The canonical shot of an East Asian city is a night skyline studded with towering apartment and office buildings, bright with neon and plastic signage, a landscape of energy and modernity. Another classic image is the same city seen from above, in which identical apartment towers march across the city, spilling out over nearby geography, like stylized soldiers colonizing new territory in a board game. Densely populated dynamic conurbations of money, technological innovation and convenience, it is hard to see the cities of East Asia as what they truly are: necropolises.
Why is this? The East Asian development model, with its gaudy miracle economies that pile up impressive industrialization, innovation, dollar reserves and exports, has a flip side. In export-oriented economies with suppressed domestic consumption (wages are held low and domestic saving encouraged to finance investment), currency controls and artificially depressed currencies, profits end up being plowed into land development, because the domestic consumption economy is too small.
This simple equation has profound implications. A key outcome of a successful export-oriented economy is wild overdevelopment of domestic land, experienced as massive and irrational overbuilding of public and private infrastructure. Japan has become the canonical example of this, with monumental public construction projects including bridges to nowhere, highways that carry a tithe of their rated capacity and village train stations built like shopping malls, all fueled by a tsunami of public debt. Its 1992 construction budget reached US$700 billion, a sum the US defense budget would not reach until over a decade later.
Photo: AFP
In Taiwan, the rivers have been lined with concrete, while housing prices skyrocket even though vacant residences are common. Meanwhile new apartment buildings mushroom across Taiwan’s cities. According to 2020 figures from the Architecture and Urban Research Institute, 62 percent of housing in South Korea consists of apartment buildings.
The Miracle economy is thus really two supernatural events: a highly visible export miracle, and an overdevelopment curse, visible only to locals.
Central to the complex ecosystems of land developers, local gangsters, corrupt local officials, gravel and concrete firms and trucking companies that drive the domestic economy are high-rise apartment buildings, where the money is. Many years ago I was at an expert talk in Taipei in which a speaker estimated that for a developer to break even on a large apartment project, just half the units must be sold, so great are the direct and indirect subsidies available to developers.
Photo: AFP
TOTAL FERTILITY RATE
The forests of residential high-rises in East Asian cities have a simple consequence for the future: across Asia and elsewhere, high-rise apartment buildings are strongly correlated with plummeting birth rates, though scholars continue to debate the reasons.
An excellent piece at Aporia by Daniel Hess lays out the correlation between apartment towers and birth rates.
Photo: Reuters
“High rise apartment towers (as they are usually built these days) are catastrophic for birth rates, and the causes are clear: there is no yard for kids to play in; kids bother the neighbors; and most apartments are too small for families,” he writes.
In suburbs, populations can be relatively dense, but birth rates are much higher, Hess says.
“Consider Sydney and Perth in Australia, where the TFR [total fertility rate] is a healthy 2.0 in the expensive but family-friendly suburbs but is an ultra-low 1.0 in the apartment-centric core.”
Photo: Lo Pei-der, Taipei Times
Asia urbanized, he said, but didn’t build suburbs on the US or Australian models.
The result of this development model is clear. Tokyo, studded with high-rises, had a TFR of .99 in 2023. In Seoul there are several districts with TFRs below 0.5 as of 2023. In central Busan in South Korea one district had a TFR of just 0.32 in 2023, less than half the city’s already low 0.66 overall TFR. South Korea’s overall TFR is around 0.8. Taiwan’s overall TFR is below 0.9. Shanghai has a TFR of just 0.57, according to calculations posted by famed Chinese demographer Yi Fuxian (易富賢) on X. Beijing, at 0.71 is right behind, and Chongqing is closing in on 1.0.
To put those numbers in perspective, at a TFR of 0.8, a population suffers a decline of over 90 percent in just three generations, the lifetime of a single human being. Tokyo is thus not a place that “offers a template” for urban development, as a recent New York Times opinion piece contended. Just the opposite: Tokyo is the place where the population of Japan goes — to die.
The supreme irony of this situation is that the ongoing demographic collapse in the East Asian construction-industrial states is slowly choking their technology export sectors to death. A hidden aspect of the Miracle export economies is slavish devotion of the workers to their tech firms. Traditionally they faced brutal workloads and long hours. The population of dedicated engineers necessary to make the export model work has been gutted by the domestic economy’s apartment-centered development model and the ideals of convenience that underpin it.
LABOR SHORTAGES
Today labor shortages are widespread across the major East Asian economies, partly due to demographics, but also to cultural change. The young do not want the work lives of their parents. Taiwan thus has deep shortages of high-level talent and mid-level professionals.
A 2023 Taipei Times editorial, one of scores of such pieces from the region on labor shortages, describes the situation: “most serious was the shortage of 84,000 mid-level technical workers, which includes technicians and associate professionals, craft and trade workers, as well as plant and machine operators.”
Taiwan hosts 750,000 migrant workers, while Korea has over a million. Even famously xenophobic Japan is starting to import people. That well will dry up in the coming decades, as these workers are drawn from countries whose TFRs are also plummeting.
The East Asian innovation and production juggernaut is living, not on borrowed time, but on borrowed populations. Its development model, lauded by economists and policymakers the world over, is a suicide pact.
There is still time for us to change.
Notes from Central Taiwan is a column written by long-term resident Michael Turton, who provides incisive commentary informed by three decades of living in and writing about his adoptive country. The views expressed here are his own.
A recent report from the Environmental Management Administration of the Ministry of Environment highlights a perennial problem: illegal dumping of construction waste. In Taoyuan’s Yangmei District (楊梅) and Hsinchu’s Longtan District (龍潭) criminals leased 10,000 square meters of farmland, saying they were going to engage in horticulture. They then accepted between 40,000 and 50,000 cubic meters of construction waste from sites in northern Taiwan, charging less than the going rate for disposal, and dumped the waste concrete, tile, metal and glass onto the leased land. Taoyuan District prosecutors charged 33 individuals from seven companies with numerous violations of the law. This
As mega K-pop group BTS returns to the stage after a hiatus of more than three years, one major market is conspicuously missing from its 12-month world tour: China. The omission of one of the group’s biggest fan bases comes as no surprise. In fact, just the opposite would have been huge news. China has blocked most South Korean entertainment since 2016 under an unofficial ban that also restricts movies and the country’s popular TV dramas. For some Chinese, that means flying to Seoul to see their favorite groups perform — as many were expected to do for three shows opening
What is the importance within the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) of the meeting between Xi Jinping (習近平), the leader Chinese Communist Party (CCP), and Cheng Li-wun (鄭麗文), the leader of the KMT? Local media is an excellent guide to determine how important — or unimportant — a news event is to the public. Taiwan has a vast online media ecosystem, and if a news item is gaining traction among readers, editors shift resources in near real time to boost coverage to meet the demand and drive up traffic. Cheng’s China trip is among the top headlines, but by no means
Apr. 13 to Apr. 19 From 17th-century royalty and Presbyterian missionaries to White Terror victims, cultural figures and industrialists, Nanshan Public Cemetery (南山公墓) sprawls across 95 hectares, guarding four centuries of Taiwan’s history. Current estimates show more than 60,000 graves, the earliest dating to 1642. Besides individual tombs, there are also hundreds of family plots, one of which is said to contain around 1,000 remains. As the cemetery occupies valuable land in the heart of Tainan, the government in 2018 began asking families to relocate the graves to make way for development. That
RSS