Wed, Feb 08, 2017 - Page 3 News List

Groups question tests on students’ pollutant levels

EXPERT FOR RENT?The professor who conducted the examinations has had several studies commissioned by Formosa Petrochemical Corp, an advocate said

By Lee I-chia  /  Staff reporter

Environmental groups yesterday protested in front of the Health Promotion Administration’s (HPA) building in Taipei, questioning the objectivity of health examinations conducted on 61 students of Ciaotou Elementary School’s Syucuo (許厝) branch, who were transferred to the main campus last semester to prevent exposure to pollutants.

The Syucuo students were transferred to the main branch last year due to the result of a three-year-study conducted by the National Health Research Institutes (NHRI) that found elevated levels of thiodiglycolic acid (TdGA) in their urine.

As high TdGA levels are an indicator of exposure to the carcinogen vinyl chloride monomer, environmental groups and parents suspect pollutants from Formosa Petrochemical Corp’s naphtha cracker in Yunlin County’s Mailiao Township (麥寮) — located only 900m from the Syucuo campus — to be the cause of the elevated levels.

However, after the Syucuo students had studied for a semester on the main campus — 5.5km from the cracker — examinations commissioned by the HPA and led by National Cheng Kung University professor Lee Ching-chang (李俊璋) found that the students’ urine contained even higher TdGA levels than previously.

After Lee’s research team suggested that the increased urinary TdGA levels might have been caused by increased consumption of eggs, a specialist meeting was held at the HPA yesterday morning to discuss the examination results.

Holding a banner reading “protect children’s health, reject wrongful study,” more than a dozen representatives from the groups protested against Lee’s test, and urged the HPA not to transfer the students back to the Syucuo campus.

Lee has conducted several studies commissioned by Formosa Petrochemical Corp, so the impartiality of the urine examinations is questionable, Taiwan Healthy Air Action Alliance director Yang Joe-ming (楊澤民) said, adding that Lee’s examination methods were over-simple and did not take environmental variables into consideration.

“The findings do not invalidate the results of the NHRI’s long-term study … he could not explain why the students’ urinary TdGA levels were even higher in some students,” Yunlin County Environmental Protection Union chairman Chang Tsu-chien (張子見) said. “The naphtha cracker is still a factor affecting their levels, and the risk to their health still exists.”

After the meeting, HPA Director Wang Ying-wei (王英偉) said that specialists have differing opinions on whether the students’ increased TdGA levels were caused by eggs, but added that he made it clear at the beginning of the meeting that the HPA would not make a reccomendation on whether the students should be transferred.

He said urinary TdGA levels can also be affected by having hepatitis B, vitamin consumption, breathing in secondhand cigarette smoke and other factors.

The decision to transfer the students was taken by the Cabinet last semester, so the local government plans to discuss the central government further, Yunlin County Commissioner Lee Chin-yung (李進勇) told reporters.

This story has been viewed 3228 times.

Comments will be moderated. Keep comments relevant to the article. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned. Final decision will be at the discretion of the Taipei Times.

TOP top