Brian Chiu (丘博元) echoes many university students when he says he’s frustrated by the lack of internships available.
“After sending out dozens of applications, only one company got back to me,” says the National Chiao-Tung University student. And that internship didn’t pan out.
Yvonne walked into a position at a tech company because of her father’s connections.
Photo: Taipei Times
As with students like her — with family connections — resumes are directly forwarded to human resources departments.
While informational interviews were set up for Yvonne, who didn’t want her full name revealed because it might compromise her father, she says that such a process is “just a formality.” Placements are almost always guaranteed with such referrals.
Another problem for these interns is that many of the positions are unpaid, leading to concerns that they are exploitative.
Photo courtesy of Google
Kiefer Huang (黃子羽) says it makes sense if companies with structured internship programs don’t pay their interns. Huang, who received an unpaid position at a multinational company over the summer, cited the resources needed to train interns as a hidden cost on the company’s side. Even though he did not get paid, he feels his internship experience was “worth it.”
But not everyone is privileged enough to work for free. Students like Chang Hsin-wen (張馨雯), for example, took a full-time unpaid internship while continuing to work part time. But she still felt the experience was worthwhile.
You first have to get your foot in the door, though.
For college students like Chiu internships can fundamentally shape the trajectory of their career paths. However, most universities provide inadequate resources to help students land such opportunities. And, as the example of Yvonne shows, competition for internships is hardly a level playing field. Oftentimes, such opportunities are exclusive to those who know the right person and those who need not worry about paying bills. Amid an economy weakened by the pandemic, students had to reckon with drastically different realities.
The Taipei Times interviewed 17 college students who attempted to seek internship opportunities this summer. Seven of them managed to secure an internship, while others were left without an offer by the start of their summer breaks.
Among the seven interviewees who interned this summer, all but one obtained their opportunities through family connections.
PRESSURE
When asked about their motivation to pursue internships, many cited their degree requirements. However, most found their school’s career center to be of little use.
“While many schools do provide pipelines to intern at certain companies, those opportunities are not particularly appealing to the students. There’s a mismatch between what students are interested in pursuing and what their schools offer,” says Claire Ke (柯友涵), a Radio & Television student at National Taiwan University of Arts who applied for three internships.
Ke received one offer, but had to decline it because it was for an entire year and could only devote time to a summer internship.
Instead, it is far more common for students to be left navigating the corporate world on their own, scavenging for the scarce openings scattered across job banks like 104 and 1111, Web sites like Blink and CakeResume and numerous private Facebook groups.
Peer pressure is also cited as a deciding factor: fear of lagging behind when students see that their peers have begun looking for internships.
The past decade has seen the emergence of the trend for college students to start looking for internship opportunities early, which can be as early as the summer before freshman year, as one of our interviewees reported. Internships have now become the new entry-level jobs. Compared to previous generations, the timeline for entering the job market has been significantly accelerated.
TRIVIAL TASKS
With very few internship opportunities openly advertised, competition for internships is fierce. It is not uncommon for acceptance rates to hover around single digits. This is consistent with the figures released last year by Line, with an acceptance rate of 0.3 percent, and Acer, one percent.
Yet even when students like Yvonne manage to secure internships, these opportunities do not necessarily guarantee an enriching experience. When the kids of the management’s friends come into the office, the managers often struggle to find jobs for them to do.
“I was often given trivial tasks or left with nothing to do,” Yvonne says. She added that even after asking for more work, she was ignored.
Yvonne’s experience reflects the peculiarity of internships in Taiwan. Not established to benefit the companies who take on interns, many opportunities are created in an ad-hoc fashion as a service to personal connections. These doors are never open to those without connections to the management. And even for those who are fortunate enough to get their foot in the door, oftentimes, such programs are not designed for personal growth.
Altogether, these practices continue to perpetuate the vicious cycle of the overemphasis on connections over merit.
Johnson Chou (周昱程), a Taiwanese student studying in China who applied for nine internships through 104, didn’t hear back from any of them.
“Climbing the corporate ladder is like scaling a mountain. You don’t get anywhere without putting in the effort,” he says. “However, without the right equipment, you are not even going to find the trailhead,” Chou said.
Last week saw a momentary spark in the election season, when Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) presidential candidate Hou You-yi (侯友宜) and Taiwan People’s Party Chairman and presidential candidate Ko Wen-je (柯文哲) attempted to form a joint ticket, ostensibly to defeat the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) and its candidate Vice President William Lai (賴清德). This mating of massive egos was arranged by longtime KMT stalwart and former president Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九). The deal predictably fell apart, though as of this writing — Thursday — there was still a chance for an 11th hour recovery. (Editor’s note: it didn’t happen.) Many people
Lesley Hughes says most climate change scientists are good at partitioning off bits of their brain. “You put all the negative stuff in a little box and you put a wall around it and you try to keep going,” she says. But in the record-breaking year that 2023 has become, some of the dread and grief has broken out of Hughes’s mental box and vaulted the wall. There have been sleepless nights, where she’s pondered the future for her family, the natural places she loves and for the species being lost. “I do grieve,” the ecologist says at her home on Sydney’s lower north
In the heart of Taipei at Legacy — a venue renowned for hosting diverse musical acts — Alvvays, a Grammy-nominated ensemble from Canada, delivered a compelling performance last week. With a fusion of indie-dream pop and shoegaze influences, Alvvays enthralled the audience with their catchy, introspective melodies and refined stage presence. Legacy, brimming with subdued anticipation, served as the ideal setting for Alvvays’ show. Almost reaching its full capacity, the venue buzzed with excitement as the band took the stage. Off Time Production, the local organizers, infused a unique touch by having a hipster pizzeria, Under The Bridge, cater the event.
On a dark November afternoon at Southampton’s City Farm, the animals are going about their business. They are all rescues. Penny the pig, a clutch of former battery farm chickens, three pygmy goats and Salvatore the cane snake, so orange and shiny he looks as though he is glowing from within as he twines around my arm in loving, even sensual embrace. All little miracles in their own right. But none so strange as the dull-looking brown shells in the glass tank in the corner. “Who’s that in there?” I ask Hannah, in whose charge they lie. “They’re African land snails”,