Wed, May 25, 2005 - Page 5 News List

Canberra firm over detention farce


The Australian government yesterday stood firmly behind its controversial policy of mandatory detention for illegal immigrants, despite a string of scandals in which its citizens have been accidentally deported and jailed.

Immigration Minister Amanda Vanstone rejected calls to soften the conservative government's immigration policies, telling reporters that the mandatory detention policy would remain.

"We have a policy of mandatory detention," Vanstone said. "We are absolutely committed to stopping people smugglers bringing people to Australia through the back door."

Speaking in parliament, Prime Minister John Howard also defended the policy and said Vanstone had his full support despite calls for her resignation.

But not all government backers were convinced.

A lawmaker from Howard's Liberal Party, Petro Georgiou, said he would submit bills this week that would require the release of women, children and long-term detainees from immigration camps.

The issue has received renewed coverage following reports that Australian national Vivian Alvarez, 42, was wrongly deported to the Philippines four years ago and was only found earlier this month in a hospice for the dying there.

A second Australian resident, German-born Cornelia Rau, has also said she will seek compensation for her wrongful 10-month detention as an illegal alien.

Speaking at a press conference in Adelaide on Monday, Rau said she had been mistreated while in custody, at one point fearing for her life.

The former Qantas first-class flight attendant said that at the Baxter immigration centre she was "locked up in a cage like a caged animal."

"I think this country has a lot of problems for the poor people who've wanted to actually come here as refugees," she said.

A closed inquiry into the Rau case has been extended to include those of Alvarez and 32 other cases of wrongful detention, but the government has rejected calls for a full investigation of the cases.

Vanstone said the Alvarez and Rau cases were unique because both had unusual circumstances.

She said that the negative publicity could damage Australia's reputation, but the government believed its policy was correct.

"We will take those most in need, we will put them first ... doing it the way we do it is harder," she said. "We have to put up with a lot of criticism and a lot of misunderstanding.

"But when I go to sleep at night and I say to myself `we're remaining strong against people smugglers, and we're taking those most in need,' I sleep like a baby," she said.

This story has been viewed 2982 times.

Comments will be moderated. Keep comments relevant to the article. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned. Final decision will be at the discretion of the Taipei Times.

TOP top