The Taipei High Administrative Court yesterday denied CTi TV’s request for an injunction over the rejection of its application to renew CTi News’ operating license.
The network filed for an injunction after the seven members of the National Communications Commission (NCC) on Nov. 18 unanimously denied the news channel’s license renewal application.
CTi TV asked the court to give it a temporary license so that it could continue operating after its license expires on Friday, and prevent the NCC from allowing other news channels to use its coveted Channel 52 slot until after the dispute has been settled.
Photo: CNA
However, the court denied the network’s petition, saying that it failed to convince the court that it has a high probability of winning subsequent lawsuits, adding that the NCC’s ruling did not cause CTi TV major damage or place it in immediate danger.
“From the explanations we have heard so far from CTi TV and the NCC, we cannot determine in definite terms the legality of NCC’s ruling to reject the license renewal,” the court said.
The network questioned the NCC’s fines and penalties against CTi News, but the court said that those issues would have to be settled through subsequent litigation.
Broadcasting licenses are valid for six years under the Satellite Broadcasting Act (衛星廣播電視法), and CTi TV understood that it might not secure a license renewal and should have prepared accordingly, the court said, adding that any financial losses it sustained as a result of the application’s rejection should not be considered “unusual damages.”
CTi TV can continue using the personnel and facilities at the news channel to produce programs, which can be aired through other platforms, the court said.
As the network can continue to generate revenue by operating its other channels, any financial losses and damage to its reputation sustained as a result of the news channel losing its license are not irreparable, the court said.
News media are public services, and the use and development of them should be overseen by the commission based on media regulations, the court said.
“If the court grants CTi TV an injunction over the NCC’s ruling, it would allow the network to circumvent oversight by the agency, which would nullify the effects of the license renewal mechanism stated in Satellite Broadcasting Act and affect the authority of the NCC to maintain the order of broadcast media,” it said.
As to preventing NCC from reassigning Channel 52 to another news network, the court said that the channel lineups are determined through negotiations between cable system operators and networks or agents representing channels, which means they are private disputes.
As the NCC has no way of intervening in those matters, the network cannot ask for an injunction on this issue either, the court said.
CTi News said it would appeal to the Supreme Administrative Court.
“We are angry and disappointed that the court said nothing about the freedom of the press, which faces significant and immediate danger,” the channel said in a statement. “It also disregarded that the NCC’s ruling has a weak legal basis, and the commission’s administrative hearing over our license renewal application had major flaws. Nor did it question the political interference that might have occurred in this case.”
“This is the heaviest day for the 475 employees at CTi News. We will continue to stand up and defend the freedom of the press and hope that the judicial system will do us justice,” it said.
The Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) said in a statement yesterday that it regrets the court’s decision.
The closure of a television news station in Taiwan one day after Human Rights Day, which is on Thursday, would damage the nation’s international image, the KMT said, urging people to “remember this day,” and to defend freedom of the press and free speech.
Additional reporting by Sherry Hsiao
AGGRESSION: China’s latest intrusions set a new benchmark for its ‘gray zone’ tactics and possibly a new pattern that it would attempt to normalize, a researcher said China’s latest military exercises represent a new challenge to Taiwan’s legal authority to demarcate its borders in the Taiwan Strait, a defense expert said, adding that the fleets in the latest exercises were likely the most powerful the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) ever assembled. The PLA conducted military exercises from Sunday last week to 6am on Friday, which encompassed large swathes of the western Pacific, including the Taiwan Strait and waters off the Philippines and Guam, National Policy Foundation associate research fellow Chieh Chung (揭仲) said on Friday. The Ministry of National Defense said that it detected 70 warship and 162 aircraft
DOMESTIC MARKET: To protect the livelihoods of local egg farmers, the government adopted a new method for releasing imported eggs, the agriculture minister said More than 54 million imported eggs will be disposed, as their expiration date has passed, Minister of Agriculture Chen Chi-chung (陳吉仲) said yesterday. Chen made the remarks at a news conference in Taipei, explaining the flow of imported eggs following recent controversies regarding the products. The ministry introduced a special egg import program to address a nationwide egg shortage earlier this year. However, controversies have risen in recent weeks. These included an accusation that the government helped some egg importing companies over others, eggs imported from Brazil that had an incorrect expiration date, and egg shipments from Brazil that were found
PACIFIC OCEAN: Defense experts have warned that the ‘Shandong,’ China’s second largest aircraft carrier, poses a serious threat to eastern Taiwan’s defenses The drills conducted by the Chinese aircraft carrier Shandong in the Western Pacific last week were more aimed at showcasing China’s military capabilities to the US rather than toward Taiwan, a Taiwanese defense expert said yesterday. Lin Yin-yu (林穎佑), an assistant professor at Tamkang University’s Graduate Institute of International Affairs and Strategic Studies, said the drills which involved dozens of warplanes sought to test China’s anti-access and area denial capabilities should the US and its allies attempt to interfere in a cross-strait conflict. Lin said that the latest Chinese drills coincided with a joint maritime exercise conducted by the US, South Korea
Thousands of bottles of Sriracha have been returned or destroyed after the discovery of excessive sulfur dioxide, a bleaching agent, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) announced on Tuesday. About 12,600 bottles totaling 9,991.8kg of the hot sauce imported from the US by Emporium Corp (河洛企業) were flagged at the border for containing illegal levels of sulfur dioxide, the FDA said in its regular border inspection announcement. Inspectors discovered 0.5g per kilogram of the common bleaching agent and preservative, higher than the 0.03g permitted, it said. As it is the first time within six months the product has been flagged, Sriracha products from
RSS