Mon, Apr 12, 2010 page3

• Political row in US over Goodwin Liu

  SHORTLIST If confirmed over the objections of Republicans, Goodwin Liu could potentially become the first Asian-American US Supreme Court judge

  • By William Lowther / STAFF REPORTER
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  A major political row is brewing over US President Barack Obama’s nomination of law professor Goodwin Liu (劉弘威) — the son of Taiwanese immigrants — to be a judge at the powerful San Francisco-based appeals court.

  The nomination must be approved by the US Senate and conservative Republicans — the politicians who are generally most friendly toward Taiwan — are dead set against him as they see the 39-year-old Liu, the assistant dean and law professor at the University of California at Berkeley, as an extreme liberal who would move the US toward the political left.

  “He is far outside the mainstream of American jurisprudence,” said Senator Jeff Sessions of Alabama, the senior Republican on the Senate Judiciary Committee.

  UNUSUAL

  What makes the nomination far more important than is usually the case are reports that if Liu is confirmed he would automatically go onto Obama’s shortlist for a seat on the US Supreme Court.

  The Washington Post and other leading US newspapers said Liu has already “been discussed as the first person of Asian descent who could be chosen for the Supreme Court.”

  If that happened and he was confirmed as a Supreme Court justice, he would become the most powerful person of Taiwanese descent in US history.

  Liu’s parents are both active in the US Taiwanese community and are members of the Formosa Association for Public Affairs, which supports freedom and independence for Taiwan and peaceful coexistence with China as a friendly neighbor.

  Senate hearings on Liu’s confirmation will open this week and are certain to be both controversial and difficult.

  The situation has become even more tense because of the announcement by Justice John Paul Stevens on Friday that he would retire from the Supreme Court later this year.

  TEST

  While Liu is not a candidate for Stevens’ seat, Republican senators will use his confirmation hearings as a testing ground for challenges to Obama’s next Supreme Court nominee if that nominee is another strong liberal as expected.

  It is more than likely that another member of the Court — Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg — will retire while Obama is still in power.

  Providing Liu makes it through confirmation hearings for the 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals — serving California, Arizona, Nevada, Oregon, Washington, Idaho, Hawaii and Montana — he would be a leading candidate for Ginsburg’s seat.

  The Washington Times said last week that Liu’s nomination hearings would be “a test of whether President Obama can win confirmation for an unabashed liberal.”

  All seven Republicans on the Senate Judiciary Committee have asked the Democratic chairman, Senator Patrick Leahy of Vermont, to postpone the hearings and he has refused.

  QUESTIONS

  The Republicans claim that Liu has not answered their preliminary questions and that he may be intentionally hiding information on his liberal background.

  While the hearing process is underway, Liu and those close to him have been asked not to grant interviews.

  A former Rhodes Scholar and Yale University graduate, Liu is widely regarded as having a brilliant legal mind.

  “I can easily imagine him as a Supreme Court nominee,” said Erwin Chemerinsky, dean of the law school at the University of California at Irvine.

  In a scathing letter to Leahy, however, the Republicans said: “At best, this nominee’s extraordinary disregard for the Committee’s constitutional role demonstrates incompetence; at worst, it creates the impression that he knowingly attempted to hide his most controversial work from the Committee.”

  The letter said that Liu failed to answer all of the initial questions on a series of forms sent to him by the Republicans.

  “Professor Liu’s unwillingness to take seriously his obligation to complete these basic forms is potentially disqualifying and has placed his nomination in jeopardy,” it added.

  Leahy said the Democrats were prepared to fight for Liu’s nomination.

  “I had hoped that in this new year, we could put political rancor aside and come together to openly and fairly debate President Obama’s qualified judicial nominees,” he said. “I am disappointed that, instead, we have seen the same delays and obstructionist approach.”

  Liu clerked for Ginsburg at the Supreme Court, worked in the administration of former US president Bill Clinton and was active in education reform.

  He won a distinguished teaching award at the University of California.

  The American Bar Association has given him its highest approval rating.

  Not one of the 175 judges now serving on the appeals courts is Asian-American.

  “He is an outspoken advocate of liberal causes, including same-sex marriage and affirmative action,” the Washington Post said.
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Taiwan to produce more than 1,200 new missiles

  • 2

    Taiwan in tsunami threat zone after major earthquake in Philippines

  • 3

    HSBC doubles down on Taiwan

  • 4

    Taiwan firms eye Philippines amid shift to non-China supply chains: CIER

  • 5

    Taiwan wants bilingual, AI-ready graduates — but tests for yesteryear