Fri, Sep 08, 2017 - Page 8 News List

Limit the work hours of physicians

By Chien Jien-wen 錢建文

A young woman named Libby Zion on Mar. 4, 1984, was admitted to New York Hospital. She was given the wrong medicine by a resident physician who was, at the time, dealing with 40 other patients and was exhausted from having worked too many hours without a break. Zion died about eight hours later in the hospital.

Her enraged parents sued the hospital, and the case led to the Libby Zion Law being passed in New York State in 1989. The law limits the number of hours that resident physicians are allowed to work without a break.

On Oct. 16, 2009, a sleep-deprived long-distance bus driver traveling along the Sun Yat-sen Freeway (Freeway No. 1) near Yuanlin Township (員林) in Changhua County failed to brake in time and plowed into 13 stationary cars in front of him, killing four people and injuring six.

This was not the first time that a fatal accident occurred due to a lack of limits on driving hours for mass transport drivers.

In response to an incensed public, the Control Yuan on Jan. 14, 2010, admonished Council of Labor Affairs and the Ministry of Transportation and Communications.

On Feb. 3 that year, the ministry implemented a regulation stating that long-distance transportation drivers could not drive more than four hours without a break of 30 minutes.

The bus company involved in the accident in question had actually introduced its own regulation before the ministry’s was legislated, to the effect that there must be a change of drivers at the halfway point, in central Taiwan.

Human factors theory provides the academic basis for limiting work hours. In certain situations, humans cannot but commit errors. These circumstances include being overtired, emergency situations and overwork.

For this reason, the aviation industry has long maintained restrictions on pilots’ flight hours. Aviation accident reports always include an investigation into whether the pilot was overworked.

In announcing the findings of the TransAsia Airways Flight GE222 that crashed on July 23, 2014, the Aviation Safety Council said that the pilots being overtired was to a small degree one of the factors contributing to the crash.

Medical research into sleep has also shown that a person’s ability to perform tasks that require thinking and making decisions is distinctly reduced when that person is sleep-deprived.

The nature of the medical profession is such that all three of these circumstances — being overtired, emergency situations and overwork — are involved.

To this cocktail is added the need for accurate cognition and inference in making correct diagnoses, providing the perfect recipe for medical professionals making mistakes when tired.

Research worldwide has confirmed that medical mistakes happen everywhere, leading to considerable loss of human life.

In December 1992, the US Institute of Medicine — now the US National Academy of Medicine — published a report estimating that as many as 44,000 to 98,000 fatalities were caused every year by avoidable medical negligence, making it No. 8 of the top 10 causes of death in the US.

Academics have estimated that, in Taiwan, medical negligence is responsible for 6,000 to 20,000 deaths a year, and for harming as many as 80,000 patients.

Consequently, the most important reason for restricting doctors’ work hours is to avoid causing harm to the patients.

This story has been viewed 8309 times.

Comments will be moderated. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned.

TOP top