The Swiss this week strongly rejected accusations that a deal allowing Chinese officials to enter Switzerland and interrogate Chinese nationals, which came to light this summer, put dissidents at risk.
Switzerland entered into a so-called readmission agreement with China in 2015. The deal expired on Monday.
The agreement, which remained a secret until Swiss newspaper NZZ revealed its existence in August, specified the terms for Chinese officials to travel to the country and interrogate Chinese nationals set for deportation.
Asia-focused rights group Safeguard Defenders this week published the text of the deal, plus a report about how it differed from similar agreements with other countries, and could pose a threat to “those the Chinese government wants to be returned.”
The details coming to light are “going to tarnish Switzerland’s reputation,” said Peter Dahlin, who heads the organization.
Following the initial revelation of the agreement, since-jailed Hong Kong dissident Joshua Wong weighed in on Twitter, decrying the secretive nature of the deal.
“Five years after the secret deal was signed, no Swiss MP had ever heard of the deal,” he wrote on Aug. 24, warning that “dissidents in exile” from Hong Kong, Taiwan and elsewhere, could risk extradition to China.
The Swiss State Secretariat for Migration denied that there was anything secretive about the China deal, insisting it was a standard, “technical arrangement” like the ones it had reached with 60 other nations.
While the agreement had never been posted publicly like many such deals, it “can be obtained on request at any time,” it said in a statement.
Ministry spokesman Reto Kormann said in an e-mail that persons seen as threatened, like Uighurs or Tibetans, would not be considered for expulsion, and “would not be questioned by Chinese officials.”
He said that readmission agreements were needed because “most states are only willing to take back their own citizens if they can verify their identity.”
“Accordingly, such interviews are standard practice in Switzerland as in other European states,” he added.
The China deal had been put to use only once in the past five years, in 2016, the ministry said.
During that mission, “two Chinese officials stayed in Switzerland for several days to interview a total of 13 people,” it said.
The Safeguard Defenders report maintained that Switzerland’s deal with China was in no way like its agreements with other countries.
The report compared the deal to ones Switzerland has with Sweden, India, Hong Kong and Britain, and said it found glaring differences.
“It differs so much,” Dahlin said, that comparing it to typical readmission agreements “is itself misleading.”
While such agreements are usually reached with immigration departments or foreign ministries, the deal with China was reached with the Chinese Ministry of Public Security, which handles immigration, but also police and intelligence matters.
The Chinese “experts” sent in are not immigration bureaucrats, but “agents,” Dahlin said, adding that the deal allowed them to “roam freely, conduct interviews and interrogations unsupervised.”
He added that the agents could conceivably also move freely throughout Europe’s passport-free Schengen area, which “would obviously be a major concern for the capitals in the countries around Switzerland.”
Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs spokeswoman Hua Chunying (華春瑩) said the criticism of its agreement with Switzerland was based on “a misinterpretation of the facts.”
“Other European countries engage in similar cooperation with China,” she said.
FEROCIOUS FISH-EATER Scientists have found a new species of dinosaur from the Cretaceous Period, a ‘hell heron’ that stalked the rivers, deep in the Saharan desert At a remote Sahara desert site in Niger, scientists have unearthed fossils of a new species of Spinosaurus, among the biggest of the meat-eating dinosaurs, notable for its large blade-shaped head crest and jaws bearing interlocking teeth for snaring fish. It prowled a forested inland environment and strode into rivers to catch sizable fish like a modern-day wading bird — a “hell heron,” as one of the researchers put it, considering it was about 12 meters long and weighed 5-7 tons. The dinosaur presented a striking profile on the Cretaceous Period landscape of Africa some 95 million years ago as it hunted
Heavy rain and strong winds yesterday disrupted flights, trains and ferries, forcing the closure of roads across large parts of New Zealand’s North Island, while snapping power links to tens of thousands. Domestic media reported a few flights had resumed operating by afternoon from the airport in Wellington, the capital, although cancelations were still widespread after airport authorities said most morning flights were disrupted. Air New Zealand said it hoped to resume services when conditions ease later yesterday, after it paused operations at Wellington, Napier and Palmerston North airports. Online images showed flooded semi-rural neighborhoods, inundated homes, trees fallen on vehicles and collapsed
‘COST OF DEFECTION’: Duterte’s announcement could be an effort to keep allies in line with the promise of a return to power amid political uncertainty, an analyst said Philippine Vice President Sara Duterte yesterday announced she would run for president of the Southeast Asian nation of 116 million in 2028. Duterte, who is embroiled in a bitter feud with Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr, was impeached last year only to see the country’s Supreme Court throw the case out over procedural issues. Her announcement comes just days before her father, former Philippine president Rodrigo Duterte, begins a pretrial hearing at the International Criminal Court (ICC) in the Netherlands over crimes against humanity allegedly committed as part of a brutal crackdown on drugs. “I offer my life, my strength and my future
NOT YET THERE: While the show was impressive, it failed to demonstrate their ability to move in unstructured environments, such as a factory floor, an expert said Dancing humanoid robots on Monday took center stage during the annual China Media Group’s Spring Festival Gala, China’s most-watched official television broadcast. They lunged and backflipped (landing on their knees), they spun around and jumped. Not one fell over. The display was impressive, but if robots can now dance and perform martial arts, what else can they do? Experts have mixed opinions, with some saying the robots had limitations and that the display should be viewed through a lens of state propaganda. Developed by several Chinese robotics firms, the robots performed a range of intricate stunts, including martial arts, comedy sketches and choreographed
RSS