Sweden’s forest industry has prepared a defense against critics who say trees should be left in the forest to bind carbon and help fight climate change.
At the heart of the conflict is the EU’s need to regulate sustainable activities across the bloc, where forest-based carbon sinks are on average declining, in net terms.
That has prompted concerns that forestry accumulates a so-called carbon debt, because trees take several decades to grow back.
Photo: AFP
In densely forested Sweden, the industry is keen to show that trees are, overall, sequestering more carbon dioxide than is released. The companies, who make their profit from pulp, packaging and timber, commissioned a study that shows a bigger climate benefit from cutting trees than reducing or halting harvests.
The math in the report published yesterday centers on displacement effects. Fossil fuels can be left underground if wood is used to replace such materials, resulting in smaller carbon dioxide emissions than keeping forests intact, but using materials such as plastic instead.
The industry says that a carbon-debt calculation is nonsensical in a forest that is managed in a sustainable manner, such as in Sweden, where trees are replanted, increasing standing volume and wood supply.
That is in contrast to clearing rainforests for palm-oil plantations, resulting in deforestation and the loss of biomass, it says.
“If you leave a tree for long enough, it will die and release the carbon into the atmosphere again. Over time, it’s a zero-sum game,” said Henrik Sjolund, chief executive officer of Holmen AB, a Swedish timber producer. “What’s best for the climate is to harvest as much as possible without reducing the carbon sink in the standing forest, and to replace fossil materials such as concrete, steel, plastics and fossil fuels with bio products.”
For environmentalists, carbon debt is “the biggest problem” the industry poses from a climate-change perspective, said Elin Gotmark, spokeswoman for Swedish non-governmental organization (NGO) Protect the Forest.
“It takes time for trees to grow back, and the soil to accumulate carbon again,” Gotmark said in an e-mailed response to questions before the industry’s study was published.
Forestry “decreases the total amount of carbon stored in the land ecosystems,” she said.
The industry’s strife with the EU began in February, when European Commissioner for Climate Action Frans Timmermans said that the state of Sweden’s forests was worsening.
Sweden needs to adapt its forestry to rising temperatures and increase biodiversity to boost resilience, Timmermans said.
Another climate controversy involving forests concerns the use of biomass as a source of renewable energy.
NGOs have accused the commission of watering down its proposed Taxonomy of Sustainable Activities, calling on it to remove forest biomass as a combustible raw material from its Renewable Energy Directive.
Yet in the Nordic region, the industry says that it only uses scraps and leftovers for power.
Wood is so expensive and grows so slowly compared with tropical areas that it is unprofitable to use timber for energy, companies say.
“It makes no sense to grow trees only to produce bioenergy,” Sjolund said. “Why would anyone do that? We grow trees to build houses and homes out of the logs, that’s the logical business model for a Swedish forest owner to earn money.”
Some time before September, a massive explosion 3,000 light years from Earth is to flare up in the night sky, giving amateur astronomers a once-in-a-lifetime chance to witness this space oddity. The binary star system in the constellation Corona Borealis — “northern crown” — is normally too dim to see with the naked eye. Every 80 years or so, exchanges between its two stars, which are locked in a deadly embrace, spark a runaway nuclear explosion. The light from the blast travels through the cosmos and makes it appear as if a new star — as bright as the North Star, according
The US is warning allies that China has stepped up its support for Russia, including by providing geospatial intelligence, to help Moscow in its war against Ukraine. Amid signs of continued military integration between the two nations, China has provided Russia with satellite imagery for military purposes, as well as microelectronics and machine tools for tanks, people familiar with the matter said. China’s support also includes optics, propellants to be used in missiles and increased space cooperation, one of the people said. US President Joe Biden raised concerns with Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) during their call this week about China’s support for
DISADVANTAGE: Erin O’Toole, who led the Conservatives during the election campaign in 2021, estimated that the interference cost his party as many as nine legislative seats Canada’s domestic spy agency on Monday concluded that China interfered in the past two elections, an official probe heard, the firmest evidence so far of suspected Chinese meddling in Canadian politics. Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s Liberal Party won both the elections, held in 2019 and 2021. Under pressure from opposition lawmakers unhappy about media reports on China’s possible role, Trudeau set up a commission into foreign interference. The commission was shown a slide on Monday containing an extract of a briefing in February last year from the Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS). “We know that the PRC [People’s Republic of China] clandestinely
‘OUTRAGE’: Local media showed the head of the Mexican diplomatic mission struggle with Ecuadoran agents, who were arresting Jorge Glas from the embassy Ecuadoran authorities on Friday stormed the Mexican embassy in Quito to arrest former Ecuadoran vice president Jorge Glas, who was taking refuge there, prompting Mexico to sever diplomatic ties after the “violation of international law.” Images taken by Agence France-Presse showed police special forces massed outside the embassy and at least one of them scaling its walls, which were already surrounded by police and military. Mexican President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador said authorities “forcibly entered” the building to arrest Glas. “This is a flagrant violation of international law and the sovereignty of Mexico,” he wrote on X. Mexican Secretary of Foreign Affairs Alicia Barcena