiwan's largest file-sharing site, has yet to be decided.
Lee said yesterday's verdict would batter the already sagging music industry, citing the failure of the nation's first legal online music distributor, iBIZ Entertainment Technology Corp, which was launched in November 2003, but shut down after 15 months.
The verdict is also a slap in the face to Taiwan's national image, as many countries have found P2P operators liable for infringing copyrights, Lee said.
Taiwan has been trying to improve its intellectual property rights (IPR) protection for several years. In January, the nation was finally taken off the US Trade Representative's "Priority Watch List" and put on the less severe "Watch List" of IPR violators under the US' Special 301 Law. One of the major reasons the US continues to list Taiwan as an IPR violator is rampant file-sharing activities.
Two IPR experts criticized yesterday's ruling.
Taiwan should match the US Supreme Court's ruling on Monday that found file-sharing companies liable for encouraging third parties to use their products to infringe copyrights, said Paul Liu (
Liu said unauthorized use of file-sharing software only serves to discourage song writers or movie producers from creating original works.
John Eastwood, a lawyer with Wenger & Vieli and co-chairman of the Intellectual Property Committee of the European Chamber of Commerce Taipei, said public awareness of IPR protection in Taiwan should also be enhanced to block file-sharing operators.
"The business model of Apple Computer Inc's iTune music store apparently is not viable here, as consumers have long enjoyed free downloading from the Internet," Eastwood said. "I think consumer education is going to be one of the next big battles."
CROSS-STRAIT COLLABORATION: The new KMT chairwoman expressed interest in meeting the Chinese president from the start, but she’ll have to pay to get in Beijing allegedly agreed to let Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Chairwoman Cheng Li-wun (鄭麗文) meet with Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) around the Lunar New Year holiday next year on three conditions, including that the KMT block Taiwan’s arms purchases, a source said yesterday. Cheng has expressed interest in meeting Xi since she won the KMT’s chairmanship election in October. A source, speaking on condition of anonymity, said a consensus on a meeting was allegedly reached after two KMT vice chairmen visited China’s Taiwan Affairs Office Director Song Tao (宋濤) in China last month. Beijing allegedly gave the KMT three conditions it had to
STAYING ALERT: China this week deployed its largest maritime show of force to date in the region, prompting concern in Taipei and Tokyo, which Beijing has brushed off Deterring conflict over Taiwan is a priority, the White House said in its National Security Strategy published yesterday, which also called on Japan and South Korea to increase their defense spending to help protect the first island chain. Taiwan is strategically positioned between Northeast and Southeast Asia, and provides direct access to the second island chain, with one-third of global shipping passing through the South China Sea, the report said. Given the implications for the US economy, along with Taiwan’s dominance in semiconductors, “deterring a conflict over Taiwan, ideally by preserving military overmatch, is a priority,” it said. However, the strategy also reiterated
‘BALANCE OF POWER’: Hegseth said that the US did not want to ‘strangle’ China, but to ensure that none of Washington’s allies would be vulnerable to military aggression Washington has no intention of changing the “status quo” in the Taiwan Strait, US Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth said on Saturday, adding that one of the US military’s main priorities is to deter China “through strength, not through confrontation.” Speaking at the annual Reagan National Defense Forum in Simi Valley, California, Hegseth outlined the US Department of Defense’s priorities under US President Donald Trump. “First, defending the US homeland and our hemisphere. Second, deterring China through strength, not confrontation. Third, increased burden sharing for us, allies and partners. And fourth, supercharging the US defense industrial base,” he said. US-China relations under
The Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) caucus yesterday decided to shelve proposed legislation that would give elected officials full control over their stipends, saying it would wait for a consensus to be reached before acting. KMT Legislator Chen Yu-jen (陳玉珍) last week proposed amendments to the Organic Act of the Legislative Yuan (立法院組織法) and the Regulations on Allowances for Elected Representatives and Subsidies for Village Chiefs (地方民意代表費用支給及村里長事務補助費補助條例), which would give legislators and councilors the freedom to use their allowances without providing invoices for reimbursement. The proposal immediately drew criticism, amid reports that several legislators face possible charges of embezzling fees intended to pay
RSS