Mon, Sep 30, 2024 page2

• Hard and fast sanctions needed for China: ECFR

  MARKET ACCESS: Europe’s strongest leverage against Beijing lies in measures targeting China’s access to the EU market, particularly noncritical goods, an ECFR fellow said

  • By Lu Yung-shan and Esme Yeh / Staff reporter, with staff writer
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  The EU should impose financial sanctions that go “hard, fast and where it hurts” on China if a Taiwan crisis occurs, as “gradual sanctions escalation could be counterproductive,” a European Council on Foreign Relations (ECFR) policy brief published earlier this month said.

  The pan-European think tank brief, published on Sept. 19 and written by senior policy fellow Agathe Demarais, aimed to draw insights from Western sanctions on Russia after its invasion of Ukraine and proposed sanctions deterrence against China in cross-strait conflict scenarios.

  The EU’s threat of sanctions against China could be “game-changing” as Beijing, like Moscow, would think it improbable for 27 EU member states to unite on sanctions, Demarais wrote.

  

  A globe is displayed in front of Chinese and Taiwanese flags in an illustration photograph taken on Aug. 6, 2022.

  Photo: Reuters

  Although China might threaten to retaliate against EU sanctions, “clear threats from the bloc would signal to Beijing that the costs of an aggression are even higher than those that the Chinese leadership already expects,” and Russia’s experience would prompt China to “think twice before brushing off Europe’s warnings,” she said.

  However, traditional financial sanctions might not work as “China has spent years insulating itself from financial sanctions through ‘de-dollarization,’ ‘de-SWIFTing’ and the development of digital currencies,” she said.

  By 2028, “threats of measures targeting China’s access to Western financial channels or currencies would be unlikely to alter Beijing’s calculus around Taiwan, as Chinese leaders are making fast progress toward financial self-sufficiency,” Demarais said.

  “This means that Europe’s strongest leverage probably lies in trade measures targeting China’s access to the EU market,” she said.

  China’s economic growth relies on exports of manufactured goods and that reliance “may well be its Achilles’ heel,” she said.

  “Exports account for nearly 20 percent of China’s GDP, with nearly 40 percent of these going to G7-EU economies,” while 100 million jobs in China depend on foreign demand, including at least 45 million from G7-EU economies, she said.

  The EU and its G7 partners should institute sanctions targeting imports of noncritical, finished consumer goods, particularly electronics and low-end goods, which accounted for 13 percent and 9 percent respectively of total Chinese exports, she said.

  “A drop in the supply of these goods would be manageable for Western consumers, at least for a while. But for China, joint G7-EU measures curbing the shipments of these products would be hugely painful,” Demarais said.

  “This means that if deterrence fails and EU policymakers choose to impose sanctions on China, then they should go hard and fast,” she said.

  Gradual sanctions escalation would risk “supporting Chinese efforts to build long-term immunity to financial sanctions,” and would make it unlikely that the EU and its allies could “engineer a balance-of-payments crisis in China through a seizure of the country’s central bank reserves,” she said.

  “European policymakers need to start discussing potential Taiwan-related triggers for sanctions on Beijing and map out the consequences of a drastic reduction in trade relations with China,” she said.

  The EU would have to “think of financial compensation packages for those EU firms that will be most affected by sanctions and seriously beef up its ability to tackle sanctions disinformation,” she added.
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Fertility rate falls to lowest globally

  • 2

    ’Up to Xi’ on Taiwan, but would be ’very unhappy’ with a change in ’status quo’: Trump

  • 3

    China widens attack on Japan’s ‘nuclear threat’

  • 4

    Marine Corps unit receives M4A1 rifles, source says

  • 5

    Interview: Trumpf expanding its Taiwan facilities