Sat, Feb 11, 2006 - Page 9 News List

Censorship in China is not as easy as it looks


For months now, the news about the news in China has been awful. Carrying out its vow to tighten controls over what it calls "propaganda," the government of President Hu Jintao (胡錦濤) has busied itself closing publications, firing editorial staff and jailing reporters.

More noticeably, the government has clamped down on the Internet, closing blogger sites, filtering e-mail messages and Web sites for banned words and tightening controls on text messages.

Last year, Yahoo was criticized for revealing the identity of an Internet journalist, Shi Tao (師濤), who was subsequently jailed. On Wednesday, the Committee to Protect Journalists said court documents posted on a Chinese Web site showed that Yahoo had done the same in 2003, resulting in the jailing of another writer, Li Zhi (李志)

Against this grim backdrop, the news that Google had agreed to apply censors' blacklists to its new Chinese search engine might have seemed like the ultimate nail in the coffin for freedom of information in this country. Chinese Internet mavens were outraged at Google for collaborating in the government's censorship effort.

"For most people, access to more diversified resources has been broken," said Isaac Mao (毛向輝), a popular Chinese blogger, in a typical sentiment.

"The majority of users, the new users, will only see a compressed version of Google, and can't know what they don't know. This is like taking a 30-year-old's brain and setting him back to the mind of a 15-year-old," he said.

Some threatened that Internet companies that toed the government line would regret it someday.

"Doing the bidding of the Chinese government like this is like doing the bidding of Stalin or Hitler," said Yu Jie (余杰), a well-known dissident writer.

"The actions of companies that did the bidding of Stalin and Hitler have been remembered by history, and the Chinese people won't forget these kinds of actions, either," Yu said.

Whether the Chinese will hold a long-term grudge is arguable. But Web specialists are far more confident that the government will fail in its efforts to reverse a trend toward increasingly free expression that has been reshaping this society with ever more powerful effects for more than two decades.

Last year, China ranked 159th out of 167 countries in a survey of press freedom, Reporters Without Borders, the Paris-based international rights group, said. But rankings like this do not reflect the rapid change afoot here, more and more of which is escaping the government's control.

A case in point is the Chinese government's recent effort to rein in bloggers who tread too often into delicate territory, criticizing state policy or detailing official corruption. In December, the government ordered Microsoft and its MSN service to close the site of Michael Anti, one of China's most popular bloggers.

Although Anti -- who is also an employee of the Beijing bureau of the New York Times -- had his site closed, any Chinese Web surfer can choose from scores of other online commentators who are equally provocative, and more are coming online all the time.

Microsoft alone carries an estimated 3.3 million blogs in China. Add to that the estimated 10 million other blogs on other Internet service providers, and it becomes clear what a censor's nightmare China has become.

What is more, not a single blog existed in China a little more than three years ago, and thousands upon thousands are being born every day -- some run by people whose previous blogs had been banned and merely change their name or switch providers. New technologies, like pod casts, are making things even harder to control.

This story has been viewed 3619 times.

Comments will be moderated. Keep comments relevant to the article. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned. Final decision will be at the discretion of the Taipei Times.

TOP top