The pilot of the TransAsia Airways Flight GE235 that crashed into the Keelung River in Taipei on Feb. 4 admitted that he shut down the wrong engine in a conversation recorded by the plane’s cockpit voice recorder, the Aviation Safety Council said yesterday.
Council executive director Thomas Wang (王興中) said that a master warning sounded after the aircraft climbed to 1,200 feet (365.8m). The aircraft’s engine warning display (EWD) then showed a series of steps that the pilot, Liao Chien-tsung (廖建宗), should have taken when the No. 2 engine flamed out after takeoff.
The pilot said that he shut down the No. 1 engine instead.
Photo: Hsieh Chieh-yu, Taipei Times
According to the transcript provided by the council, the pilot said: “Wow, pulled back the wrong side throttle,” about eight seconds before the plane crash.
As to why the pilot turned off the No. 1 engine when the EWD showed that the No. 2 engine was the problem, Wang said that the council would begin an analysis in the next phase of the investigation.
The initial investigation showed that four seconds after the flight began to take off, the copilot, Liu Tse-chung (劉自忠), cried out that the plane’s automatic takeoff power control system (ATPCS) was not armed.
Nevertheless, the pilot answered: “OK continue takeoff.”
At 10:52am, the copilot corrected himself, saying: “Oh, there it is. ATPCS is armed.”
Wang said that the ATPCS is a protection mechanism that increases power to the operating engine and turns off the bleed valve if the system detects that one of the two engines on the aircraft generates torque less than 18.5 percent. The system can also switch the failed engine to autofeather mode and inhibit the operating engine from being feathered, he said.
The feathered failed engine helps reduce drag so that the operating engine can generate sufficient power for the aircraft to continue flying, he added.
Wang said the council had inspected the engines and other devices on the ATR-600 aircraft. While the autofeather unit of the No. 1 engine passed the continuity test, the torque signal transmission of the same unit in the No. 2 engine was unstable during testing.
“The flight data recorder showed that the oil pressure, temperature and fuel flow of the No. 2 engine was normal and the engine was still running. However, the signal was not transmitted to the sensor in a reliable manner and the situation subsequently triggered the sequences of the ATPCS. The system then caused the engine to be feathered, which means that it no longer provided any power to the aircraft,” he said.
Data records also showed that the pilot disengaged the autopilot system at 10:52:41am, when the aircraft was at 1,300 feet.
At 10:52:43am, the pilot said: “I will pull back the throttle of the No. 1 engine,” with the copilot answering: “Wait a second, cross check.”
The copilot answered again at 10:53am, saying: “OK, engine flame out check. Check up-trim, yes. Auto-feather, yes.”
At 10:53:06am, the pilot repeated that he would shut down the No. 1 engine. At the same time, the copilot said that he had confirmed that the No. 2 engine was flamed out.
The condition lever of the No. 1 engine was pushed to the position to shut off the fuel at 10:53:24am, and the engine later went into the feather mode as well, according to the data.
At 10:54:05am, the copilot confirmed that they lost both engines. Though the pilot tried to restart the No. 1 engine, it did not accelerate fast enough to generate sufficient power to keep the plane in the air, the data showed.
The pilot verbally confirmed that he had shut down the wrong engine at 10:54:27am. At 10:54:35am, the aircraft crashed into the Keelung River, killing 43 people onboard.
The facts presented by the council also indicated that the pilot had once failed the simulator test to operate an ATR-600 aircraft. The airman overseeing the test said that the pilot had “insufficient knowledge of the quick reference book,” including knowledge on the engine flame out at takeoff. The pilot passed the test in July last year.
Civil Aeronautics Administration Flight Standard Division Director Clark Lin (林俊良) said that the operation manual of the ATR aircraft had said that the pilot should abort takeoff if the ATPCS is not armed and the operation speed fails to reach 70 knots.
Responding to the report, the brother of the pilot said that the council should not blame what happened on his brother and the copilot.
The copilot’s sister, Liu Chun-hsin (劉春新), said her brother and Liao had minimized casualties by avoiding densely populated zones.
MAKING WAVES: China’s maritime militia could become a nontraditional threat in war, clogging up shipping lanes to prevent US or Japanese intervention, a report said About 1,900 Chinese ships flying flags of convenience and fishing vessels that participated in China’s military exercises around Taiwan last month and in January have been listed for monitoring, Coast Guard Administration (CGA) Deputy Director-General Hsieh Ching-chin (謝慶欽) said yesterday. Following amendments to the Commercial Port Act (商港法) and the Law of Ships (船舶法) last month, the CGA can designate possible berthing areas or deny ports of call for vessels suspected of loitering around areas where undersea cables can be accessed, Oceans Affairs Council Minister Kuan Bi-ling (管碧玲) said. The list of suspected ships, originally 300, had risen to about 1,900 as
Japan’s strategic alliance with the US would collapse if Tokyo were to turn away from a conflict in Taiwan, Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi said yesterday, but distanced herself from previous comments that suggested a possible military response in such an event. Takaichi expressed her latest views on a nationally broadcast TV program late on Monday, where an opposition party leader criticized her for igniting tensions with China with the earlier remarks. Ties between Japan and China have sunk to the worst level in years after Takaichi said in November that a hypothetical Chinese attack on Taiwan could bring about a Japanese
Right-wing political scientist Laura Fernandez on Sunday won Costa Rica’s presidential election by a landslide, after promising to crack down on rising violence linked to the cocaine trade. Fernandez’s nearest rival, economist Alvaro Ramos, conceded defeat as results showed the ruling party far exceeding the threshold of 40 percent needed to avoid a runoff. With 94 percent of polling stations counted, the political heir of outgoing Costa Rican President Rodrigo Chaves had captured 48.3 percent of the vote compared with Ramos’ 33.4 percent, the Supreme Electoral Tribunal said. As soon as the first results were announced, members of Fernandez’s Sovereign People’s Party
MORE RESPONSIBILITY: Draftees would be expected to fight alongside professional soldiers, likely requiring the transformation of some training brigades into combat units The armed forces are to start incorporating new conscripts into combined arms brigades this year to enhance combat readiness, the Executive Yuan’s latest policy report said. The new policy would affect Taiwanese men entering the military for their compulsory service, which was extended to one year under reforms by then-president Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) in 2022. The conscripts would be trained to operate machine guns, uncrewed aerial vehicles, anti-tank guided missile launchers and Stinger air defense systems, the report said, adding that the basic training would be lengthened to eight weeks. After basic training, conscripts would be sorted into infantry battalions that would take
RSS