Mon, Sep 23, 2002 page2

• `Three nos' stirs rights debate

  BODY POLITIC Moves by the Taoyuan County Government to dictate what `betel-nut beauties' can wear have women's groups alleging rights have been infringed upon

  • By Jimmy Chuang / STAFF REPORTER
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  A recent Taoyuan County Govern-ment ruling on "betel nut beauties" has sparked controversy on whether the authorities should impose a dress code on the scantily-clad young women.

  While officials such as Interior Minister Yu Cheng-hsien (余政憲) support the rules, others argue that no one has the right to interfere with the way people dress, including the government.

  On Sept. 15, Taoyuan County Deputy Commissioner Liao Cheng-ching (廖正井) announced a "three nos" policy prohibiting the women from exposing their breasts, bellies and buttocks while working beginning Oct. 15.

  

  A police officer arrives at a betel-nut stand in Taoyuan County on Wednesday to serve a warning about an upcoming crackdown on scantily clad women.

  PHOTO: HSIEH WU-HSUING, TAIPEI TIMES

  On Thursday, Taoyuan County Commissioner Chu Li-luan (朱立倫) relaxed the policy to one of "two nos" by permitting the exposure of bellies.

  "I agreed that it's not quite reasonable if we force these ladies to wear those clothes that cover their belly," Chu said. "However, they still have to cover their breasts and buttocks while working. That's necessary."

  According to Liao, the fierce competition for customers has prompted some betel-nut stand owners to make their employees go topless or wear thongs.

  Employing scantily clad young women, many of whom are under 18 years of age, has long been a practice of Taiwan's betel-nut stands, most of which are scattered along suburban roads and highways. The phenomenon of "betel-nut beauties" has become a unique cultural marker in Taiwan.

  But Liao says the practice is a national embarrassment.

  National disgrace

  "It's a disgrace to Taiwan," he said. "Lots of foreign friends of mine told me that they would like to check out what betel-nut beauties look like when they came to visit. It's embarrassing that there are so many betel-nut stands along the roads carrying foreign visitors from CKS Airport in Taoyuan County to Taipei City."

  Taoyuan County Betel Nut Association Secretary-General Peng Tien-le (彭天樂) said that more than 600 of the roughly 1,700 betel-nut stands operating in the county had joined his association and signed agreements to abide by its decency rules, but added that the association has no control over the rest.

  "Our members will cooperate with the government on the new policy. However, there's nothing we can do about those non-members," Peng said.

  Minister Yu said that selling betel nuts itself is OK but these stands shouldn't block traffic or cause traffic accidents due to the presence of scantily clad women.

  "That's why the county government came up with the decision to ask these women to cover themselves up a bit. For the sake of traffic, no matter whether it's `three nos' or `two nos,' Commissioner Chu has my 100 percent support for carrying out the crackdown on those betel-nut stands and beauties who won't follow the regulations as of Oct. 15," Yu said.

  A Taoyuan prosecutor who wished to remain anonymous said that the Taoyuan County Government's original "three nos" policy wasn't legal and that the authorities would have trouble carrying out the policy.

  "Exposing women's breasts in public definitely violates the offences against morals in the Criminal Code. There's no question about it. However, there is no legal document saying that somebody is in violation of the law if she shows off her belly or buttocks," he explained. "I guess that's one reason why Commissioner Chu changed the policy from `three nos' to `two nos.'"

  A 17-year-old betel-nut beauty surnamed Lin (林) in Taoyuan told the Taipei Times that wearing such revealing clothes is not what she wanted but it is something she has to do due to the competition from neighboring stands.

  "Most customers, especially when most of them are males, love to watch. You will have no customers to knock on your door if you don't dress like this. That's the reality," she said.

  "If the county government can really carry out what it claims it will do and asks every betel-nut beauty and owner to cooperate, I'll be more than happy to follow the rules as well," Lin said.

  Another vendor who works at a stand next to Lin's expressed a different view.

  Wearing a sports bra-like top and short mini-skirt, the 19-year-old, surnamed Hu (胡), said that she loved what she was wearing but she would never expose her breasts or private parts in front of customers.

  Hu added that she feels the government doesn't have the right to tell her what to wear.

  "I'm a betel-nut beauty, not an exotic dancer or a hooker. Why should I do that?" she said. "I love to make myself beautiful when I'm at work. What's wrong with that?"

  Josephine Ho (何春蕤), an adviser to the Gender Sexuality Rights Association and a professor at National Central University, also said that nobody has the right to interfere with the way people dress, including the government.

  "No administrative body has the right to tell people how to dress. This is ridiculous," she said.

  "In this case, the decision on how to dress and what to wear should be left up to these betel-nut beauties themselves. The government should draft regulations to ask betel-nut stand owners not to request the betel-nut beauties they hire to be scantily clad just for the sake of better business. These owners should be the subject [of regulations], not the girls."

  In addition, Ho also said that women's groups shouldn't blame these young women for not thinking about their future by working at betel-nut stands.

  She said that a lot of people feel these women chose this business as their career because of the lure of a high income.

  Ho said that she personally doesn't think there's anything wrong with these women's choice of job.

  Few alternatives

  "Think about it, most betel-nut beauties didn't receive a solid education. If they don't do this, they may end up with something worse such as prostitution," she said.

  "If those women's groups really care about women, they should show their concern about those women who are still suffering from lousy jobs with low salaries. How to help them improve their life should be the focus for these women's groups," Ho said.

  See editorial:
  

  Covering up the real disgrace
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Stuttgart and Nottingham Forest advance

  • 2

    Harden hails ‘special’ Cavs after win over Knicks

  • 3

    Iran’s supreme leader Khamenei killed

  • 4

    Inter exit after Bodo/Glimt loss

  • 5

    Iran prepare for Women’s Asian Cup in Australia as bombs drop on homeland