Mon, Nov 21, 2005 - Page 6 News List

Muslim Brotherhood wins strong standing in Egypt


A surprise showing has given the Muslim Brotherhood its strongest political foothold ever heading into the second round of Egypt's parliamentary elections yesterday -- a vote that is hinting at what democracy might look like in the Arab world's largest country.

Secularists and Christians, however, were unsettled by the Brotherhood's showing in the first round where the country's oldest Islamic fundamentalist group took 34 seats, doubling its presence in parliament.

The victories have established the Brotherhood as the leader of the opposition and have proven what the government has always feared: that the banned group is popular among Egyptians despite -- or because of -- frequent crackdowns and the government's media campaign against it.

The unanswered question remains: Does the Brotherhood's success stem from its platform -- summed up in its slogan, "Islam is the solution," vague but appealing to some in conservative Egypt -- or to widespread discontent with President Hosni Mubarak's government?

Stunned by its own showing, the Brotherhood expected to win more in yesterday's vote and the Dec. 1 third round, which are being held in provinces that include its traditional strongholds.

Some members of the Coptic Christian community find it alarming that the Brotherhood is gaining ground.

Georget Qelliny, a Copt and a former lawmaker, said: "What worries me is the [Brotherhood's] vague call for implementing Islamic law."

She added she was skeptical of the Brotherhood's pledge to protect the rights of all citizens.

Rafik Habib, an Evangelical Coptic Christian and social scientist, said his co-religionists were worried about the Brotherhood's slogan, "Islam is the solution." But Habib, who has studied and written extensively about the group, discounted such fears.

"The Brotherhood was never anti-Coptic ... It's important to open a real dialogue with Brotherhood, and the Islamic trend in general," he said.

Secular observers such as Magdi el-Galad, the editor of the independent daily al-Masry al-Youm, was not so sanguine.

In a recent column he opined that the Mubarak government was allowing the Brotherhood to make non-threatening political gains against the ruling National Democratic Party as part of its campaign to "wave with the `Islamist scare' once again ... without taking into consideration the repercussions, and without being able to put the `scare' back in the bottle."

"Whatever is the secret or the reason, what is happening now puts Egypt on edge of danger," he warned.

But secular pro-democracy activist Saad Eddin Ibrahim says greater freedoms in Egypt means recognizing the Brotherhood's influence. He wrote a controversial column entitled "Islam can vote, if we let it."

"I know Copts, women are alarmed, the US will be concerned," Ibrahim said. He said there is no reason for that as "it's a very pragmatic group."

"If we are true democrats, we have to accept the outcome of elections," said Ibrahim, scoffing at the group's critics that say, if they come to power, this will be the last elections.

"This is nonsense, the group has never been in power, never tested,'' he added.

The US has been urging Mubarak, its steadfast ally in the Middle East, to allow greater democracy in a country he has ruled nearly unquestioned for 24 years. But US officials are also eyeing the Brotherhood with concern

This story has been viewed 4219 times.

Comments will be moderated. Keep comments relevant to the article. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned. Final decision will be at the discretion of the Taipei Times.

TOP top