On a harsh winter afternoon last month, 2,000 protesters marched and chanted slogans such as “CCP out” and “Korea for Koreans” in Seoul’s popular Gangnam District. Participants — mostly students — wore caps printed with the Chinese characters for “exterminate communism” (滅共) and held banners reading “Heaven will destroy the Chinese Communist Party” (天滅中共).
During the march, Park Jun-young, the leader of the protest organizer “Free University,” a conservative youth movement, who was on a hunger strike, collapsed after delivering a speech in sub-zero temperatures and was later hospitalized. Several protesters shaved their heads at the end of the demonstration.
A MOVEMENT’S FAST GROWTH
Photo: Don Huh
Since the movement’s first rally in another of Seoul’s renowned tourist sites, Myeongdong, in June last year, participation has climbed seven to eightfold, reaching about 10,000 people or more, organizers say. Similar protests have since spread, led by other groups in other tourist sites like Hongdae, as well as in Daerim-dong, which has a significant Chinese community.
“Our motivation is just to do our best for Korea,” said Lee Saya, a student at Jeonbuk National University — majoring in art, and a member of the movement.
Lee said the group initially protested near the Chinese Embassy in Myeongdong, but later shifted locations due to police intervention.
Photo: Don Huh
The Chinese Embassy in Seoul on July 9 last year lodged a complaint with the South Korean government over the protests and advised Chinese nationals in the country to be cautious. The central government subsequently barred rallies directly in front of the embassy, but allowed them in Myeondong.
“That crackdown happened because the Lee [Jae-myung] administration fears China,” Lee Saya said. “We were investigated by police for tearing the five-star red flag, and after President Lee Jae-myung ... officially condemned the marches on Sept. 9 last year, we could no longer organize protests in Myeongdong.”
Those restrictions continued through President Lee’s two summits with Chinese leader Xi Jinping (習近平) — at Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum in Gyeongju on Nov. 1 last year and in Beijing on Jan. 5 — and remain in effect. In addition, a ruling party legislator proposed in October last year banning the movement’s China-bashing song and slogans, with violators facing up to five years in prison.
Photo: Don Huh
“By contrast, there have been numerous anti-US and anti-Japan protests in this country, including tearing the Stars and Stripes, but the government never intervened,” Lee said.
Despite the harsh rhetoric, the protests have remained nonviolent. Another member of the movement said that during a different group’s protest in Daerim-dong, some Chinese residents threw bottles at demonstrators despite the presence of police.
ANTI-CHINA SENTIMENT
Photo: Don Huh
Anti-China sentiment in South Korea has been building for more than a decade. Surveys show that unfavorable views of China stood at 31 percent in 2002 and 49 percent in 2008, according to World Public Opinion surveys. The figure surged to 80 percent in 2022, according to the Pew Research Center, and stood at 72 percent last year, according to Gallup Korea.
Reasons cited for the sentiment are, first, misconduct by some Chinese tourists; second, China’s diplomatic and military pressure on South Korea, like the dispute over the US deployment of the Terminal High Altitude Area Defense (THAAD) system in 2017; and third, social issues involving Chinese nationals, including rising land prices linked to property purchases and short-term residents’ access to the country’s low-cost national health insurance system.
The situation has also affected Taiwanese visitors, as Mandarin spoken by Taiwanese is almost indistinguishable to Korean ears. One Taiwanese resident said that while speaking Mandarin on a bus near Seoul, a driver shouted at him to be quiet — a reaction he claims does not happen with other languages.
As a result, some Taiwanese tourists now wear badges stating “I am Taiwanese” while visiting South Korea. Hong Kong visitors have also reported similar experiences when speaking Cantonese on the street.
However, such encounters are not universal. Another Taiwanese visitor, surnamed You, said in December that he spoke Mandarin freely with his Taiwanese friend at the restaurants in Seoul without attaching a badge, but encountered no problems.
Even so, some Western and Japanese news outlets have described the South Korean protests as “racist” or “misled by fake news.”
That framing began appearing in South Korea’s pro-government news outlets in the second half of last year. While those outlets reported on anti-China sentiment as a social phenomenon through 2024, they began criticizing the protests as racist and insensitive to other ethnic groups as the demonstrations grew in scale.
Lee rejected that characterization, arguing that criticism from pro-government media also indicates fear of China.
“Nobody regards anti-US or anti-Japan protesters as racist here,” he said, “we are criticizing China based on what we have seen and experienced.”
Lee said that anti-China sentiment has intensified partly due to what he described as China’s cultural and commercial practices.
“China keeps pushing cultural projects and producing copycats of South Korean brands, such as the recently opened Chinese cosmetics shop ‘Only Young’ that imitates South Korea’s ‘Olive Young,’” Lee said.
He also recalled that during the South Korea’s 2019 trade dispute with Japan, his hometown of Jeonju were covered with anti-Japan banners.
“Many of those claims later turned out to be groundless rumors,” he said, “the ruling party exploited anti-Japan sentiment for political purposes and now accuses us of racism. That double standard infuriates me.”
Lee added that several government and ruling party figures, including the incumbent prime minister, were imprisoned for violent protests and arson attacks on the American Cultural Center during the 1980s and 1990s.
“They glorify their protests as democratic,” he said, “but we’re just singing and chanting, no violence.”
Another member of the movement also said that South Korea’s movement shares anti-China protests in Taiwan and Hong Kong’s characteristics in terms of “resistance to domination.”
“Several Hong Kong residents in Seoul planned to speak at our Myeongdong protest last year, but they canceled due to safety concerns,” the member said.
As anti-China sentiment increasingly moves from opinion polls to the streets, the protests are evolving from purely political concerns into cultural and everyday-life issues.
“We keep discussing our future direction every day,” Lee Saya said, “we always work for our homeland.”
In 2012, the US Department of Justice (DOJ) heroically seized residences belonging to the family of former president Chen Shui-bian (陳水扁), “purchased with the proceeds of alleged bribes,” the DOJ announcement said. “Alleged” was enough. Strangely, the DOJ remains unmoved by the any of the extensive illegality of the two Leninist authoritarian parties that held power in the People’s Republic of China (PRC) and Taiwan. If only Chen had run a one-party state that imprisoned, tortured and murdered its opponents, his property would have been completely safe from DOJ action. I must also note two things in the interests of completeness.
Taiwan is especially vulnerable to climate change. The surrounding seas are rising at twice the global rate, extreme heat is becoming a serious problem in the country’s cities, and typhoons are growing less frequent (resulting in droughts) but more destructive. Yet young Taiwanese, according to interviewees who often discuss such issues with this demographic, seldom show signs of climate anxiety, despite their teachers being convinced that humanity has a great deal to worry about. Climate anxiety or eco-anxiety isn’t a psychological disorder recognized by diagnostic manuals, but that doesn’t make it any less real to those who have a chronic and
When Bilahari Kausikan defines Singapore as a small country “whose ability to influence events outside its borders is always limited but never completely non-existent,” we wish we could say the same about Taiwan. In a little book called The Myth of the Asian Century, he demolishes a number of preconceived ideas that shackle Taiwan’s self-confidence in its own agency. Kausikan worked for almost 40 years at Singapore’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs, reaching the position of permanent secretary: saying that he knows what he is talking about is an understatement. He was in charge of foreign affairs in a pivotal place in
Just far enough out of reach to keep big crowds away, but not so far as to make a day-trip an exhausting affair, Jinhuang Hot Spring (近黃溫泉) is a nice winter escape for your next visit to Taitung County. The pools are numerous, the water is the perfect temperature and the walk in is not too challenging, though you will have to get your feet wet. The adventure starts in the county’s Jinlun Village (金崙), which is accessible by train, but you’ll want to have your own car, scooter or bicycle for this trip. If you arrive by train, walk up
RSS