Kaohsiung City Councilor Jane Lee (李眉蓁) — the Chinese Nationalist Party’s (KMT) candidate in the Kaohsiung mayoral by-election — has been accused of plagiarism and violating academic ethics after it was discovered that her master’s thesis was almost identical to Minister of Overseas Community Affairs Tung Chen-yuan’s (童振源) paper titled Political and Economic Exchanges Across the Taiwan Strait.
When the case was first reported, Lee argued that as National Sun Yat-sen University (NSYSU), which approved her work, has “very high standards,” she did not think there was any problem with her thesis, as it had passed a university review.
However, the university late last year revoked a graduate degree issued in 2018 due to plagiarism and the paper of one of the university’s researchers published in an international academic journal early this year was retracted in May for violating academic ethics.
Simply saying that the university has “very high standards” is clearly not sufficient to prove that there is no problem with her thesis.
Higher education in Taiwan has been haunted by plagiarism for years. Several papers published by Taiwanese professors have been retracted in just the past few months.
The Ministry of Education and the Ministry of Science and Technology have proposed preventive measures over the past decade to fight academic plagiarism, but their efforts seem to have been in vain.
A look into the cause of the problem shows that many Taiwanese universities would rather settle a plagiarism dispute quietly.
Some colleges and universities even have so-called “plagiarism clans.” For example, even if a graduate student copies their adviser’s doctoral dissertation in their own thesis, the student might still be able to pass the oral defense and obtain the degree if their adviser is on the oral defense committee.
Reports of such cases are often presented on the Internet, but the authorities have failed to investigate them thoroughly.
The argument that NSYSU has “very high standards” is challenged by the fact that theses violate academic ethics, but its reputation has not been shattered, as it has not covered up the truth in the Lee situation in an attempt to save face.
Amid the responses of other local universities to plagiarism, NSYSU taking responsibility for passing a thesis that violated academic ethics by revoking the degree is a rare example of good standards. In doing so, the institute displayed its academic conscience and moral courage, and it is doing a better job than education authorities.
Lee on Thursday last week finally issued a public apology, saying that she would fully respect the results of an investigation by her alma mater.
Hopefully, the university will maintain its standards as it investigates the issue, which would help address problems caused by negligence that led it to lose control of the quality of a student’s knowledge and thesis.
By doing so, it would show that it indeed has “very high standards.”
Niu Ming is a university researcher.
Translated by Eddy Chang
As India’s six-week-long general election grinds past the halfway mark, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s messaging has shifted from confident to shrill. After the first couple of phases of polling showed a 3 percentage point drop in turnout, Modi and his party leaders have largely stopped promoting their accomplishments of the past 10 years — or, for that matter, the “Modi guarantees” offered in the Bharatiya Janata Party’s (BJP) manifesto for the next five. Instead, making the majority Hindu population fear and loathe Muslims seems to be the BJP’s preferred talking point. Modi went on the offensive in an April 21
As Ukraine leads the global fight for democracy, Taiwan, facing a potential war with China, should draw lessons from Ukraine’s cyberwarfare success. Taiwan has been enhancing its arsenal with advanced weapons from the West in anticipation of a possible full-scale invasion. However, Taipei should also consider Ukraine’s effective digital warfare, notably the “IT [information technology] Army,” a decentralized force instrumental in Kyiv’s cybercampaigns. In February 2022, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine marked the onset of a significant cyberwar, where fears of a “digital Pearl Harbor” in Ukraine were unmet, thanks to robust cyberdefenses backed by Western public and private support. This led
Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) is attempting to create an alternative international world order to the US-dominated model. China has benefited hugely from the current order since former Chinese leader Deng Xiaoping (鄧小平) opened up its economy five decades ago. Countries can be categorized as continental or maritime, and to a great degree this determines their optimum foreign policy. China is continental, as is Russia. The US initially followed a continental foreign policy, before it settled on a maritime model. The British empire was so successful because a tiny island kingdom built a formidable naval presence. The US-dominated world order, stabilized by
With the addition this year of Sweden and last year Finland to NATO, the Baltic Sea has been dubbed a “NATO lake” by some analysts. A glance at a map shows that is largely (but not completely) true — the coastline has a couple of slivers of Russian territory. The rest of the coastal littoral is in NATO hands: Sweden, Finland, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Germany and Denmark. Russia controls a bit of coast between Lithuania and Poland because of its strange enclave of Kaliningrad. Russian President Vladimir Putin remains in control of the far eastern corner of the Baltic Sea