As racial justice protests have swept the US, leading retailers have taken to social media to proclaim their commitment to equality.
However, such statements decrying racism in the wake of the George Floyd killing have been met with incredulity by some non-white customers, who recount instances of being quizzed by sales staff on how they make their money or watched “through the shelves” by security, as one shopper put it on Instagram.
Racial profiling — which inspired the hashtag #shoppingwhileblack — has proven a nettlesome problem that the industry has largely avoided directly engaging in the past few days, even as retailers come out publicly to condemn racism and promise greater diversity in their leadership.
Photo: AFP
Black and Hispanic shoppers have questioned companies’ sincerity, saying that even if they have not been stopped by security guards, they feel routinely surveilled and unwelcome in stores in ways that white people do not.
The tension has in the past resulted in retailers making major payouts to settle profiling lawsuits. In one of the most well-publicized incidents, Starbucks Corp closed 8,000 stores for a day to give employees training on how to avoid implicit bias after the April 2018 arrest of two black men at a Philadelphia store.
Jerome Williams, a business professor at Rutgers University, recalled an episode in the 1980s when three of his children failed to meet back up during a shopping outing. After much worry, Williams discovered they were detained by mall security, who deemed the kids suspicious because they were wearing new shirts.
Besides the encounter itself, Williams was troubled by white work colleagues who told him the incident was no big deal.
Since then, “there has been tremendous progress, but we have not eliminated all of the problem,” said Williams, who advises retailers on addressing profiling.
Civil rights advocates express hope that nationwide racial justice protests lead to change not just in policing, but in other realms where the US has fallen short of its stated ideals.
“Corporate leaders must do a lot more than issue press statements condemning racism,” said Dariely Rodriguez, director of the economic justice project at the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law.
“They must embrace long-standing calls by advocates to dismantle structural racism” by addressing wage discrimination, promoting non-white employees and “eradicating racial discrimination against black customers and workers,” she said.
Late on Wednesday, Walmart Inc said on Twitter that it would stop placing multicultural hair and beauty products in locked cases after a Denver news report interviewed consumers who complained that the practice was discriminatory.
To counter shoplifting, which costs the industry billions of US dollars each year, retailers emphasize profiling — but only for behavior, not race, said Read Hayes, director of the Loss Prevention Research Council, an industry-backed research group.
Employee manuals outline suspicious behavior: customers who walk the perimeter of the store, avoid eye contact, or canvass for security cameras. In many cases, companies explicitly say not to profile by race, Hayes said.
He believes racial profiling still happens on an “isolated” basis, adding that retailers have every incentive to create a welcoming environment for customers.
“It’s so taboo to do any of these things, but there are still individuals who make mistakes,” he said.
In 2014, New York state fined the department store Macy’s Inc US$650,000 and required an independent monitor for three years after an investigation showed that the chain had apprehended and falsely accused non-white customers at much higher rates than white customers.
In May 2018, shortly after the Starbucks incident, Nordstrom Rack flew its president to St Louis to apologize to three young black men who were wrongly accused of shoplifting.
The company said employees had not followed procedures and should not have called the police.
Macy’s and Nordstrom have condemned the Floyd killing and promised greater diversity in leadership and suppliers. Neither company responded to requests for interviews.
Experts who advise retailers have said that even when there is a will to eliminate bias, doing so is not straightforward.
Companies sometimes link security guards’ performance evaluations to apprehensions, and some retailers lack robust systems for resolving customers’ complaints of profiling.
Shaun Gabbidon, a professor at Penn State Harrisburg who has authored a book on the history of profiling, said that retailers have ignored his recommendations to release data on customer apprehensions, which could show if there is racial disparity.
“The problem is when you have a high-profile incident, no one has enough data to say if this is just a blip,” he said.
Discussing race can be fraught and should be done in a way that encourages employees to open up and not fear reprisal, experts have said.
“There’s no shame in having biases,” but it’s important to recognize and not act on them, said Anne-Marie Hakstian, a professor at Salem State University.
ASML Holding NV’s new advanced chip machines have a daunting price tag, said Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電), one of the Dutch company’s biggest clients. “The cost is very high,” TSMC senior vice president Kevin Zhang (張曉強) said at a technology symposium in Amsterdam on Tuesday, referring to ASML’s latest system known as high-NA extreme ultraviolet (EUV). “I like the high-NA EUV’s capability, but I don’t like the sticker price,” Zhang said. ASML’s new chip machine can imprint semiconductors with lines that are just 8 nanometers thick — 1.7 times smaller than the previous generation. The machines cost 350 million euros (US$378 million)
Apple Inc has closed in on an agreement with OpenAI to use the start-up’s technology on the iPhone, part of a broader push to bring artificial intelligence (AI) features to its devices, people familiar with the matter said. The two sides have been finalizing terms for a pact to use ChatGPT features in Apple’s iOS 18, the next iPhone operating system, said the people, who asked not to be identified because the situation is private. Apple also has held talks with Alphabet Inc’s Google about licensing its Gemini chatbot. Those discussions have not led to an agreement, but are ongoing. An OpenAI
INSATIABLE: Almost all AI innovators are working with the chipmaker to address the rapidly growing AI-related demand for energy-efficient computing power, the CEO said Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) yesterday reported about 60 percent annual growth in revenue for last month, benefiting from rapidly growing demand for artificial intelligence (AI) and high-performance computing applications. Revenue last month expanded to NT$236.02 billion (US$7.28 billion), compared with NT$147.9 billion in April last year, the second-highest level in company history, TSMC said in a statement. On a monthly basis, revenue surged 20.9 percent, from NT$195.21 billion in March. As AI-related applications continue to show strong growth, TSMC expects revenue to expand about 27.6 percent year-on-year during the current quarter to between US$19.6 billion and US$20.4 billion. That would
‘FULL SUPPORT’: Kumamoto Governor Takashi Kimura said he hopes more companies would settle in the prefecture to create an area similar to Taiwan’s Hsinchu Science Park The newly elected governor of Japan’s Kumamoto Prefecture said he is ready to ensure wide-ranging support to woo Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) to build its third Japanese chip factory there. Concerns of groundwater shortages when TSMC’s two plants begin operations in the prefecture’s Kikuyo have spurred discussions about the possibility of tapping unused dam water, Kumamoto Governor Takashi Kimura said in an interview on Saturday. While Kimura said talks about a third plant have yet to occur, Bloomberg had reported TSMC is already considering its third Japanese fab — also in Kumamoto — which would make more advanced chips. “We are