Taiwan’s cosmetic medicine market has developed rapidly in recent years, but behind the glamorous packaging and commercial rhetoric lies a critical risk that is little known to the public — large numbers of “direct-entry” physicians, doctors who lack clinical training and emergency care experience, are entering the field.
This is not a normal flow of medical personnel, but the result of a major loophole that formed within Taiwan’s physician training system as a result of previous reforms to medical education. If the law is not amended in time to correct this, it would continue to endanger patient safety, erode medical professionalism and leave society to bear the costs.
In 2013, Taiwan’s seven-year undergraduate medical education program was shortened to six years, with the original seventh year clinical internship being replaced by the two-year post-graduate clinical training program, which had previously lasted for one year. However, because regulations at the time did not explicitly prohibit physicians who had not yet completed post-graduate training from performing medical procedures, anyone who obtained a medical license could be directly hired by medical institutions. Among the first cohort of six-year medical school graduates in 2019, some physicians who had never undergone post-graduate clinical training went straight into cosmetic medicine. This created the phenomenon of “direct entry” cosmetic surgeons.
The issue with these direct-entry cosmetic surgeons is that, up until graduation, they have never actually worked on the front lines of clinical care — they have not learned to identify danger signs in the emergency room, nor have they gained experience managing bleeding or infection, using anesthesia or responding to sudden complications. They have never trained in obstetrics or gynecology, pediatrics, surgery or internal medicine. They lack practical experience in the complexities of medical practice, yet they are nevertheless permitted to perform invasive medical procedures such as injections, liposuction and phototherapy — all of which could lead to shock or serious injury. This poses a significant risk to medical safety and quality.
An additional side effect of this is that these physicians are drawn to the high salaries offered by cosmetic clinics, which contributes to severe shortages in obstetrics and gynecology, pediatrics, internal medicine and rural healthcare. This creates an abnormal siphoning of medical personnel and undermines the overall medical ecosystem.
The direct-entry phenomenon is an abnormality in the medical system caused by an incomplete regulatory framework. In this context, the Ministry of Health and Welfare this month announced draft amendments to the Regulations for Using Specialized Equipment for Medical Examinations (特定醫療技術檢查檢驗醫療儀器施行或使用管理辦法). The revisions include different qualification criteria for physicians performing cosmetic surgery depending on risk, and would require new physicians to finish two years of post-graduate training to qualify as cosmetic surgeons. This is not some sort of punishment, but rather a correction of the loophole left over from earlier reforms to medical education.
Cosmetic medicine is a medical practice, and the gap between a doctor being able to perform a procedure and being able to take responsibility for it lies in the clinical competencies built through post-graduate training. Only by ensuring that every new physician entering the field of cosmetic medicine has completed full clinical training could Taiwan’s cosmetic medicine industry return to its medical foundations, rather than continuing to slide into a chaotic state characterized by high risks and commercialization. We support amending the law to seal this institutional loophole, as it is an essential step to protect patients, uphold medical professionalism and restore fairness in the medical system.
Huang Sue-ying is the founder of Taiwan Women’s Link.
Translated by Kyra Gustavsen
In Kaohsiung, you can find an old dojo built by the Japanese overlooking the seaside. There, a master of blade martial arts is the custodian of the sword of the legendary Japanese swordsman Musashi. The Japanese developed Kaohsiung. There was little to show before they arrived. The city does not define itself as a “Japanese” place, but it does not anchor its identity in anything that would oppose Japan, such as revanchism — a barbaric ideology that has only ever generated suffering — or national pride. The residents of Kaohsiung are too pragmatic for that. The city might have become a wonderful
Urban prosperity does not always begin with industrial parks or investment briefings — sometimes, it begins overnight, when the heartbeats of 170,000 people land in a stadium, shaking the ground like an invisible wave of urban renewal. During the two nights that K-pop group Twice performed in Kaohsiung last weekend, the city was not just a city. Instead, it felt like a massive body that had just woken up — the MRT’s blood flow sped up, the night markets’ sense of smell remained active until 4am and the shopping districts swelled as if injected with oxygen. This was not a
Tokyo-Beijing relations have been rapidly deteriorating over the past two weeks as China tries to punish Japan over Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi’s remarks about Taiwan earlier this month, and the off-ramp to this conflict is yet to be seen. Takaichi saying that a “Taiwan contingency” could cause a “situation threatening Japan’s survival” — which would allow Japan to act in self-defense — has drawn Beijing’s ire and sparked retaliatory measures. Her remark did not gain public attention until Chinese Consul General in Osaka Xue Jian (薛劍) made an apparent threat to behead her. The two sides lodged protests against each
There has been much catastrophizing in Taiwan recently about America becoming more unreliable as a bulwark against Chinese pressure. Some of this has been sparked by debates in Washington about whether the United States should defend Taiwan in event of conflict. There also were understandable anxieties about whether President Trump would sacrifice Taiwan’s interests for a trade deal when he sat down with President Xi (習近平) in late October. On top of that, Taiwan’s opposition political leaders have sought to score political points by attacking the Lai (賴清德) administration for mishandling relations with the United States. Part of this budding anxiety
RSS