Sun, Jul 04, 2004 - Page 9 News List

The link between scares, sperm counts and cellphones

A finding that mobile phones can reduce men's sperm count has been widely reported despite the limitations of the research. But why are the media so ready to fall for healthe scares?

By Vivienne Parry  /  THE GUARDIAN , LONDON

ILLUSTRATION: JUNE HSU

There is only one word for the "mobile phones cut sperm by a third" story that emerged from this week's meeting of the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology: nonsense.

The work, which conference organizers refused to release formally to the press because of "limitations" in the study design, made it to front pages worldwide. The study involved just 221 men and claimed that those who had their phone on standby throughout the day had about a third fewer sperm than men who did not. Those who carried phones in pockets or on belt loops were apparently more likely to be among the sperm-depleted.

Let me expound on the subject of sperm for a moment. Whether a semen sample is bursting with the beasts or not is subject to innumerable factors: age, how much you drink, your general health, stress, whether you smoke or take drugs, and how often, as I believe the expression goes, you bash your bishop (frequent bashing means higher sperm counts).

Abstinence is bad news for sperm, as the body operates on a use-it-or-lose-it principle. The more your various activities demand, the more your body thinks you need, and scales up production accordingly.

But a man who has successfully impregnated six women in a marathon all-day session would technically be deemed infertile the next, on account of him having exhausted his supply and having only a lonely few left.

Occupation is also significant. Truck and taxi drivers have lower counts because sitting all day means their testicles are held to the body and kept at a greater-than-optimal temperature. Painters and decorators have lower counts, probably because of solvent use.

Oh. And nationality. New Yorkers have loads and men in Finland, the home of Nokia phones, have the highest sperm counts on the planet.

Whatever those Finns are doing, its effect on their sperm counts is awesome.

Did the Hungarian researchers take account of any of these important variables? No, and with such a vanishingly small sample, the statistical power of such an exercise is zero.

Nevertheless, this "phones knacker your sperm" story will seep into international consciousness. In five years' time, there will still be companies taking advantage of this research in sales literature advertising supposedly safer cellphone devices. It is partly this commercial piggybacking that perpetuates these scares.

We are also particularly receptive to the "end of fertility as we know it" stories because for there have been years of reports of plummeting sperm counts. Experts are divided as to whether this is a true decrease or simply one of those reporting glitches, but the notion of men being emasculated by lifestyle again fits with our fears of fertility under threat. If sperm counts were falling as dramatically as claimed, all men would be infertile by now. The truth is that nature supplies hundreds of millions per shot and it only takes one. Trust me, the end of humankind is not here. But we'll probably go on thinking it is for some time.

There are plenty of other examples of long-running scares. The one about deodorants causing breast cancer, which is as nonsensical, has been doing the rounds for the best part of a decade. The theory that green bits on potatoes cause spina bifida was another scare that took years to eradicate. Then there was the furor over the third-generation pill in 1995, which was about thrombosis risk -- it catapulted women to a 30 cases per 100,000 risk on these types of pill, yet pregnancy carries a 60 cases per 100,000 risk of thrombosis. Still women are suspicious of something that prevents them from becoming pregnant.

This story has been viewed 3648 times.

Comments will be moderated. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned.

TOP top