Late last month Philippines Foreign Affairs Secretary Theresa Lazaro told the Philippine Senate that the nation has sufficient funds to evacuate the nearly 170,000 Filipino residents in Taiwan, 84 percent of whom are migrant workers, in the event of war. Agencies have been exploring evacuation scenarios since early this year, she said. She also observed that since the Philippines has only limited ships, the government is consulting security agencies for alternatives.
Filipinos are a distant third in overall migrant worker population. Indonesia has over 248,000 workers, followed by roughly 240,000 Vietnamese. It should be noted that there are another 170,000 Vietnamese in Taiwan married to locals. Hence, roughly 1 in every 33 Taiwanese residents is southeast Asian.
Photo: AFP
HOT WAR
Foreign Minister Lazaro’s testimony was a brave speech, intended to reassure, but it is a fantasy. Everyone in Taiwan will be trapped when the war begins. No one is getting out.
It is difficult to imagine that in the chaos of a hot war, with air and sea combat taking place across the South China Sea and in the Bashi Channel between Taiwan and Luzon, how 170,000 Filipinos are going to be evacuated. It is impossible to imagine how another half million or more Vietnamese and Indonesians are going to be evacuated — all at the same time as the Filipinos, along with the tens of thousands of Americans, Canadians, Japanese and other nationalities. Of course, hundreds of thousands of Taiwanese will be attempting to flee as well. Further, the Japanese will also be removing the roughly 120,000 civilians who live on the Japanese-owned islands east of Taiwan in the event of war with China, as they announced back in March of this year. Air and sealift to Japan will be at a premium.
Photo: EPA
Many readers have probably evolved some hazy vision of escape when the fighting begins. A flight out? Most of these fantasies are based on having weeks or months of warning. Not anymore. As incursions by the forces of the People’s Republic of China (PRC) into local air and sea space have become normalized, the warning period has shrunk. At a panel discussion organized by Taiwan Thinktank last week, military expert Kao Chih-jung (高志榮) said that the PRC will probably take up to two weeks to prepare its forces for an invasion.
Two weeks, perhaps even less. Imagine the chaos at Taiwan’s airports, which are inevitable targets of bombardment. A pro-Ukraine hacker group in July took down Aeroflot’s computer systems, crippling flights across Russia. Recall that in 2022 during then US House of Representatives speaker Nancy Pelosi’s visit to Taiwan, hackers from Russia and the PRC took control of screens across Taiwan, from 7-11s to the government, paralyzing them. Power outages will be easy for the PRC to arrange. In a real war, organized aviation in Taiwan will cease to exist hours, perhaps days, before the first drones and missiles hit the aircraft and equipment at Taiwan’s airports.
Well ok, the reader’s hazy fantasy might run, there are still fishing boats. Nope. Taiwan’s distant water fleet is almost entirely crewed by migrant workers, and their captains, usually far from Taiwan, will not return to enter a combat zone. The small fishing craft that ply the waters off Taiwan have a lower proportion of migrant workers, but they too will largely cease functioning as their crews melt away. They aren’t paid enough to run the gauntlet of drones and PRC ships. Moreover, fishing boats use fuels that will be restricted in the event of war, while sealift capable of transporting large quantities of people (like Taiwan’s inter-island ferries) is going to be reserved for military use or destroyed in the opening attacks. Sadly, Taiwan’s outlying islands will likely be cut off.
Photo: Reuters
BLOCKADE
It probably won’t come to war, right? It will be a blockade. Perfectly safe. Earlier this year the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) ran 26 wargames to explore various blockade scenarios.
“In most free-play games, despite a reluctance to escalate, teams responded to perceived escalations with minor escalations of their own and in two games spiraled to a general war,” the study’s summary said.
Casualties in fixed-escalation games were high. The focus in a blockade won’t be getting people out, but getting cargo in. Many ships will be damaged or sunk. The likelihood that the blockade will involve missile and drone attacks on Taiwan is high, especially since PRC doctrine calls for attacks on Taiwan in the event of a blockade. What happens to commercial airline flights at that point? Many flights will be halted even before attacks occur because airlines won’t want to risk Beijing’s ire.
The CSIS wargames showed that “rapidly acquiring ships to run the blockade was critical because regular shipping companies would not take the risk of getting involved.” It is true that the fleet of Taiwanese-owned vessels is large, but the crews are not Taiwanese. Indeed, in many cases officers and crews of Taiwanese-owned ships may be Chinese (hello, sabotage). The problem thus isn’t going to be finding hulls, but crewing them. There is simply no great reserve of Taiwanese mariners.
Moreover, unlike migrant workers who make minimum wage and lack the savings to bribe their way out of Taiwan, the foreign crews of Taiwanese cargo vessels will often have the wherewithal to fly home from wherever in the world they make port, even at the risk of contractual punishment.
The Philippines is the world’s leading source of migrant mariners. For example, over a third of the mariners in the US fleet are Filipinos (roughly 9 percent are Chinese). In time of war how many would stay on ships being shot at, when they can easily find work in the ships of neutral nations or stay at home for a few months? Rotating home, after all, is totally normal for Filipino mariners. It is true that Filipinos also comprise roughly a third of Russian shadow fleet crews, but nobody is sinking those ships at the moment.
In an invasion, Taiwan will be a nation of ships without crews, while the Philippines will be a nation of crews without ships. Seems like a match made in heaven, but it must be fashioned into a joint policy. Being able to remove its people from Taiwan should be a powerful incentive for Manila to strike a deal on providing volunteer crews for blockade running. Taiwan also needs to begin expanding and hardening its ports in the south and on the east coast with an eye to handling mass quantities of incoming cargo and outgoing humans. In a conflict with the PRC, even tiny ports like Houbihu (後壁湖) and Houwan (後灣) in Kenting will assume critical importance.
Notes from Central Taiwan is a column written by long-term resident Michael Turton, who provides incisive commentary informed by three decades of living in and writing about his adoptive country. The views expressed here are his own.
The primaries for this year’s nine-in-one local elections in November began early in this election cycle, starting last autumn. The local press has been full of tales of intrigue, betrayal, infighting and drama going back to the summer of 2024. This is not widely covered in the English-language press, and the nine-in-one elections are not well understood. The nine-in-one elections refer to the nine levels of local governments that go to the ballot, from the neighborhood and village borough chief level on up to the city mayor and county commissioner level. The main focus is on the 22 special municipality
The People’s Republic of China (PRC) invaded Vietnam in 1979, following a year of increasingly tense relations between the two states. Beijing viewed Vietnam’s close relations with Soviet Russia as a threat. One of the pretexts it used was the alleged mistreatment of the ethnic Chinese in Vietnam. Tension between the ethnic Chinese and governments in Vietnam had been ongoing for decades. The French used to play off the Vietnamese against the Chinese as a divide-and-rule strategy. The Saigon government in 1956 compelled all Vietnam-born Chinese to adopt Vietnamese citizenship. It also banned them from 11 trades they had previously
Jan. 12 to Jan. 18 At the start of an Indigenous heritage tour of Beitou District (北投) in Taipei, I was handed a sheet of paper titled Ritual Song for the Various Peoples of Tamsui (淡水各社祭祀歌). The lyrics were in Chinese with no literal meaning, accompanied by romanized pronunciation that sounded closer to Hoklo (commonly known as Taiwanese) than any Indigenous language. The translation explained that the song offered food and drink to one’s ancestors and wished for a bountiful harvest and deer hunting season. The program moved through sites related to the Ketagalan, a collective term for the
As devices from toys to cars get smarter, gadget makers are grappling with a shortage of memory needed for them to work. Dwindling supplies and soaring costs of Dynamic Random Access Memory (DRAM) that provides space for computers, smartphones and game consoles to run applications or multitask was a hot topic behind the scenes at the annual gadget extravaganza in Las Vegas. Once cheap and plentiful, DRAM — along with memory chips to simply store data — are in short supply because of the demand spikes from AI in everything from data centers to wearable devices. Samsung Electronics last week put out word
RSS