The Taipei High Administrative Court yesterday ruled that a Taiwanese and his Japanese partner should not have been prevented from registering their same-sex marriage with a local household registration office.
The court voided the decision by the office in Taipei’s Daan District (大安) to reject the application for marriage registration filed by Lu Yin-jen (盧盈任) and Eizaburo Ariyoshi on May 7 last year, saying that it should have been accepted.
Three years after Taiwan legalized same-sex marriage, Lu and Ariyoshi would be free to marry, provided the household registration office does not file an appeal within 20 days of receiving the verdict.
Photo: CNA
“We have been together for seven years, and now we can finally become, legitimately, husband and husband,” Lu, 34, told a news conference following a trial that lasted less than five minutes.
Ariyoshi, 42, said that he felt “really, really happy and relieved” about the result, adding that he and Lu had held a wedding ceremony shortly after Taiwan legalized same-sex marriage in May 2019.
Lu and Ariyoshi took their case to court in December last year after their marriage application was rejected by two household registration offices, which said that Ministry of the Interior rules ban same-sex marriages involving at least one partner from a country or region that does not recognize such unions.
Despite three more Taipei High Administrative Court rulings in favor of couples involving partners from Malaysia, Macau and Singapore since March last year, the ministry has reiterated that it is legally bound to reject the registration of such marriages under Article 46 of the Act Governing the Choice of Law in Civil Matters Involving Foreign Elements (涉外民事法律適用法), which says that the formation of a marriage is governed by the national law of each party’s home country.
The ministry’s rule has led to at least 467 cross-national same-sex couples — including some who registered their marriage in a third country — being prevented from registering their marriage in Taiwan, said the Taiwan Alliance to Promote Civil Partnership Rights, which provided pro bono support to Lu and Ariyoshi.
Alliance secretary-general Chien Chih-chieh (簡至潔) said that the continued rejection of certain cross-national same-sex marriages is “illegal.”
Chien said the fourth Taipei High Administrative Court ruling in favor of such couples showed that no legal amendments would be needed, contradicting the government’s position.
A draft amendment sent to the Executive Yuan by the Judicial Yuan in January last year has yet to be approved, Chien said, calling on the government to allow all cross-national same-sex unions immediately by issuing another directive or implementing other measures.
Cabinet spokesman Lo Ping-cheng (羅秉成) in May said that discussions on the draft had been held several times over the past year, but that more assessment and communication were needed before the amendment could be sent to the legislature.
Chien said that her organization would continue helping cross-national same-sex couples sue the government over rejected marriage registrations.
Victoria Hsu (許秀雯), a lawyer working with the alliance, urged the Daan Household Registration Office to not lodge an appeal against yesterday’s ruling, describing it as “wasting judicial resources.”
Hsu said that the government should act in accordance with the Constitution, which ensures freedom of marriage and equal rights for all.
In a news statement, the ministry said it respected the ruling, as well as the household registration office’s right to appeal it.
TRAFFIC SAFETY RULES: A positive result in a drug test would result in a two-year license suspension for the driver and vehicle, and a fine of up to NT$180,000 The Ministry of Transportation and Communications is to authorize police to conduct roadside saliva tests by the end of the year to deter people from driving while under the influence of narcotics, it said yesterday. The ministry last month unveiled a draft of amended regulations governing traffic safety rules and penalties, which included provisions empowering police to conduct mandatory saliva tests on drivers. While currently rules authorize police to use oral fluid testing kits for signs of drug use, they do not establish penalties for noncompliance or operating procedures for officers to follow, the ministry said. The proposed changes to the regulations require
The Executive Yuan yesterday announced that registration for a one-time universal NT$10,000 cash handout to help people in Taiwan survive US tariffs and inflation would start on Nov. 5, with payouts available as early as Nov. 12. Who is eligible for the handout? Registered Taiwanese nationals are eligible, including those born in Taiwan before April 30 next year with a birth certificate. Non-registered nationals with residence permits, foreign permanent residents and foreign spouses of Taiwanese citizens with residence permits also qualify for the handouts. For people who meet the eligibility requirements, but passed away between yesterday and April 30 next year, surviving family members
China Airlines Ltd (CAL) yesterday morning joined SkyTeam’s Aviation Challenge for the fourth time, operating a demonstration flight for “net zero carbon emissions” from Taiwan Taoyuan International Airport to Bangkok. The flight used sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) at a ratio of up to 40 percent, the highest proportion CAL has achieved to date, the nation’s largest carrier said. Since April, SAF has become available to Taiwanese international carriers at Taipei International Airport (Songshan airport), Kaohsiung International Airport and Taoyuan airport. In previous challenges, CAL operated “net zero carbon emission flights” to Singapore and Japan. At a ceremony at Taoyuan airport, China Airlines chief sustainability
‘ONE CHINA’: A statement that Berlin decides its own China policy did not seem to sit well with Beijing, which offered only one meeting with the German official German Minister for Foreign Affairs Johann Wadephul’s trip to China has been canceled, a spokesperson for his ministry said yesterday, amid rising tensions between the two nations, including over Taiwan. Wadephul had planned to address Chinese curbs on rare earths during his visit, but his comments about Berlin deciding on the “design” of its “one China” policy ahead of the trip appear to have rankled China. Asked about Wadephul’s comments, Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs spokesman Guo Jiakun (郭嘉昆) said the “one China principle” has “no room for any self-definition.” In the interview published on Thursday, Wadephul said he would urge China to
RSS