Minister of the Interior Jiang Yi-huah (江宜樺) said recently that sex trade workers could be allowed to work in “individual studios” of three to five workers not restricted to specific red light districts, although they should be kept out of residential districts or areas where schools, universities or places of worship are located. As we see it, the Ministry of the Interior’s proposal represents a practical approach to the problem, compared with simply restricting the sex industry to red light districts.
First of all, is it really the case that should the ministry’s goal of keeping the sex trade out of specific areas be adopted, that prostitution will crop up everywhere else around the city? Luxury apartment block tenants will occasionally call sex trade workers over to their homes for sex, but this kind of behavior does not necessarily disturb the neighbors and there are varying opinions as to the morality of this kind of thing.
The sex trade is fundamentally comprised of business transactions and it will tend to gravitate toward areas where there is a sufficient customer base and support network. By this we mean business districts where a lot of people come and go, neighborhoods which have developed into suitable locations for sex trade work for historical reasons, or places where there is a higher level of tolerance for such activities. It is not the case, then, that the entire country will become one big red light district.
Local residents are naturally going to have doubts and concerns about issues of law and order and personal safety if sex trade studios start cropping up in their neighborhoods. They will not want the studios to be overly conspicuous or visible. We need to find a way to make sure these concerns are addressed, tailored to individual localities.
The ministry’s solution of prohibiting such studios within residential areas is simply introducing rigid legislation from outside. It does not give any provision for self-regulation, such as relying on the work ethic of the sex trade workers themselves, or for local mechanisms to coordinate the situation.
Another issue is that many towns and cities in Taiwan are not strictly zoned: It is quite common for any given district to be both residential and commercial at the same time. This presents considerable problems for how this proposal could be policed. We feel that this is where the crux of the problem lies.
Many local community leaders have over the years adopted a flexible approach, accommodating residents while giving sex workers space to make a living. Many apartment blocks have their own rules and regulations to adhere to and these often deal with the issue as well. Examples like these, where a certain degree of mutual respect is adopted, are the way to go. The Order Maintenance Act (社會秩序維護法) contains a number of clauses related to public order, so that when the police receive a complaint they will be able to investigate and uphold the law, ensuring that local residents’ rights can be guaranteed, and giving both parties room to provide their own account.
The relationship between sex trade workers and the community is not a zero-sum game: It is not the case that one side necessarily has to gain at the expense of the other. If prostitution is legalized, sex trade workers will have an incentive to form workers’ organizations and regulate themselves. With the assistance and coordinated effort of apartment committees, community leaders and even the police, it might be possible to both work for the public good as well as to advance sex workers’ rights.
Chung Chun-chu is the chief executive officer of the Collective of Sex Workers and Supporters (COSWAS). Wu Jo-ying is a secretary at COSWAS.
TRANSLATED BY PAUL COOPER
In the past month, two important developments are poised to equip Taiwan with expanded capabilities to play foreign policy offense in an age where Taiwan’s diplomatic space is seriously constricted by a hegemonic Beijing. Taiwan Foreign Minister Lin Chia-lung (林佳龍) led a delegation of Taiwan and US companies to the Philippines to promote trilateral economic cooperation between the three countries. Additionally, in the past two weeks, Taiwan has placed chip export controls on South Africa in an escalating standoff over the placing of its diplomatic mission in Pretoria, causing the South Africans to pause and ask for consultations to resolve
An altercation involving a 73-year-old woman and a younger person broke out on a Taipei MRT train last week, with videos of the incident going viral online, sparking wide discussions about the controversial priority seats and social norms. In the video, the elderly woman, surnamed Tseng (曾), approached a passenger in a priority seat and demanded that she get up, and after she refused, she swung her bag, hitting her on the knees and calves several times. In return, the commuter asked a nearby passenger to hold her bag, stood up and kicked Tseng, causing her to fall backward and
In December 1937, Japanese troops captured Nanjing and unleashed one of the darkest chapters of the 20th century. Over six weeks, hundreds of thousands were slaughtered and women were raped on a scale that still defies comprehension. Across Asia, the Japanese occupation left deep scars. Singapore, Malaya, the Philippines and much of China endured terror, forced labor and massacres. My own grandfather was tortured by the Japanese in Singapore. His wife, traumatized beyond recovery, lived the rest of her life in silence and breakdown. These stories are real, not abstract history. Here is the irony: Mao Zedong (毛澤東) himself once told visiting
When I reminded my 83-year-old mother on Wednesday that it was the 76th anniversary of the founding of the People’s Republic of China, she replied: “Yes, it was the day when my family was broken.” That answer captures the paradox of modern China. To most Chinese in mainland China, Oct. 1 is a day of pride — a celebration of national strength, prosperity and global stature. However, on a deeper level, it is also a reminder to many of the families shattered, the freedoms extinguished and the lives sacrificed on the road here. Seventy-six years ago, Chinese Communist leader Mao Zedong (毛澤東)
RSS